Netherworld III: Final Judgment [Concluded]

[Romanic]

vote: Fluffy

It's a serious vote. Memes are fun but not helpful, and Fluffy choose not to contribute differently so I'm happy to force a claim out of him, or even lynch him.

[Zack]

vote: Fluffy

It's a serious vote. Memes are fun but not helpful, and Fluffy choose not to contribute differently so I'm happy to force a claim out of him, or even lynch him.

This is the second day in a row you're trying to get fluffy lynched based on an extremely flimsy, silly case.

Why aren't you trying to search for scum, Romanic? Do you really think fluffy is scum? If not, don't vote for him.

Vote: Romanic

As for fluffy, it would be nice if you actually contribute for once. Romanic has a valid point in that regard. No offense, but posting nothing but memes isn't particularly helpful.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Why aren't you trying to search for scum, Romanic? Do you really think fluffy is scum? If not, don't vote for him.

No, it's not searching for scum, but it doesn't make the case any less valid. Think of the Fluffy lynch as clearing away underbrush with a machete before ultimately walking the trail.

[White_eyes:D]

Nice text wall there guys but I think Earthling has it right with a "He/She said argument" all in all.

My spirit would be broken if glyphz was mafia for the fourth time and I didn't follow up at all.

Vote:glyphz

Isn't Fluffy going to post more, not less if we lynch him GH?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Well yeah, probably, but they won't have any effect and we won't need to keep them in mind when it comes down to the end.

[Double A]

Why would a player with no ability send in orders and then appear in the write-up?

Ask TwilightBlade. It was a joke about him, after all.

Vote double A

All that maybe and possibly make me think that is a mafia trying to appear town when in fact he has p.i.s. Most likely is the one that screams for me since when he is proven correct in his ideas he can say he told us all

If I was mafia trying to appear as town I'd sit on my hands and vote randomly like I usually do. Whenever I actually try to play the game, all I get is a vote or three. It's a wonder I'm trying at all.

1)

2) If this game is going to be decided by some pro-town network that discusses things in private and decides the game by voting in block, then it will be very boring for those not included in the pro-town network.

3) Pro-town networks haven't helped town much in previous games.

4) Pro-town networks get infiltrated all the time.

5) Pro-town network = BORING.

Double A is more interesting.

1-5 is exactly what I'd expect of Andres, but really, why so much interest on me?

Thank God I am still alive !

Fluffy but more discreet. I'm real surprised no one actually quoted this before, due to Warman's penchant for hiding in plain sight.

vote: Fluffy

It's a serious vote. Memes are fun but not helpful, and Fluffy choose not to contribute differently so I'm happy to force a claim out of him, or even lynch him.

Speaking out of experience, I'm inclined to agree. vote: Fluffy

I'd rather have Fluffy lynched than you, for sure. You and Believer are likely two Townies lashing at each other, as it's usually the case for similar situations. None of you have a good argument against the other (imo) and what was said in private, but not quoted, discussion is hardly significant to me. I've seen how ATPG can distort my sentences when he's Town, in the last game.

glyphz's case is thin, and I'm waiting for him to react, before saying why I disagree. Not going to give him ammo when, if he's scum, he could trip and give himself away with a scummy reply.

As for Double A, bah - the case is built on a choice of words. I could probably pressure Double A as I'm doing with Fluffy, both being spammers.

A thin case is slightly better than no case (and yes I realize the situational irony). First "case" is just a shouting match going nowhere, so I'm going to wait on glyphz and see what he does before I change my vote.

The main reason I quoted this post is so I can say that I'm actually not going to spam it up like I usually do during this game.

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

Vote:Double A

Meanie .

[SoulBlade]

vote: Fluffy
Alive fluffiniess is still suspicious.

[Zack]

This makes me angry. Does anyone actually care about catching scum?

[Zack]

No, it's not searching for scum, but it doesn't make the case any less valid. Think of the Fluffy lynch as clearing away underbrush with a machete before ultimately walking the trail.

The lynch is the town's best weapon. It's the only way for the town as a whole to actively try and kill scumbags and it's the most effective way. Lynches shouldn't EVER be wasted for something as silly as "clearing away underbrush."

Why do you think mafia are always so eager to lynch lurkers? Because it's an easy way to distract the town from lynching the actual mafia, and nothing gets accomplished! And the mafia don't have to pretend like they're searching for scum, or build cases, or anything like that. Lynching lurkers is easy, and it's largely unproductive. That's why mafia love it.

The fluffy bandwagon today is a mafioso's dream. It's not searching for scum, but merely eliminating someone perceived to be distracting and annoying.

FoS: Everyone on the fluffywagon.

[Yaropolk]

3 TheLastDays (DIY, Believer, Earthling)
3 Double A (Andres, Capt Blackadder, DE)
3 glyphz (Renata, dcmort, W_e)
5 Fluffy (Chaotix, Romanic, jh, GH, TLD)
1 ATPG (Yaropolk)
1 Romanic (zack)
1 TLD (Riedquat)

Too many votes on Fluffy, can someone switch to glyphz.

Edit: I almost forgot my tribute to Athena:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote: TheFluffyOne

I love you, but I must KILL you!

[thefluffyone93]

Vote: TheFluffyOne

I love you, but I must KILL you!

.........
You make me want to cry, Pizza.
What have I ever done to you?

Oh wait...........
Yeah, I guess you can do that.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Woah, I have been away. When I voted for Fluffy, it was Fluffy 5, others less....

There's a whole other page.... it's like a.... a.... anotherworld.

[Tratorix]

Vote: TheFluffyOne

I love you, but I must KILL you!

Thats not good, you tied the vote!

[TheLastDays]

We might have won Mafia X had we dealt with lurkers more consequently.

[Andres]

This is the second day in a row you're trying to get fluffy lynched based on an extremely flimsy, silly case.

Why aren't you trying to search for scum, Romanic? Do you really think fluffy is scum? If not, don't vote for him.

Vote: Romanic

As for fluffy, it would be nice if you actually contribute for once. Romanic has a valid point in that regard. No offense, but posting nothing but memes isn't particularly helpful.

FoS : Zack


There's so much wrong with that post.

First, you blame Romanic for making a filmsy case against fluffy, while all he did was pressuring fluffy to post something substantial instead of the usual meme's and funny guy act. You read an awful lot in a pressure vote and this "case" against Romanic smells fabricated.

Then, after you voted Romanic, you just basically agree with him.

That post smells fishy.

[Zack]

Then, after you voted Romanic, you just basically agree with him.

I said he has a point. I didn't say I thought fluffy was lynch-worthy.

EDIT: And Romanic, you voted fluffy because he "wasn't looking for scum", which you are also guilty for. What else would you call starting an easy bandwagon on someone for being silly, who you admit you don't necessarily think is scum?

[Andres]

I said he has a point. I didn't say I thought fluffy was lynch-worthy.

EDIT: And Romanic, you voted fluffy because he "wasn't looking for scum", which you are also guilty for. What else would you call starting an easy bandwagon on someone for being silly, who you admit you don't necessarily think is scum?

The fact you only quoted that part of my post is interesting and makes you look even more suspicious.

[Zack]

The fact you only quoted that part of my post is interesting and makes you look even more suspicious.

Umm, why?

I always only quote the part of posts I'm addressing. It's scummy that I didn't quote "FoS: Zack"?

[Romanic]

I said he has a point. I didn't say I thought fluffy was lynch-worthy.

EDIT: And Romanic, you voted fluffy because he "wasn't looking for scum", which you are also guilty for. What else would you call starting an easy bandwagon on someone for being silly, who you admit you don't necessarily think is scum?

Well, you may think that I am not looking for scum, but in my opinion, I am (and I've explained this in my previous answer to you).

Also, I am pretty sure that I never "admitted" that "I don't necessarily think Fluffy is scum". Don't put words in my mouth please. .

Of course I thought, and I still think, that Fluffy could be scum, since the writeup did not give us a clue about his true identity.

[TheLastDays]

Gah!

And because I can't say a lot more than that about what happend last night: GAH!

That said, can somebody tell me why we are not lynching Double A?

Because I think Seon is more deserving of attention at the moment.

First let's fix your naming once and for all - 'pearly' lady was used in one writeup - You should refer to this character as the 'winged' lady, since she's shown having wings in all writeups she appeared in. Iirc Diamondeye proposed that she is a Valkyrie, and I agree with it.

Second, you're right to point that she is not around anymore, and I am seriously considering that she was God Emperor, who was lynched just before she disappeared. If so, then the mafia would need to have a new killer (assuming the mafia can kill twice, and pick who kills - I think it was like this in the previous game)

Alright, let's call her Valkyrie from now on then. I would like to agree with you because it would feel good to have caught scum already. But, honestly, after the secons failed attempt by big axe guy, GE's claims received some more credibility and at the moment I rather have him down as a townie who did a very dumb move with keeping back his information. I might be a bit biased, because I defended him on Day 1 but I think the scums have just switched who does the killing.

[Death is yonder]

Because I think Seon is more deserving of attention at the moment.



Alright, let's call her Valkyrie from now on then. I would like to agree with you because it would feel good to have caught scum already. But, honestly, after the secons failed attempt by big axe guy, GE's claims received some more credibility and at the moment I rather have him down as a townie who did a very dumb move with keeping back his information. I might be a bit biased, because I defended him on Day 1 but I think the scums have just switched who does the killing.

More deserving of attention than yourself perhaps?

In any case, so you think that GE was town because he:

1. Claimed he needed time to see whether the situation called for revealing and how much should be revealed
2. Followed this up by contradicting himself and claiming to be a basic townie, and coming up with a flimsy defense to try and deflect this fact
3. At first implied/soft claimed a pro-town role at point 1, despite the fact that it would be imbalanced for him to be a pro-town role because of a very simple fact (almost every single time, but I see no reason for that to be disproved now) that pro-town roles do not survive night kills, it is not balanced.

The underline section indicates you actually believed he had something to reveal, but fact of the matter is that he implied being a pro-town role, quickly changed his story that he was a basic townie, then (Point 3 above) was pointed out at which case he stopped referencing to that area of his defense probably realizing the inconsistencies would be further pointed out and emphasized.

Your current attempts to back off smells more like you trying to save your scum partner and the hitting the fan because he got lynched anyway and you got cast into the spotlight momentarily and now you're trying to deflect attention elsewhere and play down your efforts to save GE (and vice versa defending) despite his obvious scummyness.

Moreover, you clearly have been reading the thread as indicated to your replies by Believer, yet you've not responded to this post I made:

I merely said:

Vote: TLD

Hello.

To which you replied within the same hour:

Vote: DiY

Let me think.

Despite the fact that as I mentioned in a later post:

An interesting reaction considering I have not been involved in private communication with you

Something note worthy too, much akin to GE trying to subtly nudge the voting direction elsewhere, except in your case, a bit more blatant.

My vote stays.

I'd most certainly like to think that you thought that someone had been speaking in private to me about something that you've done, or something that might have implicated you as scum and you were trying to buy time to come up with a decent explanation before decided it could be ignored to play it down.

Vote: TLD

Why isn't he lynched yet?

In any case, glyphz reaction doesn't seem that scummy, compared to his behavior in Midgard when he was Jotun (can't put my finger on it, but it does feel pretty dissimilar) and I'm inclined to believe that TLD is someone who needs to be looked at first (more so than glyphz at least).

[Romanic]

vote: glyphz

Not convinced by his defense anymore, he's only defending, not trying to find Scum, I'm reading some vague answers that could be left to interpretation and he has not voted yet.

Also if GE was scum, then Renata casting the 2nd vote on GE is good enough to follow her.

[glyphz]

vote: glyphz

Not convinced by his defense anymore, he's only defending, not trying to find Scum, I'm reading some vague answers that could be left to interpretation and he has not voted yet.

Also if GE was scum, then Renata casting the 2nd vote on GE is good enough to follow her.

Vote: glyphz
should have done this last round. Though I'm still open to switch to another, preferablt TLD, if someone decides to start a late trend.

[TheLastDays]

I don't understand what you're getting at completely. My vote for you was certainly a joke since I switched it as soon as I said something serious and your case was "Hello". Believe it or not.
Your "case" is based off the assumption that I was trying to imply something with my vote on you and the statement "let me think, which I didn't.

glypz isn't scummy enough for you? Vote Seon then.

[Yaropolk]

1) can someone post a tally please?

2) Khaan can you end the rounds at an hour when more people are awake please?