Netherworld III: Final Judgment [Concluded]

[Earthling]

Honestly we know pizza can do better than vote on nonsense OMGUS cases and lie to other townies, so what we get out of that is he's too busy to give this game an effort, that's not even much of a loss and doubly so if he was a basic townie when we don't have reveals and can't distinguish those from scum for sure.

[Riedquat]

Err... just to note a little thing, I never ever played a mafia game before but still can say some people act scummy or differently than previous games... btw, don't think I'm defending TLD, in fact I think you two are mafia and are barking at each other just to confuse town...

[TheLastDays]

This was kinda a crosspost and I'll just mention again because this constant lying deserves other players seeing the callout.

You and I have never played in a mafia game before for any meaningful length of time. Everybody can check this.

It's a complete lie that you could possibly know anything about me despite that you constantly say my posts are somehow different, except that you have scum partners telling you in private this is a good way to stir up trouble. Of course it is about the same as your accusations again Seon or DiY or anyone who you have no connections to and no reason to criticize, you're just a scum.

1) We played in two games together and being dead hasn't stopped you from posting in either of these games.
2) My accusations against Seon are completely different in nature. He voted me on bad reasoning, then received pressure and has since disappeared, voting for somebody else.
3) I never accused DiY on anything so I don't even know what you're trying to say there.

[TheLastDays]

Err... just to note a little thing, I never ever played a mafia game before but still can say some people act scummy or differently than previous games... btw, don't think I'm defending TLD, in fact I think you two are mafia and are barking at each other just to confuse town...

ALright then let's lynch Earthling tomorrow and you can lynch me the next day. Problem solved
Or if that doesn't suit you, do it the other way round, just get rid of Earthling and Seon.

[johnhughthom]

Err... just to note a little thing, I never ever played a mafia game before but still can say some people act scummy or differently than previous games... btw, don't think I'm defending TLD, in fact I think you two are mafia and are barking at each other just to bore the town...

Like you said, you're new so I fixed that for ya. You're welcome.

[Zack]

Like you said, you're new so I fixed that for ya. Your welcome.

Wait, I didn't think anyone was actually reading their bickering.

[Earthling]

1) We played in two games together and being dead hasn't stopped you from posting in either of these games.
2) My accusations against Seon are completely different in nature. He voted me on bad reasoning, then received pressure and has since disappeared, voting for somebody else.
3) I never accused DiY on anything so I don't even know what you're trying to say there.

This laughably isn't hard to refute. Every point here is wrong even with you purposefully trying to seem vague. Though I grant you that you've given a better scum performance to survive this long since GE died, being active and giving an effort, much better than many recent games and it's nice not to have a team of pure lurker scum.

So again, you think that barely a handful of anonymous posts and being killed Night One means you have some special insight to me in this game? You've said this again and again so don't change your story, you don't think there's anything different about posting while dead and not being able to vote, nor do you even care about the actual game mechanics and story differences here?

If you want to say that you don't like me for reasons different than the OMGUS on the several others, the only thing you've said is my posts are weird compared to before. Which is just a lie, because you have no experience to base that on.

You actually voted for Death is Yonder once before, as already pointed out, and you're just making no sense about Seon. Seon voted for you, true. Nothing else you implied about him that is "bad" is true - he's not been lurking and missing votes, he's not given really bad reasoning, none of it.

At this point though there's enough arguing with scum. You won't be an entirely confirmed scum anytime soon but arguing with a scum who we know is saying things in bad faith does waste people's time.

[johnhughthom]

Wait, I didn't think anyone was actually reading their bickering.

Gah, you only quoted me to highlight my poor grammar and make editing the original pointless, didn't you?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Since you killed me in the last mafia game, I just had to get some payback against you and this is it I guess!

Yes Warman, I understand why you play the game. I know that you only really sign up to these games to have a chance at killing me over some lame stuff that happened 1-2 years ago that you won't let go.

It's kind of sad that this is how you get your jollies, really. Honestly you should find a new hobby.

The thing is, it doesn't bother me that you do this; the fact that you'd think it bothers me is really amusing.

[Arjos]

LOL johnhughthom XD

[TheLastDays]

This laughably isn't hard to refute. Every point here is wrong even with you purposefully trying to seem vague. Though I grant you that you've given a better scum performance to survive this long since GE died, being active and giving an effort, much better than many recent games and it's nice not to have a team of pure lurker scum.

So again, you think that barely a handful of anonymous posts and being killed Night One means you have some special insight to me in this game? You've said this again and again so don't change your story, you don't think there's anything different about posting while dead and not being able to vote, nor do you even care about the actual game mechanics and story differences here?

If you want to say that you don't like me for reasons different than the OMGUS on the several others, the only thing you've said is my posts are weird compared to before. Which is just a lie, because you have no experience to base that on.

You actually voted for Death is Yonder once before, as already pointed out, and you're just making no sense about Seon. Seon voted for you, true. Nothing else you implied about him that is "bad" is true - he's not been lurking and missing votes, he's not given really bad reasoning, none of it.

At this point though there's enough arguing with scum. You won't be an entirely confirmed scum anytime soon but arguing with a scum who we know is saying things in bad faith does waste people's time.

But... come back... Earthling what do I have to do if I can't argue with you?

Well if you're implying that you post reasonable analysis when dead and weak cases when alive then yes, I was mistaken because of a lack of experience with you as an alive player.
I voted DiY on an OMGUS/joke vote, giving no reason whatsoever and thus not accusing him of anything. (unvoting very quickly after that for a serious vote)

Alright, guess we'll talk again tomorrow

[johnhughthom]

Hey guys! The way forward for your unresolved sexual tension.

[TheLastDays]

Hey guys! The way forward for your unresolved sexual tension.

You are seriously offending me! We're just making an effort to get khaan on top of the "games with most posts" list.

[Zack]

It's kind of sad that this is how you get your jollies, really. Honestly you should find a new hobby.

[johnhughthom]

Ummm, are you volunteering to be Warman's new hobby?

[Andres]

Why exactly was Pizza lynched?

And why is glyphz under pressure?

And why are Double A and Zack flying under the radar so easily?

[Askthepizzaguy]

I believe I was lynched because I wasn't cluttering up the thread with pages-long cases on anyone, which I usually reserve for the endgame anyway.

In other words, no real reason, just random lynch choice.

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

Yes Warman, I understand why you play the game. I know that you only really sign up to these games to have a chance at killing me over some lame stuff that happened 1-2 years ago that you won't let go.

It's kind of sad that this is how you get your jollies, really. Honestly you should find a new hobby.

The thing is, it doesn't bother me that you do this; the fact that you'd think it bothers me is really amusing.

Actually, it's quite amusing that you brought it up as I haven't thought about that incident in uhm.... yeah, how long? And you say I'm the one with the problem?

And no, I like my time in mafia games and Interactive History. I'll think I'll continue to play in as many as I am physically able to. We going to be new best friends in mafia games now!

Ummm, are you volunteering to be Warman's new hobby?

I don't know. Let me know and I'll chase after y'a!

[Zack]

Warman should automatically be nightkilled Night 1 until he changes his name to something shorter.

[johnhughthom]

Why exactly was Pizza lynched?

Pretty much my fault for tying the vote to provoke a reaction. Why he was in a position to be tied ( not like that, that's khaan's job), I don't know.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Actually, it's quite amusing that you brought it up as I haven't thought about that incident in uhm.... yeah, how long? And you say I'm the one with the problem?

*Shrug* You've admitted to me in private that you play games to get revenge on me. You just admitted today that you voted for me for explicitly the purposes of revenge. Warman only plays games for revenge. Warman denies that is the case, after admitting that is the case.

Dude, problem is on your end. Problem should actually be plural, but let's stick to the one I'm talking about.

Anyway, don't bother talking to me. I've deleted your private message. Keep it up, and I'll make sure I don't get any more of them.

[Andres]

Pretty much my fault for tying the vote to provoke a reaction. Why he was in a position to be tied ( not like that, that's khaan's job), I don't know.

What's your opinion on Double A and Zack?

[Andres]

Warman should automatically be nightkilled Night 1 until he changes his name to something shorter.

I concur.

[ELITEofWARMANGINGERYBREADMEN88]

Warman should automatically be nightkilled Night 1 until he changes his name to something shorter.

Sure, why not.

*Shrug* You've admitted to me in private that you play games to get revenge on me. You just admitted today that you voted for me for explicitly the purposes of revenge. Warman only plays games for revenge. Warman denies that is the case, after admitting that is the case.

Dude, problem is on your end. Problem should actually be plural, but let's stick to the one I'm talking about.

Anyway, don't bother talking to me. I've deleted your private message. Keep it up, and I'll make sure I don't get any more of them.

Wish is your, my command.

[johnhughthom]

What's your opinion on Double A and Zack?

Sigh...

Okay Double A:

If I was mafia trying to appear as town I'd sit on my hands and vote randomly like I usually do.

According to Askthepizzaguy mafia 101 this post makes him scum.

That's about 5 games worth of analysis right there by my usual standards. Zack's been chatty without much substance recently. 8 games.

[Andres]

Hmmm...

I'm confident that one day, you'll be posting pages long analysis. In 2049 or so

[GeneralHankerchief]

Please keep all out-of-game issues out of game.

Seriously guys, I've spent more time moderating this game than actually playing it. Can we maybe turn it around for the second half?

[Double A]

unvote; vote ATPG

Oh, look, a last minute vote switch which resulted in the tie being broken. Totally not incriminating of both glyphz and Earthling.

Sigh...

Okay Double A:



According to Askthepizzaguy mafia 101 this post makes him scum.

That's about 5 games worth of analysis right there by my usual standards. Zack's been chatty without much substance recently. 8 games.

Yeah, I kinda figured that would happen shortly after I posted it.

All I have to say is sorry for using logic :/

[johnhughthom]

Hmmm...

I'm confident that one day, you'll be posting pages long analysis. In 2049 or so

I do try, I've even managed to bring up all of a persons posts at once, though it was only 3 posts. I'm hoping to graduate to analysing voting patterns sometime in the next decade. After that who knows?

[Death is yonder]

I don't understand what you're getting at completely. My vote for you was certainly a joke since I switched it as soon as I said something serious and your case was "Hello". Believe it or not.
Your "case" is based off the assumption that I was trying to imply something with my vote on you and the statement "let me think, which I didn't.

glypz isn't scummy enough for you? Vote Seon then.

No, the crux of my case is that you suppose that GE wasn't scum but there are quite a few compelling reasons listed there why GE was probably scum.

In fact you still haven't provided any reasoning as to why in the face of such a situation (those reasons) you would nevertheless think GE is not scum, hence I believe that you tried to defend your scum partner, and now are trying to back off from it because he got lynched and fallout was definitely inevitable.

And please do not quote: (as a supposed example which explains it all)

GE's claims received some more credibility and at the moment I rather have him down as a townie who did a very dumb move with keeping back his information. I might be a bit biased, because I defended him on Day 1 but I think the scums have just switched who does the killing.

Because while the second occurrence of the Axe Guy raised the possibility of night kill failures, but it proved nothing in relation to innocence or guilt, because as I raised up sometime shortly after the night kill write up:

Even if Night Kill % was the reason behind his failings, this did NOT give GE's claims more credibility, but rather brought up a question that if such was the case, wouldn't GE as scum have a even higher chance of surviving it? (Assuming of course that axe guy is a third party)

Fact is, he claimed to be hesitant to revealing, then backtracked and claimed basic townie. I'd love for you to explain how all this means that GE was a silly townie rather than a panicked scumbag who was seeing whether a soft claim could get him out of it. (Why not right? In Midgard III, "what if we hit a power role?" was a primary concern that averted quite a few lynches of possible power roles.) Tincow even used it to ride out suspicion for quite a while as Jotun, where after a fairly incriminating reveal was imminent, he played this exact card and managed to lie low)