Well in the end all that is being said is this:

a) Chaotix cannot be seriously using the excuse that being a god = unrecruitable because classical has disproved this, and unless you want to propose with evidence that someone else did the revive, you basically cannot dispute that the fact is that being a god does not inhibit recruitment

[You might want to nitpick that it was claimed that Andres was recruited via the revive, but what I recall the fact of the matter being was that Andres was alive long enough to have been recruited following his revival in a night phase and thus Earthling cannot so easily discount it.]

b) The fact that he is unrecruitable irrelevant of possible godhood raises the only other power role available, scumbag

Irrelevant of any other nitpick with the details you may possibly have, fact of the matter is that:

1. A revive happened
2. There is no evidence to suggest that anybody other than classical did it, which supports his claim of godhood, especially makes sense because IIRC he claimed to be god of death or something
3. It thus cannot be the case that his supposed "pro-town god" status prevented chaotix from being recruited
4. The only other logical conclusion is that Chaotix is the mafia

In any case, what is being put on the table is a chance at a united joint win, it has already been mentioned that is part of the victory conditions.

To reiterate:
You may choose a definite lose scenario by prolonging the mafia's existence

OR

You may accept a shot at a united victory that is otherwise unattainable. Unless you would like to do the most foolish thing available at hand which is to attempt to trust the mafia.

What does having a large group of followers do towards that goal?
Well for starters you could realize that you can't force the lynch, even if you solicited the mafia's help, which is definitely going to go well from a townie point of view. It isn't even a third party offering "oh let us be your vigilante for suspects", this is a clear cut mafiosi plain and simple.

Then next you could realize that we want the mafia dead, and what better way to do that than voting.

I must admit I'm torn between humor and pity that Beskar has worked out through reveals and stuff that the only way for town to possibly secure a win is to trust us (and some aren't listening to him in the 'interest of pursuing victory' which is already essentially being offered), I mean, the offer here is to work together to eliminate the mafia, contrary to what might be expected, I fail to see how that can go wrong.

Essentially what some are proposing is that you leave the mafia alive, because evidently getting rid of the mafia is somehow unimportant in the grand scheme of having more townies alive.