Three Wolf Moon [Concluded]

[Seamus Fermanagh]

Vote: B-Ray; Vote: Warman etc.

I don't agree with your mafia numbers assessment, Pizza. I think that many mafiosi would be an imbalance from a games construction perspective.

I am happy with the B-Ray vote, at least until I hear him argue against it a bit.

Other thoughts?

[Ishmael]

Upon re-reading through the thread I'm still getting scummy vibes from Seamus. I'm not going to compile evidence to support this, as I'm rather lazy and don't have much time at the moment - call it a hunch, if you will. I realise that I'm not selling this case very well, but feel free to scan through the thread yourselves and see what conclusions you draw. Anyway:

vote: Seamus Fermanagh
vote: Warman

Also, FoS: Yarapolk, for similar reasons to the above.

[Tratorix]

Upon re-reading through the thread I'm still getting scummy vibes from Seamus. I'm not going to compile evidence to support this, as I'm rather lazy and don't have much time at the moment - call it a hunch, if you will. I realise that I'm not selling this case very well, but feel free to scan through the thread yourselves and see what conclusions you draw. Anyway:

vote: Seamus Fermanagh
vote: Warman

Also, FoS: Yarapolk, for similar reasons to the above.

Lynch B-Ray, scan Seamus. If Seamus comes up innocent lynch Ishmael

[Askthepizzaguy]

Lynch B-Ray, scan Seamus. If Seamus comes up innocent lynch Ishmael

Also: if Seamus comes up as guilty lynch Ishmael.

[Ishmael]

Lynch B-Ray, scan Seamus. If Seamus comes up innocent lynch Ishmael

I'd like to point out that poor judgement does not necessarily make a mafioso - look at my earlier work in Vespasian as an example . I really don't see where the case on B_Ray is coming from, though - sure he's posting similarly to his game as mafia, but that may just be his posting style. He might be scum, but Yarapolk and Seamus seem far more likely.

[Tratorix]

I'd like to point out that poor judgement does not necessarily make a mafioso - look at my earlier work in Vespasian as an example . I really don't see where the case on B_Ray is coming from, though - sure he's posting similarly to his game as mafia, but that may just be his posting style. He might be scum, but Yarapolk and Seamus seem far more likely.

Scum scum scum.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote: B-Ray; Vote: Warman etc.

I don't agree with your mafia numbers assessment, Pizza. I think that many mafiosi would be an imbalance from a games construction perspective.

Small game with a "detective" that cannot die?

Disagree. Mafia needs at least one over standard. Standard for a game this size is 2-3.

[Tratorix]

Small game with a "detective" that cannot die?

Disagree. Mafia needs at least one over standard. Standard for a game this size is 2-3.

I say 3. 4 seems too powerful for a small game and two seems underpowered.