The facts, as they are now.

The mafia, as of the current situation cannot kill. The fact that there was no night period last night, also indicates they cannot recruit. So the write-up from Night 1 is likely to be the only time when such an occurrence happens. The other thing I got from reading that write-up is that the first man seems to be a bit of a loose cannon, even though his brother says that they can't shoot anyone at night, he appears as though he might go against that, if given the chance at all.

So chances are if there are enough No Lynches, the first guy is going to lose patience and kill someone.

Moral of the story, we probably do have to lynch. The real question is who do we lynch?

My next question is, Is Heinrich an NPC or a living character?