Clue Mafia [Concluded]

[Montmorency]

No, as in full-on random, where each individual votes randomly and some guy is lynched, no other considerations. At least, it works offline.

[johnhughthom]

The broken drumstick is a reference to the Music Mafia in which he played Phil Collins, a mafioso drummer who murdered people by beating them up with drumsticks. As this is an obscure reference, it is highly likely to be a True Clue.

Octopus, under the sea, drumstick = Ringo Starr? Can anyone think of a link, there have been Beatles mafia games I believe, were any of the players in this Ringo? Seems too obvious though.

[Captain Blackadder]

Vote: Skooma
Vote Cecil
Vote Montmorency

I think that to try to determine the answers currently is not going to work we need at least one more days worth of clues since each clue will make it so that certain possibilities are removed. I wouldn't say too loudly who you think are scum since I would be sure that whomever we say will be framed in the next few days.

[Montmorency]

dont vote Me I AM town NOOOOO!

[Montmorency]

NO PLEASE I'LL KILL YOU I MEAN LYNCH

[edse]

As you can see Montmorency broke just like the ship in the bottle. Vote:Montmorency

[landlubber]

Vote: Hero di classico
Vote: Skooma Addict
I wish I could say that I have more to contribute than piggybacking on the reasoning of others, but the cases against Skooma and classico are the best I've seen so far. I don't think I'll have a third vote, unless some new evidence surfaces.

[TheLastDays]

WEll, let's go random then.

vote: ATPG
vote: johnhughthom
vote: Cecil XIX

[Askthepizzaguy]

WEll, let's go random then.

vote: ATPG
vote: johnhughthom
vote: Cecil XIX

You evil person you! I'll murder you in your sleep!

[TheLastDays]

Because you couldn't do it while I'm awake

[classical_hero]

What's the point of coming up with a false clue to frame someone, who is getting killed the same night?

FoS: hero di classico

Because they don;'t know each other in these games.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Because you couldn't do it while I'm awake

Technically I can't do it while you're sleeping either.

Sucks being a townie. But I can still frame myself for your death and hope it happens.

[Chaotix]

Vote: ATPG

There were no clues about you. Why not?

[robbiecon]

My three votes are somewhat random. The first two are simply for people who haven't been voted for yet, as for DaveShack, he's only enquired whether Verarde played here under a different name.

Vote: Ishmael
Vote: Chaotix
Vote: DaveShack

[Askthepizzaguy]

Vote: ATPG

There were no clues about you. Why not?

Pizza envy?

[Zack]

A question for our host: did the mafiosi submit the clues with those phrases bolded, or did you do that yourself and the rest is just flavour?

I bolded the phrases.

[DaveShack]

That question was to try to analyze a clue. Verarde's former name was Drum Student, which would point to the drumsticks. But I don't know all the names of people who play here.

Random is nice, unless you end up with a couple votes that way. On the someone other than me approach I must choose:

Vote: hero di classico
Vote: landlubber
Vote: skooma addict

[johnhughthom]

Some votes,

Vote: Cecil
Vote: edse
Vote: DaveShack

[Seon]

Vote: SKOOMA addict
Vote: Chaotix

[Zack]

DAY THE FIRST

After a long day of arguing, the townspeople gathered together for a nice, relaxing round of "brutally murder the top three vote-getters".


Tally:


Skooma Addict: 6 (Arjos, Ishmael, Blackadder, landlubber, DaveShack, Seon)
Cecil XIX: 5 (hero di classico, ATPG, Blackadder, TLD, JHT)
hero di classico: 5 (Sprig, Ishmael, ATPG, landlubber, DaveShack)

Askthepizzaguy: 3 (hero di classico, TLD, Chaotix)
landlubber: 3 (hero di classico, ATPG, DaveShack)
DaveShack: 3 (Skooma Addict, robbiecon, JHT)
johnhughthom: 2 (Skooma Addict, TLD)
Chaotix: 2 (robbiecon, Seon)
Captain Blackadder: 1 (Skooma Addict)
Ishmael: 1 (robbiecon)
edse: 1 (JHT)



** two people voted for the deceased Montmorency

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Skooma Addict was Mafia!

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Cecil XIX was Innocent!

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

hero di classico was Innocent!

IT IS NOW NIGHT TWO.






PLAYERS

1. johnhughthom
2. Montmorency -- Townie, Killed Night 1
3. landlubber
4. Skooma Addict -- Mafia, Lynched Day 1
5. Ishmael
6. Cecil XIX -- Townie, Lynched Day 1
7. Arjos
8. Askthepizzaguy
9. Cahoma -- Townie, Killed Night 1
10. Captain Blackadder
11. robbiecon
12. hero di classico -- Townie, Lynched Day 1
13. edse
14. Seon
15. Chaotix
16. DaveShack

[Ishmael]

Skooma, were we correct in our line of reasoning with the clue, or were we right for the wrong reasons?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Nice, random hit.

[Arjos]

Nice, random hit.

Random? Pff amateur that's called logic :P

[Ishmael]

Also Zack, I have another question for you - can you confirm whether the mafia know each others' identities? Classical hero said something about that the other day, and I'd like to be certain about it.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Random? Pff amateur that's called logic :P

Teach me, master Arjos, or I'll never learn.

[Skooma Addict]

Skooma, were we correct in our line of reasoning with the clue, or were we right for the wrong reasons?

The best part is, I got lynched from town incorrectly guessing a false clue. I swear, this could only happen to me.

[Montmorency]

Looking to be a short game.

[Captain Blackadder]

Well done team randomness continues to show its power.

[classical_hero]

I told you I was innocent.

[TheLastDays]

I am innocent as well.