Clue Mafia [Concluded]

[Zack]

THE THIRD, EXTREMELY LENGTHY NIGHT

And Zack said, "Let there be update!"

And the players saw the update and said, "It is mediocre (at best)."




Captain Blackadder's corpse was the lone dead body found.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

His body had been branded, cow-style, with the following words:

Kill The Queen, Save Rasputin

IT IS NOW DAY THREE.



You may vote for ONE person.






PLAYERS

1. johnhughthom -- Townie, Lynched Day 2
2. Montmorency -- Townie, Killed Night 1
3. landlubber
4. Skooma Addict -- Mafia, Lynched Day 1
5. Ishmael -- Townie, Killed Night 2
6. Cecil XIX -- Townie, Lynched Day 1
7. Arjos
8. Askthepizzaguy -- Townie, Killed Night 2
9. Cahoma -- Townie, Killed Night 1
10. Captain Blackadder -- Townie, Killed Night 3
11. robbiecon
12. hero di classico -- Townie, Lynched Day 1
13. edse
14. Seon
15. Chaotix -- Mafia, Lynched Day 2
16. DaveShack

[Zack]

Due to the circumstances, Day 3 will be 24 hours if everyone has voted, and 48 hours if not.

[johnhughthom]

classical hero had a Queen avatar at CFC once upon a time I do believe. But he's dead.

[Montmorency]

Robbiecon = Robespierre?

[Arjos]

Could it be about the Boney M song? Anyone a fan of 70s disco music? XD

[edse]

I am, but I didn't kill him. I would say that it point to Russia, but I don't know...

[DaveShack]

Robbiecon = Robespierre?

Rasputin was in Russia, Robespierre in France. Also Robespierre wouldn't say "Save the Queen". Though it's hard to say if that would make it a bad frame or a really bad true clue.

The clue could be the "branded, cow-style" part.

[edse]

NIGHT THE FIRST

They went to Cahoma's house first.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

His corpse wasn't very bloody, but it was covered in bruises. A broken drumstick was found near his body, along with the following note:

octopus... under the sea

THE SECOND NIGHT

Ishmael was found next.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

An icicle was found impaled in his chest, along with the following note:

sunk by the iceberg

THE THIRD, EXTREMELY LENGTHY NIGHT

Captain Blackadder's corpse was the lone dead body found.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

His body had been branded, cow-style, with the following words:

Kill The Queen, Save Rasputin

It should be the same person for these three kills.

[Arjos]

Yet, two must be false clues or two must be true...

[Montmorency]

Right, so figure out whether the two dead scum had the true clues. For now:

Rasputin was in Russia, Robespierre in France. Also Robespierre wouldn't say "Save the Queen". Though it's hard to say if that would make it a bad frame or a really bad true clue.

The clue is "Kill the Queen, save Rasputin". So, maybe something Robespierre might advocate, and Robbiecon = Robespierre.

[Zack]

THE FOURTH NIGHT

No one died that night.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

"Listen here, listen to this clue
You know it to be true!"

The last killer hails from a foreign land!


("foreign" as in not the US)

IT IS NOW DAY THREE.



You may vote for ONE person.






PLAYERS

1. johnhughthom -- Townie, Lynched Day 2
2. Montmorency -- Townie, Killed Night 1
3. landlubber
4. Skooma Addict -- Mafia, Lynched Day 1
5. Ishmael -- Townie, Killed Night 2
6. Cecil XIX -- Townie, Lynched Day 1
7. Arjos
8. Askthepizzaguy -- Townie, Killed Night 2
9. Cahoma -- Townie, Killed Night 1
10. Captain Blackadder -- Townie, Killed Night 3
11. robbiecon
12. hero di classico -- Townie, Lynched Day 1
13. edse
14. Seon
15. Chaotix -- Mafia, Lynched Day 2
16. DaveShack

[Arjos]

Well moving to the second target, who hasn't been online, apparently not even to order a kill (:P): Vote: robbiecon

[Askthepizzaguy]

You should be able to determine which of this set of clues is true and false by now.

Solve it and remove a suspect from inclusion.

[Montmorency]

Apparently, everyone but robbiecon has voted for scum twice.

Is that not proof enough?

[landlubber]

Vote: Robbiecon.
Need I say more?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Also, Chaotix was mafia. You gotta know he encouraged his mates to bus him, because it works.

Play the man, and the man is a cunning man. Chaotix doesn't play it safe or timid.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Apparently, everyone but robbiecon has voted for scum twice.

Is that not proof enough?

No, not really. Bussing is especially effective in these situations because when a scum is going to die, you get credit for also voting them. Now, ducking a late game lynch could be game-winning.

Solve the clues, remove a suspect. Maybe it is robbiecon, ok? But what if you can prove that it is not him? Then you get two blind shots that have a chance of winning instead of only one.

[Zack]

You should be able to determine which of this set of clues is true and false by now.

Solve it and remove a suspect from inclusion.

Since there was no kill order, (as per the rules) the most recent clue was a true clue. It might not necessarily line up with the true/false alternation of the preceding clues.

[DaveShack]

OK, information gathering mode...

From CFC, robbiecon claims to be from Ireland. Notice the Interests field in the profile.

About robbiecon

Location
Longford,Ireland
Interests
Beatles!
Occupation
Computer Engineering student

CFC and org profile for landlubber is inconclusive, but IP lookup shows a US address.

Likewise for Seon, profile location info is inconclusive but IP lookup shows a US address.

No CFC info for Arjos.

For completeness, I'm from the US and you can find me as such on multiple websites.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

There are two clear suspects in 5 players, the others can be discounted. If we lynch wrong (yet choosing one of Arjos or robbiecon) and there is a kill, we go into a last day with 3 players and at most one of the remaining players is a suspect according to this clue. Even if you only take obvious information into account, robbiecon is the only one who actively lists a non-US location, and an extensive search might turn up other evidence of location for all remaining players.

I think the Beatles! info also makes it likely in light of the 1st clue: vote: robbiecon

[landlubber]

I am indeed from the US; a lot of people know that my twin brother is civplayah, and his profile has that location listed IIRC.