Quote Originally Posted by Andres View Post
The way I understood is that town lost because too many people couldn't resist the Dark Side.
That was my main argument after the game. The shyster not being in the game wouldn't have prevented a mafia victory. I'd be dead, but the mafia would still be there. Most people had picked a side long before then... the allure of being mafia was too great. A team doesn't win when most of the people on it decide to turn their backs on it, or go inactive.

Why was the Shyster not killed or lynched? Surely, if enough people would play town, they would be able to penetrate through defenses.
Ooh this discussion so belongs in the Capo IV thread itself. Redirecting and reposting it there.