DARKLING [Concluded]

[edse]

EDIT: Having just bolded that text it totally contradicts what I was guessing at above: Maybe Chaotix and Atheotes are in fact just dead men walking. However it does reinforce my belief that a lynch vote for either is a wasted vote

But isn't it worse to lynch someone based on weak suspicions and he then turns out to be townie? I will however not argue about this further as you are both of the same view and I'm apparently doing it wrong.

[LazyMcCrow]

But isn't it worse to lynch someone based on weak suspicions and he then turns out to be townie? I will however not argue about this further as you are both of the same view and I'm apparently doing it wrong.

no need for the self-deprecation, we all know that weak suspicions, or 'instinct' is generally all you have to go on at first, I'd like you to explain your reasoning to me how lynching Chaotix or Atheotes is more useful. In my mind they are apparently innocent victims, but you obviously think not - so what do you think and why?

[edse]

I might have misunderstood you, what do you mean with

Maybe Chaotix and Atheotes are in fact just dead men walking.

They are innocent victims but we don't know what will happen with them. If they die this evening and we vote for one of them we will have 2 dead townies. If we instead vote for someone not confirmed mafia we can have 3 dead townies. If we vote for them and they survive the plague we will have 1 dead townie and if we vote for someone else while the two survives we can have 1 dead townie as well.

The only thing that can make the odds better is if we lynch a scum. How certain are you that White_eyes:D are mafia?

[LazyMcCrow]

I might have misunderstood you, what do you mean with

They are innocent victims but we don't know what will happen with them. If they die this evening and we vote for one of them we will have 2 dead townies. If we instead vote for someone not confirmed mafia we can have 3 dead townies. If we vote for them and they survive the plague we will have 1 dead townie and if we vote for someone else while the two survives we can have 1 dead townie as well.

The only thing that can make the odds better is if we lynch a scum. How certain are you that White_eyes:D are mafia?

What I meant by 'Maybe Chaotix and Atheotes are in fact just dead men walking. ' was that maybe they were the Darklings nightkill, but they don't actually die til the end of the day phase.

I am not certain that White_eyes:D is mafia, BUT given that the lynch is the only method we have of destroying mafia and that I don't believe either Chaotix or Atheotes to be mafia, then it is useful to town to lynch someone else no?
Do you honestly believe that either Chaotix or Atheotes is a Darkling?

[edse]

No, I don't believe they are Darklings, but I don't know if anyone else is either so I rather have 2 dead townies than 3. That is IF they die of the plague and that seems likely.

[LazyMcCrow]

No, I don't believe they are Darklings, but I don't know if anyone else is either so I rather have 2 dead townies than 3. That is IF they die of the plague and that seems likely.

So after how many phases would you suggest the lynching begins, because it sounds like you are keen to simply let the Darklings continue with their nefarious schemes until a lynch is statistically more likely of hitting the right target?

[edse]

So after how many phases would you suggest the lynching begins, because it sounds like you are keen to simply let the Darklings continue with their nefarious schemes until a lynch is statistically more likely of hitting the right target?

Al right then, Unvote: vote: White_Eyes:D You were right about Jarema, maybe you are right again.

[atheotes]

I visited Chaotix last night.
I spent some time with him. Now i am in constant pain. not sure what to make of my state right now. we are yet to see a pattern in the night happenings.