Let me synposize the dilemma: our stated objectivecoming into this was to lynch the "purest" individual and please the gods.

On N1 there were no kills.

On N2, there were 3 kills, and 2 of them were written in a very unusual manner.

In each of these kills, the killer was written in a way that almost makes it seem like the same guy did the killing.

Despite the sudden onset of kills, our stated objective has not changed.

...

Have we learned nothing from Pizza's game? Things are not as they appear.

A note: in the previous large game (Buffy 2) there was a mafioso who could kill 3 players a night. Just saying.