We should go with the near-tie vote plan. Every day we do this gives over half of the players the power to change who lives and dies on every day after that day. After a few days we will all have the power to change who is alive and dead. Because everyone will abuse this power to try kill people who they believe are scum or save those they think are innocent, we will arrive at a state where who is alive and who is dead is constantly shifting. This means that we will rapidly shift through the different possible combinations of alive / dead players. As soon as we hit a combination where both scum are dead, we win.

In this situation it is actually better to have as many peoples lives threatened by the near-tie vote, as it gives more players power over life/death on that day and allows for more combinations. At the moment Ishmael, Arjos and Greyblades all have 2 votes. I will vote: Montmorency so that he now also has two votes.