Knights of Honor mafia 2 [IN PLAY]

[Arjos]

The assigned power roles are the most dangerous in the hands of mafia

Oh yeah, a mafia with scanning and protecting abilities: RUN FOR THE HILLS!!!

Why isn't the town lynching this scumbag?

[BSmith]

I concur. Lynch Chaotix!

[Ibn-Khaldun]

You have ~3 hours left for voting.


Tally:
2 DaveShack - Chaotix, Xenoneb
1 Chaotix - Montmorency
1 Jarema - rickinator9
1 rickinator9 - edse


Not voted: classical_hero, King Jan III Sobieski, Ignoramus, DaveShack, Jarema

[Xenoneb]

Why not. Unvote;Vote: Chaotix

[classical_hero]

vote:Choatix

[Ibn-Khaldun]

Day 4 is over!

Tally:
3 Chaotix - Montmorency, Xenoneb, classical_hero
1 DaveShack - Chaotix
1 Jarema - rickinator9
1 rickinator9 - edse

Not voted: King Jan III Sobieski, Ignoramus, DaveShack, Jarema

[DaveShack]

Sorry I missed it, my water heater was leaking and had to be replaced, which kept me away from the computer.

[Ibn-Khaldun]

Write-up will be up soon.. Sry for this delay.. I waited something.

[Ibn-Khaldun]

Day 4

Once the people heard that their King was poisoned the city fell into chaos. After the riots were finally put down by the guards the last people gathered in front of the castle to continue what their King started. That murderer was still out there. Soon, it was clear that Chaotix will be lynched by the mob. As the people moved closer he grabbed his sword, hidden underneath his clothes, and tried to defend himself. He pierced Ignoramus and slashed through King Jan III Sobieski's throat but it didn't help him. His weapons and stuff were taken away and the people stoned him to death.

The list of people in the town:
1. -
2. -
3. -
4. -
5. rickinator9 Noble
6. classical_hero Commoner
7. -
8. edse Commoner
9. Jarema Noble
10. -
11. Montmorency Commoner
12. -
13. DaveShack Commoner
14. -
15. Xenoneb Noble

Royal advisors:
Jarema - Marshal
edse is the Town Watch


Dead:
Ishmael - Commoner, Castle Guard, Innkeeper (Town) (killed N1)
The Celtic Viking - Noble (lynched D2)
Arjos - Commoner, Spy (lynched D3)
atheotes - Commoner, Crusader (Neutral) (killed N3)
BSmith - King (Town) (killed N3)
Chaotix - Commoner, Mercenary (Neutral) (lynched D4)
Ignoramus - Commoner (killed D4) (Town)(WOG)
King Jan III Sobieski - Commoner, Thug (Neutral) (killed D4) (WOG)

Night 4 will end about ~24 hours from this post!

[Arjos]

Har! So many neutrals lol
Anyway with Chaotix out of the way, town can finally protect or scan...

Though right now, I have my money on Xenoneb and Classical as mafia, with an incredible stroke of luck on TCV XD

[Xenoneb]

I'm not mafia.

[Montmorency]

Why exactly were there no alignment reveals for TCV and Arjos? At first I figured lynchees' are omitted, but with Chaotix and the WoGs...

[classical_hero]

vote:Daveshack I am not certain about who to lynch, but this is just a gut feeling.

[Jarema]

well
that post leads me to gut feeling that vote: classical hero is better option

[edse]

Hey! What are you doing out here in the middle of the night? Go back to sleep!

[classical_hero]

I thought it was day, not night. No wonder why there weren't many votes.

[Ibn-Khaldun]

Night 4 is over!

[Ibn-Khaldun]

Night 4

rickinator9 barricaded his door and made other preparations to make sure he will not be another victim to the mysterious killer. After all was done he sat next to his window and being tired from all that work he took a sip of wine. That was the last thing he did. A crossbow bolt pierced his head and he fell to the floor..

The list of people in the town:
1. -
2. -
3. -
4. -
5. -
6. classical_hero Commoner
7. -
8. edse Commoner
9. Jarema Noble
10. -
11. Montmorency Commoner
12. -
13. DaveShack Commoner
14. -
15. Xenoneb Noble

Royal advisors:
Jarema - Marshal
edse is the Town Watch


Dead:
Ishmael - Commoner, Castle Guard, Innkeeper (Town) (killed N1)
The Celtic Viking - Noble (lynched D2)
Arjos - Commoner, Spy (lynched D3)
atheotes - Commoner, Crusader (Neutral) (killed N3)
BSmith - King (Town) (killed N3)
Chaotix - Commoner, Mercenary (Neutral) (lynched D4)
Ignoramus - Commoner (killed D4) (Town)(WOG)
King Jan III Sobieski - Commoner, Thug (Neutral) (killed D4) (WOG)
rickinator9 - Noble (killed N4)

[classical_hero]

Continuing from my night vote, vote:Daveshack

[edse]

Vote: Jarema either he's scum or extremely unlucky.

[Jarema]

Rickinator is listed both as alive and dead...

[Jarema]

vote: Daveshack

last night I targeted Xenoneb. I believe he is not guilty

[Montmorency]

Jarema - this is critical: whom did you target on previous nights?

[Jarema]

night 3: Atheotes. I forgot I cannot target commoners :(
night 2: well, sorry, but I cannot recall. I do not have pm with result. It is even possible that I forgot to do anything (but also possible I deleted that message) :(
night 1: rickinator, I was with him entire night

and as I said before, night 4: Xenoneb. Whole night together

[Ibn-Khaldun]

Rickinator is listed both as alive and dead...

Fixed now.

[Montmorency]

Alright.

Now, I recall some questions raised over the fact that Ishmael, when made Town Watch, was killed immediately - while edse has survived up to this point.

Edse also raises the point that Jarema has never been under any threat.

I think I have an idea of the sequence of events that preceded this day: Ishmael was made TW, killed, Edse was made TW, edse happened to be scum so no one killed edse, scum don't kill Jarema because he is no threat (meaning either no nobles are scum or TCV was scum).

However, on N3 there were two kills, despite edse's being blocked. Chaotix couldn't have done it; he's known to be neutral and his block of edse was confirmed.


On that night of two kills, BSmith the King was one if them. Note the circumstances: Arjos, one of the two assigned power roles, was lynched. There was only one kill last night, during which Xenon was blocked. This might implicate Xenon as the second killer, but it could also mean that there is a specific sine qua non for Mafia to make a second kill (e.g. in the absence of a major role, only on the King etc.) OR that atheotes died by the failure of his own neutral action OR that Xenon is in fact a vig/SK.

On the other hand, Jarema's ignorance of his own action on N2 - the night of no kills - and misaction on N3 - the night of two kills - is suspicious, especially given that he was at that point the only one with access to the King. Did he try to protect Atheotes, forgetting his own limitations, or did he kill him?

But I don't believe Jarema could be scum. If edse is scum, he must have two partners alive - Xenon and Dave, presumably. There isn't another way, if he is scum and was blocked on the night of two kills. In that case, town has already lost. We'll discard it.

Addendum: It is also possible that edse has in fact prevented a kill, one day or another. He should clarify that he has never received news after patrolling the streets.

[Montmorency]

Vote: Xenon

[Xenoneb]

Vote:Montmorency
OMGUS, I know. But it isn't my first vote against you.

[Arjos]

Iirc edse didn't even try to prevent kills, he only "scanned" the streets and was allegedly blocked several times...
No idea about last night though...

[edse]

I'm tempted to call Arjos mafia.

My first night as Town Watch I went to the City Gate Tower. That was because it offers me protection and I thought I was going to be killed as Ishmael was his first night as Town Watch.

The second night I went to the Gate Tower again but was blocked by Chaotix.

Last night I finally patrolled the street with no result.

The only person I might have been able to protect was atheotes but that night I was blocked anyway.