Reworking the mercenary and factional status...

[Brave Brave Sir Robin]

Hmm, I just did every unit so here goes. If you'd like to parse through it Arjos go ahead. A few things you may like to revise anyway. I'm just here to do the grunt work.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Epeiros
Teceitos - Merc
Galathraikes - Merc
Agrianikoi - Merc
Lugoae - Merc
Boii Ciingetos - Merc
Uridusios - Merc
Taxeis Triballoi - Merc
Thraikioi Rhomphaiaphoroi - Merc
Peltastai Makedonikoi - Factional
Thraikioi Doryphoroi - Merc
Hoplitai Haploi - Factional
Gaeroas - Merc
Cordinau Orca - Merc
Hypaspistai - Factional
Illyrioi Thureophoroi - Factional
Keltohellenikoi Hoplitai - Factional
Phalangitai Deuteroi - Factional
Aichmetai Leukanoi - Factional
Thureophoroi - Factional
Hoplitai - Factional
Pezhetairoi - Factional
Thorakitai - Factional
Chaonion Agema - Factional
Sphendonetai - Factional
Toxotai - Factional
Akontistai - Factional
Peltastai - Factional
Thraikioi Hippeis - Merc
Hippeis Tarentinoi - Factional
Somatophylakes Strategou - Factional
Hippeis - Factional
Prodromoi - Factional
Hetairoi Aspidophoroi - Factional
Lonchophoroi Hippeis - Factional
Molosson Agema - Factional
Elephantes Indikoi - Merc
Hippakontistai - Factional
Galatikoi Kluddolon - Merc
Pezoi Brettioi - Factional
Hastati Samnitici - Factional
Illyrioi Paraktioi - Factional
Enoci Curoas - Merc
Samnitici Milites - Factional
Phyletichoi Illyrioi - Factional
Misthophoroi Toxotai Kretikoi - Merc
Misthophoroi Thraikioi Peltastai - Merc
Illyrioi Hippeis - Factional
Hippeis Tarantinoi (Merc) - Merc
Misthophoroi Hippeis - Merc
Misthophoroi Thaikioi Prodromoi - Merc
Hippeis Thessalikoi - Merc
Curepos - Merc
Eqvites Campanici - Merc

Lusitanians
All factional except:
Enoci Curoas
Cuerpos
Qala'im Balearim

Ptolemioi

Anatolikoi Phyletai - Factional
Uazali - Factional
Ioudaioi Taxeis - Factional
Machimoi - Factional
Lugoae - Merc
Pantodapoi - Factional
Aichmetai Noubaioi - Merc
Galatikoi Klerouchoi - Factional
Galatikoi Tindanoae - Merc
'Hanatim Kushim - Factional
Gaeroas - Merc
Machimoi Phalangitai - Merc
Hoplitai Troglodutikes - Factional
Keltohellenikoi Hoplitai - Factional
Thureophoroi - Factional
Hoplitai - Factional
Klerouchoi Phalangitai - Factional
Pezhetairoi - Factional
Thorakitai - Factional
Klerouchon Agema - Factional
Basilikon Agema - Factional
Sphendonetai - Factional
Toxotai - Factional
Akontistai - Factional
Spendonetai Rhodioi - Factional
Bnei Shevet 'Arabim - Factional
Aithiopikoi Toxotai - Factional
Peltastai - Factional
Toxotai Syriakoi - Merc
Machimoi Hippeis - Factional
Aithiopikoi Hippeis - Factional
Thraikioi Hippeis - Merc
Somatophylakes Strategou - Factional
Prodromoi - Factional
Hetairoi Aspidophoroi - Factional
Agema Klerouchon Hippeon - Factional
Lonchophoroi Hippeis - Factional
Galatikoi Lavotuxri - Factional
Hetairoi - Factional
Pilei Ya'ar Libim - Factional
Elephantes Hulaioi Liboukoi - Factional
Hippakontistai - Factional
Parashim 'Arabim Meguiasim - Factional
Galatikoi Kluddolon - Merc
Enoci Curoas - Merc
Aithiopikoi Machairophoroi - Factional
Qala'im 'Arabim - Factional
Misthophoroi Toxotai Kretikoi - Merc
Misthophoroi Thraikioi Peltastai - Merc
Curepos - Merc

[capomafioso]

my revisions of AS and epeiros, possibly not correct.
Epeiros:

Keltohellenikoi Hoplitai - Factional
Taxeis Triballoi - Factional
Hoplitai - Factional
Elephantes Indikoi - Mercenary
Pezoi Brettioi - merc - i dont recall that epeiros was ever allied with the brettioi in fact i recall that the tarantinioi called in epeiros to help fight against them
Hastati Samnitici - merc - same as above
Samnitici Milites - merc - ""
Thraikioi Prodromoi - merc - i just plain disagree, i dont think epeiros owned thracian lands
Thraikioi Hippeis - merc ""
Thraikioi Peltastai - merc - ""
Hippeis Thessalikoi - Mercenary

i feel that as far as AS goes, all galatians should be mercs, IIRC galatia was a mostly autonomous region, also it was claimed by pontos aswell, also as far as gameplay goes i kind of prefer them that way for some reason
Arche Seleukeia:

Anatolikoi Phyletai - Factional
Lugoae - merc
Galatikoi Kuarothoroi - merc
Galatikoi Tindanotae - merc
Gaeroas - merc
Galatikoi Lavotuxri - merc
Galatikoi Kluddolon - merc
Keltohellenikoi Hoplitai - merc
Thraikioi Hippeis - merc - i dont think AS moved into thrace and held those lands long enough
Thraikioi Peltastai - merc
Harmata Drapanephora - Factional
Elephantes Indikoi - Mercenary
Elephantes Kataphraktoi Indikoi - Mercenary
Hippakontistai - Factional
Kôfyârên-î Verkhânâ - Factional
Shipri Tukul - Factional
Gund-î Nîzagân - Factional
Toxotai Kretikoi - merc - they were well known mercenaries

i might be wrong so just tell me if i am

[gamegeek2]

Arjos, why are we making a bunch of GREEK units factional for the DACIAN/GETIC faction?

[Arjos]

i dont recall that epeiros was ever allied with the brettioi in fact i recall that the tarantinioi called in epeiros to help fight against them

Taras called for help against the SPQR, but after few months people from Samnium and neighbouring communities, abandoned Roma to join Pyrros, who promised them local autonomy...
Now I know this happened few years prior to the EB start date, but imo in EBO that isn't such a big deal, especially when we have factions like the KH owning troops from poleis/leagues that were never part of the KH...
But this one is the only point that could go down...

i just plain disagree, i dont think epeiros owned thracian lands

Pyrros was both hailed and later conqueror of the Kingdom of Makedonia, while it's not sure how far south his dominion stretched (Gonatas always regrouped), he most certainly held the north and in Upper Makedonia there were Thraikioi...

i feel that as far as AS goes, all galatians should be mercs, IIRC galatia was a mostly autonomous region, also it was claimed by pontos aswell, also as far as gameplay goes i kind of prefer them that way for some reason

We have examples of Galatikoi siding with usurpers and for example after the treaty of Apamea, they didn't "revolt" against Antiochos Megas for a missing payment (if the Basileus was robbing temples, surely he couldn't pay them), instead the Galatikoi were attacked by Vulso, for the sole reason of having helped Antiochos. In my view all of this points to a symmachia and not to a status of misthophoroi. Some of them were still up for hire, but the tetrarchy (or at least one of the four cantons) always sided with whomever was in power in Anatolia...
Pontos did own the land, because Mithridates invited most of the nobility and assassinated them, but this happened decades after the aforementioned events...

Fact is there were a lot of highland communities and poleis that gained an autonomous status in Anatolia through diplomacy or political choices made by Basileis and the Galatikoi were just one of the many...
Not to mention military settlers and their descendants...

i dont think AS moved into thrace and held those lands long enough

Roman intervention, was mostly due to Antiochos reclaiming the lands of his Progonoi, among these was Thraike, which he secured in 196 BC, refounded Lysimacheia and expanded further north, gaining oaths of allegiance: that gives 6 good years of Seleukid rule...

Kretikoi were well known mercenaries

We know that many Kretikoi went as far as living in Antiocheia and Alexandria, also there are examples of symmachia, like with Doson and there were the so called Neo-Kretikoi, who depending on interpretations, could very well have been Asiatikoi armed and trained in the cretan manner...

Arjos, why are we making a bunch of GREEK units factional for the DACIAN/GETIC faction?

The consensus me and Rob reached so far, was to consider the largest territorial expansion, during the EB time frame, as the base for factional units: Burebista did capture and control all the land from Slovakia to the Black Sea, Kallatis and many other greek colonies were part of that...

[Brave Brave Sir Robin]

Eh, I didn't say that all units within the largest territorial expansion should be factional though...

[Arjos]

He did capture the cities and occupied them, what should we make of that then?
Note for example I didn't add Bouiroi, because they left or were killed...

In this case, Pontos Euxinos Greeks co-existed with Getae for a long time, the latter were even recognized as friends and protectors centuries before Burebista...
Would he pay for their services? I don't think so, they would just get their share of the loot...

But if we want factional to be strictly denoting ethnicity, well let's get ready for 3 Karti factional units at best lol

[Brave Brave Sir Robin]

The thing with Epeiros is this however. When Pyrrhus controlled Makedonia, he took the title of King of Makedonia rather than making Macedon part of Epeirote territory. Essentially in my opinion, his faction at that point would be Makedonia rather than Epeiros, probably since the title being King of Macedon held much more weight than that of Epeiros. I don't think Epeiros should have factional access to Thracians because of this.

Also I don't think that mercenaries in our sense would be the same as mercenaries in real life. It includes those sure, but also would include soldiers who would not necessarily be common in the armies of said factions. The labels of Factional and Mercenary are themselves misleading.