The Castration of Boxing

[johnhughthom]

I think we probably are just differing on semantics. To me, skill is all about physical ability, reflexes, footwork all that stuff. I consider mental toughness and willpower something completely different, though no less important.

[Vuk]

I think we probably are just differing on semantics. To me, skill is all about physical ability, reflexes, footwork all that stuff. I consider mental toughness and willpower something completely different, though no less important.

I agree with you that mental toughness and willpower are not part of 'technical skill'. However I judge 'skill' in a fighting art by how effectively it keeps you alive and takes the other guy down...not just how good you are at your style. Meaning if you are really skilled at a style that is all about crumpling up on the floor when attacked so that your attacker takes pity on you, I would say that you are not as skilled a fighter or martial artist as someone who is skilled at an art that teaches you to effectively neutralize an opponent using strikes to vital areas.
Those I would deem a boxer who is proficient at 1800s boxing to be more skilled than one proficient in modern boxing, because his style demands more and better reflexes, and because he is better suited to survive a real fight.