Results 1 to 30 of 36

Thread: The Banality of Heroism

Hybrid View

Previous Post Previous Post   Next Post Next Post
  1. #1
    has a Senior Member HoreTore's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Norway
    Posts
    12,014

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    Quote Originally Posted by Tiaexz View Post
    Old story of a soldier jumping upon a grenade to save his fellow soldiers from death is often a example of heroism. Might be brave and considered "stupid" in the sense of the action to one self, but it is the whole idea of putting other people before yourself, even as for personal risk.
    That's a great example to use. If I remember correctly, it was an american soldier on patrol in Iraq, right?

    So, the question is why did he throw himself on that grenade? It must be assumed that it was an instinctive action, I can't imagine him thinking anything, much less weighing the options. Was it a special character trait, or was it something that many others, if not most, would have done if put in that same situation?
    Still maintain that crying on the pitch should warrant a 3 match ban

  2. #2
    Voluntary Suspension Voluntary Suspension Philippus Flavius Homovallumus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    Isca
    Posts
    13,477

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    Quote Originally Posted by HoreTore View Post
    That's a great example to use. If I remember correctly, it was an american soldier on patrol in Iraq, right?

    So, the question is why did he throw himself on that grenade? It must be assumed that it was an instinctive action, I can't imagine him thinking anything, much less weighing the options. Was it a special character trait, or was it something that many others, if not most, would have done if put in that same situation?
    There was a British Marine who calmly lay down on top of an IED in Iraq - he calculated that he would probably survive as he was wearing his large pack - he did.

    But only just, if he had laid slightly lower, one of the fragments would have gone through his neck.

    Then there's the guy who went back into he APC to pull his section clear while it was being strafed by an American A-10. Got the George Cross for that one, as Americans aren't the "enemy".
    "If it wears trousers generally I don't pay attention."

    [IMG]https://img197.imageshack.us/img197/4917/logoromans23pd.jpg[/IMG]

  3. #3
    Stranger in a strange land Moderator Hooahguy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    The Fortress
    Posts
    11,852

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    Quote Originally Posted by HoreTore View Post
    That's a great example to use. If I remember correctly, it was an american soldier on patrol in Iraq, right?

    So, the question is why did he throw himself on that grenade? It must be assumed that it was an instinctive action, I can't imagine him thinking anything, much less weighing the options. Was it a special character trait, or was it something that many others, if not most, would have done if put in that same situation?
    Its happened more than once:
    On December 19, 1941 at the Battle of Hong Kong, Canadian Army Company Sergeant Major John Robert Osborn jumped on a grenade, sacrificing himself to save his men. He was posthumously awarded the Victoria Cross.

    On November 7, 1943 at Bougainville, Marine Sergeant Herbert J. Thomas, Jr deliberately fell on a grenade, sacrificing himself protecting nearby Marines.

    On September 1, 1950, near Yongsan, Korea, U.S. Army Private First Class David M. Smith noticed an enemy grenade lobbed into his company's emplacement. Pfc. Smith shouted a warning to his comrades and, fully aware of the odds against him, flung himself upon it. Although he was mortally wounded in this display of valor, his act saved 5 men from injury or death.

    On February 11, 1954, IDF private Nathan Elbaz was disarming grenades when he noticed one of the grenade's safeties had slipped. He grabbed the grenade and ran from the tent but realized he wouldn't be able to throw the grenade away without harming some of his friends, so he smothered the explosion with his body.[3]

    On February 23, 1971, a M35 2½ ton cargo truck was ambushed by a squad of NVA soldiers near An Khê. At one point during the firefight, an NVA soldier threw a fragmentation grenade into the truck's compartment. 21-year-old Specialist Four Larry G. Dahl was the only occupant who heard the grenade land into the truck. Realizing that there was not sufficient time to return it, he immediately threw himself on top of the grenade, saving his comrades' lives but at the cost of his own. Dahl was posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor.

    On April 14, 2004, near Husaybah, Iraq, Jason Dunham used his body and helmet to shield others from a grenade explosion - but died shortly afterward from his injuries.

    On July 26, 2006, IDF Major Roi Klein, during the Battle of Bint Jbeil jumped on a grenade thrown into the house where Klein and his unit were present and stopped the explosion with his body.

    On September 29, 2006 in Iraq, United States Navy SEAL Michael A. Monsoor, died after falling on a grenade.[1]

    On Dec. 4, 2006 in the Iraqi capital Baghdad, 19 year old U.S. Army Spc. Ross A. McGinnis was killed instantly when he used his body to smother a grenade, saving the lives of four nearby soldiers.

    In 2008 near Sangin in Afghanistan Matthew Croucher used his body and rucksack to pin a grenade to the floor. Suffering "just a nose bleed" as a result [2].
    From Wikipedia.

    Why did these people do what they did? If I had to guess, it was because they loved their fellow soldiers more than they loved themselves.
    On the Path to the Streets of Gold: a Suebi AAR
    Visited:
    A man who casts no shadow has no soul.
    Hvil i fred HoreTore

  4. #4
    Voluntary Suspension Voluntary Suspension Philippus Flavius Homovallumus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    Isca
    Posts
    13,477

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    I think a more interesting question at this point is why HoreTore wants to banalise heroism - the most likely answer seems to be that as a socialist he doesn't believe in extraordinary individuals, and is therefore trying to make heroism "ordinary" so that it will fit into his worldview.
    "If it wears trousers generally I don't pay attention."

    [IMG]https://img197.imageshack.us/img197/4917/logoromans23pd.jpg[/IMG]

    Member thankful for this post:



  5. #5
    Stranger in a strange land Moderator Hooahguy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    The Fortress
    Posts
    11,852

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    If heroism was ordinary, society wouldn't make it into a big deal when it occurs.
    On the Path to the Streets of Gold: a Suebi AAR
    Visited:
    A man who casts no shadow has no soul.
    Hvil i fred HoreTore

    Member thankful for this post:



  6. #6
    One of the Undutchables Member The Stranger's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Location
    Nowhere...
    Posts
    11,757

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    heroism can be ordinary as in ordinary people doing something extraordinary (or under extraordinary circumstances) as opposed to a hero being an extra ordinary person doing something in a situation ordinary people would not. and thus society would still make a big deal out of it.

    my opinion is that they are both valid and both occur. sometimes a person is just extraordinary and he does stuff normal people would not do or achieve, for example Nelson Mandela or gandhi. Sometimes it is an extra ordinary situation and an ordinary person does something not all but still more others would do and pull off, like saving someone from a wreckage or from drowning.
    Last edited by The Stranger; 10-15-2012 at 01:27.

    We do not sow.

    Member thankful for this post:

    naut 


  7. #7

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    Is there more to heroism than "socially integrative behavior under duress"?

    Whether the single mom working three jobs or the soldier giving up his spot on the chopper out of the kessel...

    But the more contested definitions are interesting: what about deliberately socially disruptive actions, and not necessarily under duress (from more than a chronically 'degenerate' society, at least).

    On these terms, the successful bomb-lobber seems distinct from the previous examples. Is there another formulation that would link them?

    As for the causes of heroism, well, that's a matter of value: what the hero values - this informs action - and what the labelers value - this informs the selective appellation of "hero".

    In sum: there's nothing banal about the unusual or exceptional - by definition; on the other hand, the roots are...
    Vitiate Man.

    History repeats the old conceits
    The glib replies, the same defeats


    Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 



  8. #8
    Stranger in a strange land Moderator Hooahguy's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    The Fortress
    Posts
    11,852

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    Quote Originally Posted by Montmorency View Post
    As for the causes of heroism, well, that's a matter of value: what the hero values - this informs action - and what the labelers value - this informs the selective appellation of "hero".
    ...which then explains why if you ask most soldiers who are labelled a hero by society if they consider themselves heroes, they will most likely answer that they do not.
    On the Path to the Streets of Gold: a Suebi AAR
    Visited:
    A man who casts no shadow has no soul.
    Hvil i fred HoreTore

  9. #9
    has a Senior Member HoreTore's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Norway
    Posts
    12,014

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    Quote Originally Posted by Philipvs Vallindervs Calicvla View Post
    I think a more interesting question at this point is why HoreTore wants to banalise heroism - the most likely answer seems to be that as a socialist he doesn't believe in extraordinary individuals, and is therefore trying to make heroism "ordinary" so that it will fit into his worldview.
    I am always fascinated by your incredible ability to make things personal.

    Once again though, that accusation belongs in the dustbin.
    Still maintain that crying on the pitch should warrant a 3 match ban

  10. #10
    Voluntary Suspension Voluntary Suspension Philippus Flavius Homovallumus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    Isca
    Posts
    13,477

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    Quote Originally Posted by HoreTore View Post
    I am always fascinated by your incredible ability to make things personal.

    Once again though, that accusation belongs in the dustbin.
    You made a post I consider exceptionally weird - working out why you did is more interesting than your OP.
    "If it wears trousers generally I don't pay attention."

    [IMG]https://img197.imageshack.us/img197/4917/logoromans23pd.jpg[/IMG]

  11. #11
    has a Senior Member HoreTore's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2005
    Location
    Norway
    Posts
    12,014

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    I can certainly answer that question:

    Because I was thinking about Hannah Aarendt in the shower, specifically whether or not it can be applied broader. Heroism seems like a good starting point.
    Still maintain that crying on the pitch should warrant a 3 match ban

  12. #12
    Voluntary Suspension Voluntary Suspension Philippus Flavius Homovallumus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Location
    Isca
    Posts
    13,477

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    Quote Originally Posted by HoreTore View Post
    I can certainly answer that question:

    Because I was thinking about Hannah Aarendt in the shower, specifically whether or not it can be applied broader. Heroism seems like a good starting point.
    Which completely misses the point of heroics - as others have shown.

    Why would you even think heroism could be banal?
    "If it wears trousers generally I don't pay attention."

    [IMG]https://img197.imageshack.us/img197/4917/logoromans23pd.jpg[/IMG]

  13. #13
    Sovereign Oppressor Member TIE Fighter Shooter Champion, Turkey Shoot Champion, Juggler Champion Kralizec's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2005
    Location
    Netherlands
    Posts
    5,812

    Default Re: The Banality of Heroism

    Quote Originally Posted by HoreTore View Post
    Because I was thinking about Hannah Aarendt in the shower
    Whatever makes you happy

    As for your original question, now that I think about it, I guess there's something to say for the position that most human individuals are capable of both doing great evil or good deeds, depending on their situation and their state of mind.

    I imagine that some heroic deeds were done in the heat of the moment, and the person doing it might not have done the heroic thing if he had time to ponder his actions. And also the other way around - people who are naturally cautious and timid, but with strong willpower, might be able to sacrifce themselves after making a conscious decision.

    I'm not sure if it's plausible that someone would by his own initiative sacrifice himself because he thought it was expected of him as opposed to genuine altruism. I wouldn't rule it out.

    Heroic deeds are still admirable even if you take a down-to-earth approach and examine the reasons and motivations, of course.

    Member thankful for this post:



Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO