Academy of Elemental Magic [Concluded]

[Alsark]

To a certain extent, yes. However you are claiming that Autolycus is scummy because he wanted to give stuff to Andres. That would only work if Andres was so inherently scummy that no one in their right mind would have thought him a townie. Yet the only post of any significance that Andres made prior to Autolycus' first 'gift' post was this one in which Andres did a bit of RPing. You are fully entitled to say that RPing like that is scummy, but I would not say it is so inherently scummy that everyone else would immediately see it as such. I certainly didn't see it as a post indicating that Andres was scum, so why would we assume that Autoloycus would have? Thus, there's no particular reason to assume that Autolycus is scummy based on his gifting to Andres. In fact, if what you claim were true, why would Autolycus have split his vote on the potions and offered one to someone else?

I could understand giving him the shield on Day 1, sure - that was mostly just a random giveaway. However, when he just so happens to also give him an item on Day 2, that goes beyond coincidence - especially when Andres isn't at all towny (even if you don't find him scummy, he is neutral at best). And if he gave both potions to Andres that would just be way, way too obvious. Splitting it up makes it more subtle. Also, if they're really elemental defense potions, as I think someone had posted, then maybe Andres needed the water potion more than the muddy potion. Maybe he already has a high Earth defense, which, if they're scum together, Autolycus would know exactly what potion to give his scum buddy.

Isn't it a bit early in the game to be launching a vendetta against a person? Why are you so aggressive in your pursuit of the A-Team?

Lol, you make it sound like I hate the guy(s) - I don't even know anybody here, really, besides Visorslash. I'm just offering my opinion and going through with it.