Academy of Elemental Magic [Concluded]

[seireikhaan]

Out of curiosity, can we know what exactly this investigative item is? Or where it came from?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Out of curiosity, can we know what exactly this investigative item is? Or where it came from?

I have a request for mister Khaan, helpful finder of ye olde scumbags.

I would greatly appreciate some assistance from your College in taking out Ironside. I shouldn't have to tell you that we probably won't lynch him today, particularly without your votes, and that he will undoubtedly expect the attack is coming.

I also don't want to put my own college members of the pain of being asked to attack our HM based on reads and no proof. But I figure since you're Geodudes, you might be more persuaded to attack the college that has been taking potshots at your members. As they were largely coordinated by Ironside and co, now is your chance for a little justice that serves two purposes, revenge and just plain good for town behavior.

As for Edse, I expect I will have not convinced everyone or anyone of his innocence so whoever wishes to can fire at will.

But I'd request a little assistance taking out the Water College's infiltrator, funnily enough, by members of that college. They clearly have one, and IMNSHO it is not Edse for he is the sacrificial lamb targeted by the spoof.

You all personally know that you are not guilty, and if I'm right, you can probably cross off Edse as scummo.

Doesn't Visorslash's change in tone and opinion over the course of the game strike you as the most likely infiltrator of your college?

If you agree, I'd request permissions to attack that man. You need not do the deed yourself unless you want to.

If there is someone else you suspect more, tell me now, we do not have much time to plan our response to the scums.

Prediction is we mislynch someone today and night is supposed to be short, so just like in big team games we need to get ready to do something big tonight and that requires planning ahead.

Assume the lynch is Edse or Xenoneb, and the lynch is bad. Can we agree on tonight's targets and/or a place to start tomorrow?

And don't ask me to scan anything. I have to give this scanning item away today to someone willing to take it, so that there is a chance the scums cannot spoof the investigations anymore. Not that this is my top concern, because as I said before, detectives blow. And I'm not talking about gusts of wind, here.

Do me a favor:

Could a whole bunch of you just send Jarema orders now to "accept" the Lens from Askthepizzaguy? That way, I don't have to reveal in-thread who I am sending it to, and if I give it to a townie, they might actually be able to do something productive with it tonight. I clearly cannot be trusted to provide reliable results because the scums know that I have the item. It's utterly useless in my hands.

[Askthepizzaguy]

And in sending such orders also post in thread that you're a willing and able recipient of the item?

I don't want to give the item to someone who won't accept it, but I do need to keep the scums guessing and I cannot hand it off anonymously any other way besides this.

Also sorry about the lack of time remaining in the round. Took me a while to work this out. You don't mind time pressure, do you, fellow townies?

I think not.

[NinjaCow64]

I'd say go with Pizza. The best course of action would be to lynch edse, nightkill Ironside and if edse comes out guilty or Ironside comes out innocent (which I doubt) then we kill ATPG. Because there are two dangerous types of Pizza, Wrong Pizza and Scumbag Pizza. I shouldn't have to explain why Scumbag Pizza is dangerous (Scumbags are really unpleasant to have down your throat), but Wrong Pizza is just as bad. Wrong Pizza is a Townie Pizza who gets it wrong, yet everyone listens to him. The Mafia enjoy this kind of Pizza, I was laughing my dead Mafioso head off in ATOC on the CFC forums when Pizza was just getting it wrong and the town was following him.

tl;dr: If ATPG's theory is wrong, then lynch him. It's the only way to be sure.

[Ferret]

I would much rather test out ATPG's theory after he's dead. That way if he is lying and turns out to be mafia we won't lose two innocent college heads...

Edit: No but it implies it. That wording can be interpreted in two ways:

1. People that become college heads after the start of the game can be mafia.
2. Starting college heads can become mafia but aren't at the beginning.

I took it to mean the first one but obviously only Jarema knows what he really meant.

[edse]

I would much rather test out ATPG's theory after he's dead. That way if he is lying and turns out to be mafia we won't lose two innocent college heads...

Edit: No but it implies it. That wording can be interpreted in two ways:

1. People that become college heads after the start of the game can be mafia.
2. Starting college heads can become mafia but aren't at the beginning.

I took it to mean the first one but obviously only Jarema knows what he really meant.

In the quicktopic dedicated to the headmaster and wielders of a college Jarema says that both the starting members of the college is innovent. I can only be a cult recruit.

[TinCow]

As a confirmed innocent Air student, I would like to note that I trust Ironside over ATPG. I believe edse should be lynched and, if he flips innocent, we can thing pick between ATPG and Ironside. However, between the two I'd prefer an ATPG lynch. ATPG's actions have increasingly skewed towards his typical anti-town chaos; if someone was recruited I think it's more likely it was ATPG than Ironside. This is exactly the kind of situation that ATPG would engineer to cause chaos in an otherwise relatively peaceful and united town. Still, lynch edse first.

[Jarema]

Edit: No but it implies it. That wording can be interpreted in two ways:

1. People that become college heads after the start of the game can be non-innocents.
2. Starting college heads can become non-innocents but aren't at the beginning.

fxed for you, now it is what I mean (both 1 and 2)

[Jarema]

Tally (I hope):

6 Edse: Elite Ferret, Alsark, issaikhaan, Ironside, Visorslash, johnhughtom
2 Xenoneb: White_eyes:D, Chaotix
2 Ironside: ATPG, edse

5 No Vote: Captain Blackadder, Autolycus, Memnon, Xenoneb, Robbiecon

[NinjaCow64]

FROM TEH RULEZ:

4. Heads of colleges are guaranteed innocents – at least at the begining(sic) of the game.

Doesn't say anything about Headmaster's can't be Mafia. No sir.

[Visor]

Doesn't say anything about Headmaster's can't be Mafia. No sir.

I'll assume that is sarcasm. For our viewers at home however, edse can't be mafia, only cult.