Random-ice-cream-flavoured friends of the friends [Concluded]

[Major Robert Dump]

I am sorry you are being flooded. Pat Robertson says it is because you all are heathens.

I will retaliate vote for Vote: Dark Feather because that is the easiest thing to do short of joining a bandwagon, and a bandwagon sometimes results in FOS later and I don't want that because I hate to be fingered. I do not, however, mind fingering Dark Feather.

[El Barto]

DAY TWO

A plurality of the players agreed to kill B_Ray and then check his papers to see who he was.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

B_Ray: Askthepizzaguy; Montmorency; Lazy McCrow; Elite Ferret; Diana Abnoba (5)
Major Robert Dump: Darth Feather (1)
LazyMcCrow: Makrell (1)
Makrell: edse (1)
Elite Ferret: BSmith106; Chaotix (2)
Montmorency: Jarrrrema; rickinator9 (2)
johnhughscum: Riedquat (1)
edse: Ibn-Khaldun; B_Ray (2)
Darth Feather: Choxorn; Major Robert Dump. (2)
BSmith1068: Visorslash (1)
Jarema: townhughthom (1)

Abstain: Caius (1)

Not voting: Double A, Seon

They showed an unmistakeably Sicilian origin, an unrepentant criminal who'd never been held to account for his crimes.
He was a Mafia.

Living
1. BSmith
2. Chaotix
3. Double A
4. Jarema
5. LazyMcCrow
6. Darth Feather
7. Askthepizzaguy
8. edse
9. Makrell
10. Montmorency
11. rickinator9
12. Riedquat
13. choxorn
14. Caius
15. Seon
16. Diana Abnoba
17. Ibn-Khaldun
18. Elite Ferret
19. Major Robert Dump
20. Visorslash
21. townhughthom

Dead
1. robbiecon, town, killed Night One.
2. B_Ray, Mafia, lynched Day Two.

Time remaining: .

[Montmorency]

Can I call 'em, or can i call 'em?

Well, I've done my part. Carry on with the good fight, fellow townies.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I still admit nothing.

[Darth Feather]

Is this a sign Makrell and Montmorency are scum as well?

On a more serious note, I am quite suspicious of edse. B_Ray voted edse in his last dying post. That might have been a way to clear edse (as it was obvious he would die)

True, it is still a lot of speculation, but fish FoS: edse

[Jarema]

I would rather FoS: Diana Abnoba for putting vote on B_Ray when he has four votes on him already. Seems like a mafia partner trying to capitalize on death of buddy scum

[edse]

Is this a sign Makrell and Montmorency are scum as well?

On a more serious note, I am quite suspicious of edse. B_Ray voted edse in his last dying post. That might have been a way to clear edse (as it was obvious he would die)

True, it is still a lot of speculation, but fish FoS: edse

B_Ray was basically lynched for putting a third vote on me day 1. That would have been quite a risky move if the consensus would have been that we wanted a lynch on day 1.

[Makrell]

Is this a sign Makrell and Montmorency are scum as well?

On a more serious note, I am quite suspicious of edse. B_Ray voted edse in his last dying post. That might have been a way to clear edse (as it was obvious he would die)

True, it is still a lot of speculation, but fish FoS: edse

please, explain why this is a sign(hint its not)

[LazyMcCrow]

I would rather FoS: Diana Abnoba for putting vote on B_Ray when he has four votes on him already. Seems like a mafia partner trying to capitalize on death of buddy scum

Nope. Both Diana and myself voted B_Ray on day 1 and the vote was too close - So Diana is innocent as far as I'm concerned. You however are far more suspicious, given your vote on Monty. It is clear that Monty is innocent and a vote for him is an attempt to lynch an 'easy target' - given his disturbing demeanour. Darth Feather and Makrell also whiff a bit given their contributions thusfar. FOS Jarema

[Darth Feather]

please, explain why this is a sign(hint its not)

B_Ray was scum. He was certain he would die (or as certain as you can be in this game). If he votes for a scumbuddy, that would give said scum credibility. That's why I FoSsed edse.

EDIT: I read edse's defense and it is indeed quite solid. so unfish FoS: edse

EDIT²: Suppose someone tried to loosen pressure on B_Ray, then the most sensible manouvre would be to second-vote: so that means either Chaotix or rickinator9 are suspicious.

[Major Robert Dump]

I very seriously doubt the mafia all know who each other are this early in the game.

I would also be willing to bet there is more than one mafia faction due to the number of players

[LazyMcCrow]

I did say 'mostly simple affair' in the OP. ;)

I very seriously doubt the mafia all know who each other are this early in the game.

I would also be willing to bet there is more than one mafia faction due to the number of players

Host intimates there might be some basis to your theory. What prompted your observation specifically?

[Darth Feather]

I very seriously doubt the mafia all know who each other are this early in the game.

I never said all mafia know each other. In fact, there might be more than one team out there. I was just saying if B_Ray was not alone on a team (which is a quite safe assumption IMHO) someone might have tried to depressurise him. Out of Chaotix and rickinator9, I think chaotix is the most dubious one. Claims to hate the bandwagons and still places a second vote on EF.

[Ferret]

Fish FoS: Ibn-Khaldun

For thinking just like B_Ray.

[Chaotix]

I never said all mafia know each other. In fact, there might be more than one team out there. I was just saying if B_Ray was not alone on a team (which is a quite safe assumption IMHO) someone might have tried to depressurise him. Out of Chaotix and rickinator9, I think chaotix is the most dubious one. Claims to hate the bandwagons and still places a second vote on EF.

Two votes does not a bandwagon make, friend.

Obviously in this case the bandwagon was the right choice after all, which makes me look bad after the fact.

Anyway, I never claimed to hate bandwagons themselves. What I do hate is when a bandwagon gets so far ahead in the beginning of the round that it becomes insurmountable by mid-way. It's better to have choices to be able to adapt to new developments later in the phase. B_Ray had four votes on him before anyone else had two, which is why I tried to bump up a contender.

[Darth Feather]

Fish FoS: Ibn-Khaldun

For thinking just like B_Ray.

I think I-K is not very likely to be scum (or at least not likely to be teamed up with B_Ray.) I don't think B_Ray would be voting for edse if he saw his scum-buddy was already voting for him. Again a lot of speculation, but he is not very likely to be scum IMO.

Of course, someone who voted completely differently can be scum as well, but they blend in, so they are hard to notice.

[Jarema]

It's better to have choices to be able to adapt to new developments later in the phase

but it can also work for mafia advantage

[El Barto]

People, let me remind you that PMs are allowed at night.

[Askthepizzaguy]

People, let me remind you that PMs are allowed at night.

If the mafia haven't sent in their orders yet, may I send them in for them?

That would be an awesome way to penalize them.

[Major Robert Dump]

Host intimates there might be some basis to your theory. What prompted your observation specifically?

My role PM

[El Barto]

If the mafia haven't sent in their orders yet, may I send them in for them?

That would be an awesome way to penalize them.

What? No. It's bad enough that you're ubiquitously capitalised, now you want a tax break. No way.

[El Barto]

NIGHT TWO

edse was found dead in the morning.
He was an Innocent.

Living
1. BSmith
2. Chaotix
3. Double A
4. Jarema
5. LazyMcCrow
6. Darth Feather
7. Askthepizzaguy
8. Makrell
9. Montmorency
10. rickinator9
11. Riedquat
12. choxorn
13. Caius
14. Seon
15. Diana Abnoba
16. Ibn-Khaldun
17. Elite Ferret
18. Major Robert Dump
19. Visorslash
20. townhughthom

Dead
1. robbiecon, town, killed Night One.
2. B_Ray, Mafia, lynched Day Two.
3. edse, town, killed Night Two.

Time remaining: .

[Montmorency]

yo mrd wats up

[B-Wing]

They say the good die young.

[Major Robert Dump]

yo mrd wats up

Oh just having a beer and watching a movie?
Want to come over?

Oh, you mean whats up in the game? I'm a snitch. A turncoat. I hate mafia, they ruined my life and impregnated my sister with a little greasy retard baby. They owe me 6 months of back pay, their dental plan is crap, and there is a total glass ceiling making it impossible to get promoted. Screw the mafia. I dare the mafia to come kill me, because I will take your stupid mafia gun from you, shove it up your butt and pull the trigger until it goes CLICK

[Askthepizzaguy]

Whyfor did not any of these people get murderized?

Askthepizzaguy; Montmorency; Lazy McCrow; Elite Ferret; Diana Abnoba

[Darth Feather]

Whyfor did not any of these people get murderized?

Askthepizzaguy; Montmorency; Lazy McCrow; Elite Ferret; Diana Abnoba

They must all be scum !!!!!

[Choxorn]

Vote: Darth Feather

Clearly has Perfect Information Syndrome, he knows all 5 of those people are scum.

[Darth Feather]

Vote: Darth Feather

Clearly has Perfect Information Syndrome, he knows all 5 of those people are scum.

I was just trying to find a logical answer for ATPG's question.


It means I was just kidding

[Darth Feather]

Now more seriously: if MRD indeed can see in his job description there are more than one scum team, why do we only have one kill per night?