Random-ice-cream-flavoured friends of the friends [Concluded]

[Darth Feather]

Maybe DoubleA is scum: vote: DoubleA (due to one kill per night and inactivity, even though announced. )

[Askthepizzaguy]

They must all be scum !!!!!

Impossible. I've already been scum working with Diana at least four times off the top of my head [FightforInishmoreTheOrgMafiaLegendOfZeldaCapoIV] so a fifth time would be just overkill.

And I bet that's not even all of the instances. Kind of frightening when I think about it.

Vote: Diana probably scum this time.

[LazyMcCrow]

Impossible. I've already been scum working with Diana at least four times off the top of my head [FightforInishmoreTheOrgMafiaLegendOfZeldaCapoIV] so a fifth time would be just overkill.

And I bet that's not even all of the instances. Kind of frightening when I think about it.

Vote: Diana probably scum this time.

So you're saying Diana voted for a scum - despite being scum. So you're saying she's on a different team? Seems you know too much. vote: ATPG

[Askthepizzaguy]

So you're saying Diana voted for a scum - despite being scum. So you're saying she's on a different team? Seems you know too much. vote: ATPG

When did I say any of those things?

[LazyMcCrow]

When did I say any of those things?

You are aware that Diana voted for B_Ray - who was mafia. That made me pretty certain that Diana was innocent. Of course, it could be that Diana is a scum of a different flavour...pistachio perhaps? and was unaware of B_Rays scumminess, but as we've only had a single kill two nights running, we've either got awol scum, or just one flavour. Anyway, that's all a possibility, but your vote mentions none of that - its just light-hearted and anecdotal. It uses the word 'impossible'. The only way your post would have seemed scummier to me would have been if you had used the word 'inconceivable' instead :)

After a read through I still find Jarema a bit suspect - and we know that Jarema is always scum = scientific fact, so we can lynch him later - Also Choxorn and possible kumquat would be up there as potential votes for me - but basically your post made me vote for you.

[Visor]

I've had more then a fair few drinks. (all Guinness, townhughthom would be proud).

That said I need to say some things before I forget. I mmight post them next. After I actually look at the thread,

[Visor]

Edse was obviously considered a good idea by B_Ray, so depending on whether who voted first...

Which IK didn't, so He is obviosuly not scum with BRay, no scum team would be that obvious.

Vote: Chatoix Mafiatiox Chaotix

Too easy a vote for me here. The guniness sings for thee, Chaotix.

[Montmorency]

Random.org!

Vote: Makrell

[Visor]

Though I must admit I am tempted to vote BSmith again.

Choxorn is another I would FoS;.

[Visor]

Random.org!

Vote: Makrell

Your random.org sickens me.

We both know, it is not randmon.orged.

[Darth Feather]

I am suspicious of Chaotix as well, but I am not going to vote him (yet), but I think Double A is a safer bet (because the major said there are more than one team.)

You better not be scum, Major Robert Dump.

You really mean Randmon.org (?)

[Visor]

I am suspicious of Chaotix as well, but I am not going to vote him (yet), but I think Double A is a safer bet (because the major said there are more than one team.)

You better not be scum, Major Robert Dump.

I have trouble lynching mRD at the best of times. He's too funny to lynch. Lynch Mafiotix.

[Darth Feather]

Let's give him a chance to defend himself @mafiotix









I am perfectly aware this link is not working, so no need to point out.

[Visor]

Let's give him a chance to defend himself @mafiotix

It's not like you gave AA one?

[Darth Feather]

He told in the beginning of the thread he would be AWOL in the beginning of the game, so even if I gave him the chance he would not be able to take it.

[Visor]

He told in the beginning of the thread he would be AWOL in the beginning, so even if I gave him the chance he would not be able to take it.

Eh, mafia isn't 2 people. Poor vote.

[Darth Feather]

ok, if you insist: @Double A : Defend yourself!!

And he might be a SK (just saying...)

[Visor]

Highly unlikely.

Vote: Mafiotes Mafiotix Chaotix

[Darth Feather]

Highly unlikely.

Care to explain why?

[Visor]

Care to explain why?

Double A not sending in a least one order? Eh, don't buy him being SK atm, and certainly not worth a lynch just yet. FoS Dath Feather

[Darth Feather]

Ok, I'll unvote for now. Vote: nobody ATM. Let's wait a little while longer. If the killing increases when Double A returns, we can still lynch him.

[Darth Feather]

Damn underlined instead of bolding: vote: Darth Feather for underlining instead of voting

But as he is not scum I am going to unvote, Vote: Chaotix. Defend yourself.

[Jarema]

I wanted to vote for Darth Feather for a moment. But he is acting in a way that attracts much attention. Scum would not do that.
I will rather vote: MRD

[Choxorn]

Why is Chaotix mafia?

[Diana Abnoba]

I do agree with the FOS and even the votes on Chaotix, but Jarema's post just pinged me, so...

Vote: Jarema
Your logic makes no sense to me, you didn't vote Darth Feather because he is "acting in a way that attracts much attention", but so is MRD, but you voted for him. This sounds to me like a mafia trying to come up with a reason to vote someone, instead of a townie trying to find scum IMHO.



BTW, Pizza, what is up with you, no logic at all in your post. That's not like you . FOS Pizza.

[Darth Feather]

I explained yesterday why he COULD be mafia: not saying he is for sure, but this is the post where I made my vague assumption

Suppose someone tried to loosen pressure on B_Ray, then the most sensible manouvre would be to second-vote: so that means either Chaotix or rickinator9 are suspicious.

I never said all mafia know each other. In fact, there might be more than one team out there. I was just saying if B_Ray was not alone on a team (which is a quite safe assumption IMHO) someone might have tried to depressurise him. Out of Chaotix and rickinator9, I think chaotix is the most dubious one. Claims to hate the bandwagons and still places a second vote on EF.

[Major Robert Dump]

Now more seriously: if MRD indeed can see in his job description there are more than one scum team, why do we only have one kill per night?

I never said that.

I said, in post 161:
I very seriously doubt the mafia all know who each other are this early in the game.

I would also be willing to bet there is more than one mafia faction due to the number of players



The first line is common mafia regulations. Very rarely do the mafioso know who the others are. It would make them OP. And often in the event that mafia start knowing who the other teammates are, it is because there is more than one mafia faction.

The second line is simply an observation.

Lazy McCrow asked in post 162:
Host intimates there might be some basis to your theory. What prompted your observation specifically?

Except he does not specify which theory. Notice the singular "observation." Well, it turns out I presented two theories. Not being in the mood to split hairs in response to vague questions and a subtle attempt at fishing -- I answered "In my role PM" just before the buzzer in hopes that mafia would take a shot at me because I threaten them, or that someone from town would start sending me night PMs. I got neither, as far as I know. Townies should not punish me for giving a vague answer to an even more vague question.

In fact I have no reason to believe there is more than one faction. I do, however, have reason to believe that there is more than one snitch. I also think there may be a way to turn a mafioso into a snitch. I would also wager that the mafia team gets some sort of bonus for finding and killing the snitches, which is one more reason I am bringing all this up now -- come get me you Canoli eating greaseballs

I suppose now is a good time to also let you know that if the town investigator does a background check on me, it is going to be muddled because of the person I used to be. Same for the other snitches, if they exist.

[Askthepizzaguy]

You are aware that Diana voted for B_Ray - who was mafia. That made me pretty certain that Diana was innocent. Of course, it could be that Diana is a scum of a different flavour...pistachio perhaps? and was unaware of B_Rays scumminess, but as we've only had a single kill two nights running, we've either got awol scum, or just one flavour. Anyway, that's all a possibility, but your vote mentions none of that - its just light-hearted and anecdotal. It uses the word 'impossible'. The only way your post would have seemed scummier to me would have been if you had used the word 'inconceivable' instead :)

After a read through I still find Jarema a bit suspect - and we know that Jarema is always scum = scientific fact, so we can lynch him later - Also Choxorn and possible kumquat would be up there as potential votes for me - but basically your post made me vote for you.

Yakk yakk yakk yakk. All this boils down to is that you invented a "gotcha" out of thin air that didn't exist.

I didn't say any of the things you voted me for, which would have been a clever "get" if I had said them, but I didn't.

Why is that? Are you just a very, very bad townie, or are you a sloppy scumbag?

[Askthepizzaguy]

BTW, Pizza, what is up with you, no logic at all in your post. That's not like you . FOS Pizza.

Logic comes later. First comes the poking and the prodding....

Gosh that sounds dirty.

[Chaotix]

ITT:

Darth Feather: Chatoix, I think yous are the mafia. Defend yourself.
Visorslash: Agreed, Choatix is mafia. Defend yourself, @Chotoaxz.

Chaotix: Vote: johnhughscum