“As I have shown” You have shown nothing. I can give you it is difficult as there is no “Communist” My Kampf. You just can describe various episodes of the USRR and others in order to sustain your claim.
“communist IDEOLOGY” You are just plain wrong. What the Communist Manifesto is describing is a consequence, not a tool.
“Communists wanted to send both the NAME and the PEOPLE into oblivion.” Your readings of it (and Lenin and Stalin), not what the Communist Manifesto tells.
“communist ideology (as expounded by Lenin and Stalin)” Communist Ideology is not define by the two you named, who were as well dictators. So what is part of Dictatorship and Ideology? In Nazism, you don’t have the same problem as Nazism is Dictatorship.
“Flawed comparison. You can't compare a book and an organization. You may do it with Hitlerjugend and Scouts, if you wish.” Well, it is what you do, I just return the favour. You pretend because superficial similarities that Communist Ideology and Nazi Ideology are similar (I know, it is not what you are actually writing, but deeper we go in this exchange, it looks like it is the direction you are aiming to). So I choose an example to show you can do this to each organisation.
“You really should do something with the memory or refer to the earlier posts.” It is because you are a little bit chaotic, so I have to remind you of what you wrote. "Ideology of Communism has some similar features:exporting socialist revolution (which can be equated to expanding the ideoligically friendly space), superiority of one social group (proletariat), annihilation of class enemies and their minions."
My answer to this was: “Nope. There is no equivalent in Communist Ideology of My Kampf. Nazism is quite unique in this (well, excepted of course the main 3 monotheistic religions, and probably the polytheistic as well, but I am not sure of the last ones).”
Note that you did cut the part on others violent and aggressive ideologies having much more in common with Nazism than Communism.
You still fail to define the Communist Ideology, as obviously to retract rightly from the idea of the Communist Manifesto could play this role. Just in France, the Anarchist movement produced a lot of literature and ideas about what Communism is/was about (i.e. Manifesto of the Equals (1796)). And the same can be said for the Socialist Movement and indeed the Communist Movement.
"Classes can't disappear after a decree was issued" Really? I just gave you an exemple when one, Nobility, just did.
Bookmarks