Pirate Ship Mafia III [Concluded]

[Csargo]

It wouldn't have changed much for your team because I had been telling Visor and the captain I would leave any night they ordered me off the ship, no questions asked. When I didn't do so I would always be the lynch the next day. I also spread it around publicly that I would leave if asked. So I did that to discourage myself from being recruited.

At that time, because Visor began suspecting the thieves, I was going to be asked to leave soon, so I felt like I'd rather leave now than wait much longer. It was a good idea, it denies recruits to the French. I also said I'd have to leave if I was scanned susceptible to conversion and not made into an officer, because eventually, I would become an obvious convert from the ever shrinking pool.

I had been playing a fairly anti-French game despite my lack of desire in forming groups and also doing vigs, I didn't even want to appear in protection groups because I wanted the fairness that comes with the ambiguity of having to trust the folks I said I had stolen from as being reliable witnesses to my own location, obviously, the French could have said they had stolen from a convert for example. It's risky but it's one way of blending in. The trouble is not enough townies did what I was doing.

I wanted there to be room for the French to do what they were doing without it being a simple solve by spreadsheet, but I also wanted to fight the French at every turn and find them myself.

I also wanted to accumulate gold from my fellow players as part of the sport of the game because otherwise it totally overlooks that mechanic. I felt like it needed more than a token nod from the players.

I get that some folks wanted to simply catch all the french by vigging and lynching as much as possible, and I don't begrudge them that, but I also thought that stealing and the bonuses associated with stealing should be emphasized.

I believe the folks who did stealing often got triggered an event just for them that made it much more profitable to steal, that one night, which encouraged them to not participate in night actions.

That sort of thing was really good, fun, and balanced- I think if the thefts were a bit more dire, as opposed to likely not being as good as a protect that did nothing, and people lost more gold that way or gained more gold that way, more people would have bothered protecting their own stashes and stealing.

As it stood, most of the thieves in the game were kind enough not to steal from the same person over and over again, and more people were attacking and defending, so there wasn't much worry about being stolen from in general.

I could be wrong, I know Visor got stolen from a lot just as an example. The officers are generally sitting duck steal targets.

After Ishmael died our VC was based on gold, so I chose you and El Barto because I thought you two would have the most gold. I don't know what exactly the other orders were for last, but we were planning to leave until BSmith got auto and me by killing him. We weren't sticking around.

[El Barto]

After Ishmael died our VC was based on gold, so I chose you and El Barto because I thought you two would have the most gold.

This be unfriendly o' ye. I's sendin' Arrrskthepizzaguy ta repossess yer goods.

[Csargo]

This be unfriendly o' ye. I's sendin' Arrrskthepizzaguy ta repossess yer goods.

Why's that?

[El Barto]

Although in fairness, you only received 1 gold from my will (sorry about that, by the way!).

But tha' meant ye fulfilled yer deal -an' did outbid wee Visorslashie. Incident'lly, deals such as yers were wha' got AdmiralHankerchief ta pay me me bonuses fer host amusemen' an' consisten' roleplayin'.

Why's that?

Ye war covetin' our gold! An' also, ye be dead noo an' has left gold strewn around, we must repossess it afore anywan else do it!

[Visor]

I'd like to thank The Flax and presumably landlubber for their kind donations to the visor fund. Gave me a shot in the gold race.

[Zack]

I expressed this in private to some, and while I don't know the actual details of the role, just what Double A told me, TheFlax's role seemed problematic. The Captain can choose at any time to make Flax an officer, they both win, and everyone else loses? What was the thought process behind that role, because to me it looks... poorly designed, to put it diplomatically. Of course, Flax could have simply been lying.

[Zack]

Autolycus
How do you want to play this, with Zack wanting us both in the landlubber kill?

Ishmael
I think it might be hard to beg off the kill, especially since we're both on the same one. As much as it pains me to say it, we might have to go along with it tonight and delay recruiting Csargo until the next night phase.

See, my efforts that night weren't a complete waste.

[GeneralHankerchief]

What was the thought process behind that role, because to me it looks... poorly designed, to put it diplomatically. Of course, Flax could have simply been lying.

Ouch, my secret roles have been taking a beating so far in this game! He wasn't lying, I'll address my thinking behind that one as well when I get to it. For now, though, I have an epilogue to finish.