Quote Originally Posted by Papewaio View Post
They volunteered it was their choice. It wasn't Empire demanding for them to join up, nor after independence joining the Commonwealth.

It is a rebuttal that Muslims and Indians in general did not chose to fight alongside the British. If they were anti British you will have to explain the largest volunteer fighting force the world has ever seen being on the British side.
There were enough Indians for many millions to be both violently for and violently against the Commonwealth, as well as many more who were apathetic or some more nuanced position.