Mafia v. Cult [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

Whaddya reckon, three mafia left? I think 3 mafia with 20 players and a second scum team fwiw

2 cult players max or something?

That is likely. But it's also possible they have 1.

Try to convert a mafioso or try to convert an unconvert-able. I forgot what day it is, but cult is at 1-2 persons imo.

2 mafioso is also possible, but I'd put 3 if i were designing it.

[Visor]

That is likely. But it's also possible they have 1.

Try to convert a mafioso or try to convert an unconvert-able. I forgot what day it is, but cult is at 1-2 persons imo.

2 mafioso is also possible, but I'd put 3 if i were designing it.

i was more worried about the possibility of 4 maf.

It occurs to me 2 things

1. Cult could deliberately not recruit 'obvious' converts
2. jarrema would have recruited me if he was cult leader

[Askthepizzaguy]

Not my top priority but it still needs to be addressed

Can you / others help me look at GH

I don't think he was starting cult. What changed in his reads if anything did, and is it even significant.

Really no reason for GH to change his reads and make it obvious. But it's worth looking at even a little bit just in case there is something there that could reveal a clue about who else may be on that team or who recruited, or at the very least, someone who the cult team wants to eliminate and doesn't want to convert- such as a mafioso.

It's possible there's subtle knowledge from the cult left behind which could help us lynch mafia today.

[Visor]

Not my top priority but it still needs to be addressed

Can you / others help me look at GH

I don't think he was starting cult. What changed in his reads if anything did, and is it even significant.

Really no reason for GH to change his reads and make it obvious. But it's worth looking at even a little bit just in case there is something there that could reveal a clue about who else may be on that team or who recruited, or at the very least, someone who the cult team wants to eliminate and doesn't want to convert- such as a mafioso.

It's possible there's subtle knowledge from the cult left behind which could help us lynch mafia today.

I also agree that he was highly likely to be a recruit.

[Visor]

At a guess I think he was recruited after the khaan lynch. Or sometime after that.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Absent that I'm lynching based on what I see as guilty in-thread behavior.

If Visor were mafia I'd be dead by now.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I will look at it after Sooh goes to work if I have the time, otherwise I'm welcoming opinions on either subject

a) people are mafia because _____
b) analysis of the revealed cultists and who you think the leader is, and who is specifically not cult right now

If anyone wants to put that level of effort in. I kind of do but I could easily see myself not doing it and just yolo'ing mafia suspects until town wins because mafia killed the cult off and we lynched mafia, or I get converted and then hunting the mafia becomes ridic simple.

[Visor]

Oh, before I forget.

One of the reasons I was suspicious of choxorn was his blatant parroting for no reason of your 'case' on me.

Especially the lack of justification which is normally seen by choxorn and the fact that he had obviously read the thread if he had seen the case but had nothing else to comment on just struck me as suspicious.

[Jarema]

1. Cult could deliberately not recruit 'obvious' converts
2. jarrema would have recruited me if he was cult leader

1. Of course, but IMO GH was 'obvious' convert
2. agreed :)

I still think that vote: ATPG must be scum now

[Visor]

Cmon mate, that ain't gonna fly.

Why is he scum?

Reasons please.

[Jarema]

I stated it already I think, and this is almost self-explaining.

He is ATPG.
I try to think 'whom I would recruit if I was a cult leader?'
then, my short list was on day one: ATPG, GH, Visor, Zack.
If I was a cult leader, they all would be cultists by now

[Visor]

I stated it already I think, and this is almost self-explaining.

He is ATPG.
I try to think 'whom I would recruit if I was a cult leader?'
then, my short list was on day one: ATPG, GH, Visor, Zack.
If I was a cult leader, they all would be cultists by now

We want to lynch mafia not cult.

Vote: Jarrema

[Jarema]

I want to lynch any scum.
And there is of course possibility that ATPG is mafia - he is still alive after all.

Do you think I am mafia?

[Askthepizzaguy]

i was more worried about the possibility of 4 maf.

It occurs to me 2 things

1. Cult could deliberately not recruit 'obvious' converts
2. jarrema would have recruited me if he was cult leader

Mafia not cult imo.

[Visor]

Mafia not cult imo.

Yeah he definitely more likely mafia than cult.

re the giraffeboards game

that was a very limited cult and not what you would typically expect.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Yeah he definitely more likely mafia than cult.

re the giraffeboards game

that was a very limited cult and not what you would typically expect.

Yeah, not really useful for analysis anyway but what the heck, maybe I display different behavior after conversion.

I know I was all serious bsns after I got converted.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Visor, any of those seem likely to be townies to you?

I think I die shortly, so let's use the time.

[Visor]

Visor, any of those seem likely to be townies to you?

I think I die shortly, so let's use the time.

As far as I am aware there are no townies in this game.

You'd be the closest one.

I don't have ANY town reads.

Basically shooting into a barrel.

[Askthepizzaguy]

full re-read before I go