Quote Originally Posted by Post 1065: On Visor
No offense to Visor, but I'm no longer reading his alignment based off of his day one "suspicions". He has admitted in several games that he doesn't put much thought into them.

And this is a guy I greatly respect for his town and his mafia game. I just know that the good stuff comes later, if it does. Or he's scum.

Or it's that 1 out of 20 really bad town games.
Quote Originally Posted by Post 1070: ON Khaan
Not as useful given the short time frame. It's been forever since I squared off against mafia-you. I don't think your meta has changed that much in nearly a decade of playing so I'm trusting what I remember from really long ago.

[...]

My quality of analysis is proportional to the length of time I'm alive.
Quote Originally Posted by Post 1114: On Candidates
I request anyone available who is voting novice and has a case for doing so please link me to said case or restate it.

2 CrimsonFox (Winston Hughes, khaan) <--------Not voting here
1 BSmith (novice)
1 Choxorn (Al Sips)
1 Cuthillius (Stork)
1 Dp101 (GeneralHankerchief) <-----no
1 Montmorency (Pelican) <-------no
1 seireikhaan (CrimsonFox)
1 Winston Hughes (john) <-------no

In case you're voting for non-novice or non-Reidquat and want my vote on the non-no people above, lmk that as well.
Quote Originally Posted by Post 1139: Asking DP101
Visor, Cuthillius, atheotes, BSmith

^Which is the worst looking?
Quote Originally Posted by Post 1230: Asking Winston to clarify on his opinion of Visor's scumminess
Quote Originally Posted by Winston Hughes
I've seen a lot of Visor's game in the last couple of years, and feel like I've got pretty good at reading his flow.

Could be that I've been totally tilted here, but his process and vibe on D1 seemed very much in his scum zone, and I've seen nothing since that wouldn't fit there.
Could you compare it directly with a specific game?
Also now, Winston needs to acknowledge how bad almost all of his reads have been so far.

Quote Originally Posted by Post 1272: Pizza gladhanding Cuthilius on the back of Visor
But seeing you play this way as your second game ever gives me great hope for the future generation of mafia players.

I remember a young Visorslash when he was about yea high in post count, and I sensed that he would become mightier than myself.

Should thou be scum this game, I shall nickname thee Visorslash 2: Visor slashier.
Quote Originally Posted by Post 1273: See above
My boner-pulling highlight reel will always be 10 times as massive as my awesome reel. Thus is the nature of this game for just about everyone.

Unless you're Visorslash, in which case I will repeatedly bring up the only two-ish times he's ever screwed up just to help me feel less bad.