Tokens of My Confection [Concluded]

[Zack]

It's more reason then you gave for voting me

[Dp101]

It's more reason then you gave for voting me

I mean, I'm voting you because someone who is now confirmed town saw you as mafia, and while following the dead is generally a bad move due to the gamestate changing since their death, there has really been nothing interesting going on during the night so their words still have merit. Basically, their case is better than anything I can come up with right now, so I'm sheeping Monty.

[Zack]

I mean, I'm voting you because someone who is now confirmed town saw you as mafia, and while following the dead is generally a bad move due to the gamestate changing since their death, there has really been nothing interesting going on during the night so their words still have merit. Basically, their case is better than anything I can come up with right now, so I'm sheeping Monty.

he was lynched so who cares what his reads were

not like he was killed because he suspected me

mindlessly sheeping a townie who was lynched d1 is ridiculous

[Zack]

I saw you in futurama and I have a hard time believing you think your best option here is to exasperatedly throw up your hands and say, "well, better just sheep a dead guy and give no effort to actually solve anything!"

[Dp101]

I saw you in futurama and I have a hard time believing you think your best option here is to exasperatedly throw up your hands and say, "well, better just sheep a dead guy and give no effort to actually solve anything!"

Did you really see me in Futurama and think I'm not the kind of person who sheeps people for poor reasons? I sheeped horribly that game, it's why I lost. Besides, I'm not just sheeping, I could have sworn I posted my own opinion earlier about finding your tone and stuff similar to how Monty played when he was mafia, which is my own opinion and not sheeping at all, I just mentioned it because you were looking for more reasons and I thought that you must have missed my support of prior arguments, and also was really just grabbing at anything to add to my case, since I know that people want a variety of reasons even if I only believe in one of them. This post is probably rather incoherent, so I will stop here. I have to do something else now, I might shift my vote when I get back to something better once I have stepped away and cleared my head.

[Newyn]

I don't understand your last sentence. Do you have an investigative role or something?

If I did have a certain investigative role, then yes, that was totally me openly breadcrumbing. Of course, I might just be a vt hoping to draw a nk. Think what you will.
Are you fishing for PRs or something?

[Dp101]

If I did have a certain investigative role, then yes, that was totally me openly breadcrumbing. Of course, I might just be a vt hoping to draw a nk. Think what you will.
Are you fishing for PRs or something?

No, just confused and wanting clarification. Looking back, me saying anything at all was probably a horrific mistake if you are indeed a PR.

[Scarlett Aria]

That's fine, but what you said was that you expected a bit more from him. As in, "what he's done so far is ok, but I expect a bit more.". But he hadn't done anything at all yet.

I never said it was ok either just that I expected him to do more except that vote. This type of question with entering words in my mouth is wolfy.

[Riedquat]

Did you really see me in Futurama and think I'm not the kind of person who sheeps people for poor reasons?

But Dp has a point there, also I almost agree with him about your behavior Zack.... you are acting weird for whatever reason...

[novice]

Where is everybody?

I saw you in futurama and I have a hard time believing you think your best option here is to exasperatedly throw up your hands and say, "well, better just sheep a dead guy and give no effort to actually solve anything!"

In fairness, there really isn't that much to solve yet. However, if you think sheeping went so horribly last game, Dp, why are you doing it again?

Scarlett, I'm not trying to put words in your mouth, I'm trying to illustrate why I find your "a bit more" phrasing strange.
So you expected Cuthilius to do "a bit more" than just put down a one-word vote. I don't find that explanation very convincing, but there's not much you can do about that. I also don't find your townread on Winston based on the idea that a scum Winston would have problems posting off topic very convincing.

I tried to see if the Choxorn kill could tell us anything. The only non-random reason I can see is if Cuthilius is scum and they wanted Choxorn off his back. That seems pretty far-fetched though.

I'm liking NAC today, and I don't think Zack or Dp are the best lynches either. I'd side with Zack over Dp currently.

Let's see if anybody else has feelings for
Vote: Scarlett Aria

[novice]

Tally as of post 430:

Lynch votes
3 votes: zack (Cuthillius, BSmith, Dp101)
2 votes: GeneralHankerchief (NotACop, Askthepizzaguy)
1 votes: Al Sips (Sooh)
1 votes: El Barto (seireikhaan)
1 votes: Dp101 (Zack)
1 votes: Cuthillius (Newyn)
1 votes: Scarlett Aria (novice)

Voting history:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

GeneralHankerchief

zack

GeneralHankerchief

Al Sips

GeneralHankerchief

Zack

El Barto

Zack

Dp101

Cuthillius

Scarlett Aria

[NotACop]

Please keep me in your thoughts and prayers right now.

[Riedquat]

Please keep me in your thoughts and prayers right now.

OK! Perhaps is to much to ask why??

[NotACop]

OK! Perhaps is to much to ask why??

Nothing is going on, I'm just a narcissist

[BSmith]

What does this mean?

Not much. Just that I felt like instigating a reaction and Zack and Pizza are pretty good targets to get a reaction from. Pizza probably would have returned more direct fire.

There is still not much to go on in the thread other than fine nuances and imagined slights. At this point I’d pretty much be happy with anyone being lynched (other than myself of course).

I’m around a fair bit more today than normal and am certainly open to being persuaded to vote in a different direction.

[Dp101]

Apparently I wasn't clear enough, for the last time, the misguided sheeping I only mentioned because the game state hadn't changed since the case was made, and it wasn't the main thrust of my point at all. I only emphasised it because you wanted more reasons. Your tone still appears to be off, and your attacks against my arguments have done nothing to change my mind.

[novice]

Apparently I wasn't clear enough, for the last time, the misguided sheeping I only mentioned because the game state hadn't changed since the case was made, and it wasn't the main thrust of my point at all. I only emphasised it because you wanted more reasons. Your tone still appears to be off, and your attacks against my arguments have done nothing to change my mind.

This appears to be aimed at Zack, but he hasn't posted since your last post...

[Scarlett Aria]

I can go with that.

Vote: Generalhankerchief

Not 100% convinced on Scarlett, but the rest of NAC's list looks pretty good.

Why GH?

[Dp101]

This appears to be aimed at Zack, but he hasn't posted since your last post...

Most of the statements were directed at him, but it was posted because of your criticism of me. Which is justified really, I'm not playing that well right now.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Does anybody know a recent-ish game in which Barto was mafia?

[Cuthillius]

I am still of the opinion that Zack's response to being voted is scummy.

He's trying to hushy hushy it up, and sort of push it out of the way, such as the post wrt ignoring me and the interaction with dp

ime zack, like visor, doesn't respond in that way as town as much

when town he's not afraid to just say hey that's idiotic go commit suicide

when scum he tends to do this less often

and right now he's trying to stay out of the center of attention

meh

boils down to

zack>meta>scum

[BSmith]

Does anybody know a recent-ish game in which Barto was mafia?

Kingslayer here is the only one I know of.

[novice]

Ok Dp, I see what you're saying. You're not just sheeping, you think Monty's case is still valid.

Showing a willingness to go after people maybe? I dunno, I haven't loved your play so far, it feels honestly kind of like Monty last game, lots of poking at players. To honour Monty's wishes I think I will Vote: Zack for now, given that we got basically no info from the night so I have to go by feel.

I mean, I'm voting you because someone who is now confirmed town saw you as mafia, and while following the dead is generally a bad move due to the gamestate changing since their death, there has really been nothing interesting going on during the night so their words still have merit. Basically, their case is better than anything I can come up with right now, so I'm sheeping Monty.

Honestly I remembered Monty's case on Zack as unexplained, but I see he added some details just before the lynch:

ZacK Scum

Zack is scum because GH is voting me, which is exactly what I expected from town GH.

Not enough time to give you my posts, but largely his part in driving every conversation and almost every wagon, at some point, plus the individual approaches to these being well-crafted setup for future spinning for scum Zack.

[El Barto]

Does anybody know a recent-ish game in which Barto was mafia?

I have never been mafia. Ever.

vote: seireikhaan

[Riedquat]

Does anybody know a recent-ish game in which Barto was mafia?

Barto acts always the same but if you see him voting a dead townie killed at night you better start suspecting him! ;)

[El Barto]

Vote: El Barto

I'm not sensing enough proper role play from barto. Why are you not bread, sir?

Barto acts always the same but if you see him voting a dead townie killed at night you better start suspecting him! ;)

seireikhaan is not a dead townie killed at night. He merely has two posts in two day phases.

[Riedquat]

seireikhaan is not a dead townie killed at night. He merely has two posts in two day phases.

I know, just wondering what GH and khaan are wondering about you... as you are acting normal to me.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'm sorry, I have not been able to look at this game or do anything today. My sincere regrets about that.

I don't have time to play this right now and I'll be able to next phase if I am alive.

Not game related stuff. Thanks for understanding.

[GeneralHankerchief]

I'll be drinking heavily starting an hour from now and monitoring this thread while watching the US election results, ask me anything.

[Synecdoche]

Tally as of post 449:

Lynch votes
3 votes: zack (Cuthillius, BSmith, Dp101)
2 votes: GeneralHankerchief (NotACop, Askthepizzaguy)
1 votes: Al Sips (Sooh)
1 votes: El Barto (seireikhaan)
1 votes: Dp101 (Zack)
1 votes: Cuthillius (Newyn)
1 votes: Scarlett Aria (novice)
1 votes: seireikhaan (El Barto)

Voting history:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

GeneralHankerchief

zack

GeneralHankerchief

Al Sips

GeneralHankerchief

Zack

El Barto

Zack

Dp101

Cuthillius

Scarlett Aria

seireikhaan

Day 2 ends on 11/8/16 at 10 PM.