Tokens of My Confection [Concluded]

**GamerDude** · 11-14-2016, 17:35

I am here. Someone cliffs me.

**Dp101** · 11-14-2016, 17:45

Well currently, Pizza has claimed SK and another SK showed up dead this morning. Most people are voting him because the likelihood of 2 SKs is very low. That is the current situation, previously there has just been mislynching.

**GamerDude** · 11-14-2016, 18:22

Vote: ATPG

ez game

**NotACop** · 11-16-2016, 12:58

Originally Posted by Dp101

Well currently, Pizza has claimed SK and another SK showed up dead this morning. Most people are voting him because the likelihood of 2 SKs is very low. That is the current situation, previously there has just been mislynching.

I mean, DP, I can see here that you were well aware that an SK had already flipped. If Pizza was a SK that would had been 5 NKs being blocked/protected throughout this game, which is so far from likely that it gives a hint of you not really thinking things through at all.

**NotACop** · 11-16-2016, 12:59

possibly even 6 NKs, as Khan had a 1-shot vig in his tool belt.

**NotACop** · 11-16-2016, 13:01

Would like to hear where you are at @Newyn , can barely remember you playing this game

**novice** · 11-16-2016, 13:34

My top three suspects are GH, Cuthilius and BSmith.

GH has done nothing useful, and was the counterwagon to both Zack and Scarlett (or rather, they may have been his counterwagon).
The one thing I can say in his defense is that he was (to be brutally frank) pretty useless in the last game as well, as town jailer. I've gathered that he's a strong player but I'm really not sure what his contributions are supposed to be either in this game or the last one.

Cuthilius pushed a bad case on Zack on day 2, and disappeared for most of days 2 and 3. Pizza hard vetoed voting him with dubious reasoning. GamerDude covered this.

BSmith stealth lynched Zack on day 2 and has been mostly absent ever since. Pizza did not support the case, which I felt was and is very valid. In general it's a case that scum can credibly support if it's wrong, so its lack of traction is suspicious.

We do need to block vote today. Vote: Cuthilius for now.

**NotACop** · 11-16-2016, 15:59

Originally Posted by novice

My top three suspects are GH, Cuthilius and BSmith.

GH has done nothing useful, and was the counterwagon to both Zack and Scarlett (or rather, they may have been his counterwagon).
The one thing I can say in his defense is that he was (to be brutally frank) pretty useless in the last game as well, as town jailer. I've gathered that he's a strong player but I'm really not sure what his contributions are supposed to be either in this game or the last one.

Cuthilius pushed a bad case on Zack on day 2, and disappeared for most of days 2 and 3. Pizza hard vetoed voting him with dubious reasoning. GamerDude covered this.

BSmith stealth lynched Zack on day 2 and has been mostly absent ever since. Pizza did not support the case, which I felt was and is very valid. In general it's a case that scum can credibly support if it's wrong, so its lack of traction is suspicious.

We do need to block vote today. Vote: Cuthilius for now.

Except that I haven't paid much attention to BSmith(I'll read the case, 2 sec), I like this guess at the last scums. GH has had a bad vibe for most of the game, and haven't really put in any attempt at solving that I remember. Cuth's D1 was really weird, the way he threw around suspicion left and right and said "changed my mind" almost identically a couple times, with no elaboration on what changed his mind.

**Cuthillius** · 11-16-2016, 16:58

Originally Posted by novice

Cuthilius pushed a bad case on Zack on day 2, and disappeared for most of days 2 and 3. Pizza hard vetoed voting him with dubious reasoning. GamerDude covered this.

I pushed a case that was mostly founded around my understanding of Zack's meta

And I've barely been posting any of the days

I posted more on d1, but that was all in one chunk

so saying i disappeared after that is meh

and that's misusing the term 'veto'

**novice** · 11-16-2016, 14:48

Originally Posted by NotACop

I mean, DP, I can see here that you were well aware that an SK had already flipped. If Pizza was a SK that would had been 5 NKs being blocked/protected throughout this game, which is so far from likely that it gives a hint of you not really thinking things through at all.

Is that a scum tell in your opinion?

**NotACop** · 11-16-2016, 15:55

Originally Posted by novice

Is that a scum tell in your opinion?

Probably it isn't, since scums rarely do stuff that are easy to prove as not making sense at all.
So it's more to see what kind of response he'll give(which probably won't be of much use as I'm stating this now).