Swords and Sorcery Mafia Without the Swords [Concluded]

[Csargo]

Top towns and scums, no particular order:

Towns:

Zack
Renata
Csargo
Snerk
Renata

Zack and Snerk on tone, Csargo is a soul read, Renata's listed twice because she's that townie to me.

Scums
Visor
atheotes
Winston
Arakhor

Visor and atheotes from the interaction I highlighted earlier, atheotes a bit stronger of a read hence my vote. Haven't liked Winston's thread presence so far, particularly this tidbit:



Seems twiggy and a go-to defense as mafia in my experience.

Arakhor because his non-socializing posts have been super hedge-y.

I'm not sure how to feel about that...

[Snerk]

Snerk's effort levels would seem scummy for him, but he's also hung a massive lampshade on it.

Why are my effort levels scummy?

I think that both Zack and Winston are clearly town from this engagement.

I'm not onboard this train at all. But I liked their confrontation last page.

Consider yourself warned @Snerk :P

Sorry didn't know edits were not allowed. This is odd it's highly unusual for me to brake any game rules.

Arakhor because his non-socializing posts have been super hedge-y.

This is bang on but for what it's worth Arakhor is a hedge-y kind of guy regardless of alignment.

[Renata]

You gonna reconsider your vote on me at any point today, Snerk?

[Snerk]

You gonna reconsider your vote on me at any point today, Snerk?

It's certainly possible.Who's your best candidate for the lynch today and why?

[Renata]

Winston, right now. I didn't like his response to Zack's case on him. But you should be able to figure that out just be reading, shouldn't you?

[Snerk]

Well it's always nice to have things clarified. :)

[Snerk]

^was a response to renata

[Winston Hughes]

Winston, right now. I didn't like his response to Zack's case on him.

But why?

I get where Zack is coming from. It fits with pretty much every other occasion he's suspected me (albeit he was scum on some of them).

I'm not getting that sense from you.

[Renata]

But why?

I get where Zack is coming from. It fits with pretty much every other occasion he's suspected me (albeit he was scum on some of them).

I'm not getting that sense from you.

All the answers below look really weak to me. Like trying to pass off yourself off as just lalaladon'tcare when that's really not your MO that I've ever noticed -- when you go "make myself lynchbait" you don't mess around. Lampshading that it's a weak vote and all. I mean, I get that the vote in itself. I do stuff like that myself. I just feel like you got called out and you're fumbling a bit in a way that seems unlike you.

A bit weak.

Powerful weak, more like.

I'm not joking, I'm just chatting shit without a care.

Not quite.

I mean it does sound like Al's M.O.

Which means that it's not alignment indicative in itself.

But he has just dropped it and not come back, making him a valid place to put a vote.

It is a weak vote on Renata's part, and an even weaker one on mine.

But, hey, I never said I had anything better.

[Snerk]

^Must resist urge to edit brake to break...

[Winston Hughes]

I'm gonna need explanations for the reads on me and Renata.

That's difficult, as they are not founded on conscious reactions.

But I'm working on it.

Why are my effort levels scummy?

It was a way back, but around the time of that game we played at GitP there was a thing about you acting more townie as scum than as town, which I think was largely down to effort.

And that notion is supported/lampshaded by your comments on town/scum effort levels.

[Snerk]

It was a way back, but around the time of that game we played at GitP there was a thing about you acting more townie as scum than as town, which I think was largely down to effort.

And that notion is supported/lampshaded by your comments on town/scum effort levels.

Congratulations, you have better memory than me. :)

The reason I asked is that I don't see my efforts thus far as all that constructive. So I don't really follow the logic, but I guess I sort of see where it's coming from.

[Zack]

Red Dwarf was the one where you spent the first few days just talking about votecounts, right? (at winston)

[Winston Hughes]

Red Dwarf was the one where you spent the first few days just talking about votecounts, right? (at winston)

Do you mean postcounts? (As in, I worked through the ISOs from the low posters upwards.)

If so, yes.

If not, I'm not sure what you're talking about.

[Zack]

Do you mean postcounts? (As in, I worked through the ISOs from the low posters upwards.)

If so, yes.

If not, I'm not sure what you're talking about.

Sorry, yes that's what I meant.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

It was definitely a trick question, in the hopes I could spring the trap on you of not remembering your most recent scum games well enough to use the lame "would I really do this as a wolf?" defense.