Quote Originally Posted by Arakhor View Post
I think it's super-unlikely that Zack and Montmorency are both mafia, given that it was Zack who started the attempted rush on Monty near the end of D1. Trying to turn a double-scum vote into a triple-scum vote seems foolish in the extreme, though of course it would make sense if Zack was scum and trying to implicate an innocent Monty. Given that the only two other votes on him were known scum, I think it rather unlikely that Monty is scum at all.

Zack then of course voted for Dp, when it might have been more sensible to vote for Al, given that if you're guaranteed to lose one scum, you want to lose the inactive one first. Chances are then that Zack is not scum either, but scum-Zack is not nearly as implausible as scum-Monty is.

(Granted, I've done implausible things before, but that doesn't make implausible things any more plausible simply because they do occasionally happen.)
I 100% agree with this. Don't want to examine either of them individually until we start getting into tinfoil-safe territory (f7 and beyond), refuse to consider them both together.