Swords and Sorcery Mafia Without the Swords [Concluded]

[Arakhor]

Day One
Dp101 - 6 (Bsmith, Choxorn, Kcaz, Lewwyn, Montmorency, Renata)
Al Sipsclar - 5 (Arakhor, Dp101, GHC, Visor, Winston Hughes)
Montmorency - 2 (Atheotes, Al Sipsclar)
Arakhor - 1 (Csargo)
Kcaz - 1 (Sooh)
Renata -1 (Snerk)

Dp bussing Al at this point was a matter of survival, and it seems that Visor was also bussing Al, presumably because he was the inactive one compared to Dp. This was D1, when everything was manic, right up until the deadline.

Day Two
Visor - 6 (Renata, Winston Hughes, GHC, Choxorn, Arakhor, Sooh)
Sooh - 5 (Atheotes, Snerk, Lewwyn, Montmorency, Kcaz)
Lewwyn - 1 (Visor)
Atheotes - 1 (Csargo)

D2 was much less hectic, with the deadline only really pulling in unplaced votes and Visor surprisingly failing to make a vote to defend himself. We still have yet to resolve the Sooh/Atheotes inconsistency, but it looks like that Visor was doomed either way, whether by Sooh bussing him to stay alive or by Atheotes voting for Sooh and causing her to vote Visor instead.

[Arakhor]

For the record, Renata, I maintain that Visor was acting just like himself on D1, which is when I made your quoted comment. He certainly was not acting like I'd expect him to on D2, which is why I voted for him over the other clear favourite (Sooh).

[Zack]

I did not have wolfy relations with that man.

[Arakhor]

That's, uh, just cat hair on the pillow!

[Arakhor]

I'm probably over-posting now, but GH's D1 scum list is still of interest:

atheotes, Arakhor, Visor, maybe Al Sips.

Other than me of course, you're doing fine so far.

[Snerk]

Tinfoil: there are 5 scums because town has a metric feckton of PR abilities :)

[Choxorn]

Tinfoil: there are 5 scums because town has a metric feckton of PR abilities :)

Possible, but that seems like a very high number for just a 16 player game. I'd say 3rd party roles are far more likely than a 5-man scum team.

I also think that a 5-man scum team could do a better job of keeping votes away from two of their members on day 1.

[Choxorn]

I also think Visor was protecting his scummates early today, because bussing doesn't make sense in this spot and Visor wasn't attracting any real suspicion until after people noticed how odd he was acting.

I also highly doubt that any scum were on the Dp wagon day 1, given the scum's pretty clear preference for lynching Al. If they were, they could have easily switched to Al for some made-up reason at EoD (the way GH actually did switch) and try to get some easy town cred for last-second switching to lynch a scum while also getting minor town cred to Visor for also voting Al. Doesn't really change my opinions much, because I already thought Renata and Monty were >99% town anyway and Zack and Lewwyn only slightly less so, but now they're all even more almost sure town.

Also, there were some peek claims, right? Zack said he peeked Winston not corrupted, and someone (I forget who) said they peeked GH not corrupted.

I think most signs point to Sooh as the most likely wolf. If anyone has any incineration spells left, that's who I'd recommend for the target.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Snerk wouldn't be a bad lynch either.

This one post of Snerk's did bother me after EOD2:

We still should have lynched Renata tho

This was after I gave him minor town points for posting something similar after the D1 lynch. Reads to me as more deliberate this time though, and it could be NAI depending on Snerk's general sense of humor.

I also can't in good conscience positively weigh this against the big night action dispute with Sooh/atheotes, but the post is there nonetheless.