French Revolution Mafia [Concluded]

[Dp101]

I've actually never seen you be scum, tbh. It's mostly based on this game's behavior.

Tell me about your day one, what you were thinking when you did stuff.

Initially I was just fluff-posting while I tried to figure out how to play the setup. Then I realised that I should probably get to solving the game as I had no idea who I was going to vote, so I posted my reads list halfway through. When thread discussion didn't really pick up I decided to pressure Monty since I thought his pressure on me was weird. I woke up 5 mins before EOD, asked for the cases, got nothing back, so voted the guy who wasn't as pure.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Tell me more about the decision to vote Jabbz. Which post from Manasi (or posts) did you see which made you feel Manasi was pure, and why?

[Askthepizzaguy]

A snerk marches on his stomach.

Anyway, to business. El Barto AKA Jean Baptiste Bernadotte has declared his royalist ambitions. Off with his head!

vote: El Barto

I am curious as of now as to whether or not this accusation was a joke. I assumed it was, but let's not leave any stone unturned.

[Dp101]

Tell me more about the decision to vote Jabbz. Which post from Manasi (or posts) did you see which made you feel Manasi was pure, and why?

The post immediately prior to my vote, when Manasi said that they didn't regret livening up the thread a bit. The tone of it just felt like what I'd expect a joking townsperson to say.

[Snerk]

I am curious as of now as to whether or not this accusation was a joke. I assumed it was, but let's not leave any stone unturned.

You think I actually thought Barto was more scummy for something he said in the sign-up thread?

Though at that time I thought it was as good as vote as any. Still think he's a plausible lynch candidate.

[Al Sipsclar]

Bon matin! Just want to mention that my top town right now is Khaan for calling out Jabbz. My top scums are all dead now. Unfortunately, this is going to be a busy weekend for me, but I'll try to put in a vote.

[Askthepizzaguy]

You think I actually thought Barto was more scummy for something he said in the sign-up thread?

Though at that time I thought it was as good as vote as any. Still think he's a plausible lynch candidate.

Lol

I wasnt paying attention. Thought he might have said something silly in his faction quicktopic after the game started. Thanks for clarifying.

[Renata]

vote: Autolycus

Wolfy bandwagon movement.

[Arakhor]

That is a lot of dead people.

It's also a lot of dead Royalists. Are Org games always this brutal to the scum early on? ~:P

[Snerk]

That is a lot of dead people.

It's also a lot of dead Royalists. Are Org games always this brutal to the scum early on? ~:p

Yeah I'm beginning to see a trend too.

vote: Autolycus

Wolfy bandwagon movement.

vote: Autolycus

I'm not sheeping!!

Ok I'm sheeping. Sue me.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Tally as of post 520. I might have missed a vote, especially if it was made early in the round, any doublechecking would be appreciated.

autolycus: 2 | Renata (518), Snerk (520)
Csargo: 1 | Montmorency (475)

Round ends:

(pending DST shenanigans)

[Montmorency]

Unvote: Csargo

Why auto? Why auto over the other lurkers/inactives?

[Snerk]

Well I tried Barto yesterday but it didn't gather much enthusiasm..

[Csargo]

Sorry, at that time Jabbz had 3 votes and you and BSmith had 2 votes. He voted to increment BSmith while arguing for your towniness. This was clearly part of the scum effort to save Jabbz, and it might also be spew wrt reasoning against voting another salient wagon.

There was

This is a stretch at best. The simplest solution is Kage needed to switch his vote to try and save Jabbz, and so he had to unvote me for whatever reason. Also, BSmith had 3 votes and was tied with Jabbz, so there's that. He gave a random reason to switch his vote, you're clearly reading too much into it.

[Csargo]

Aww...

[Renata]

Unvote: Csargo

Why auto? Why auto over the other lurkers/inactives?

"Wolfy bandwagon movement"

I'm judging people on whether they're willing to go check for themselves what I mean. glgl, next vote count's just a few posts down the line.

I didn't like his phrasing with that vote on BSmith either. Over-explainy. I doubt he treasures my presence that much.

[Csargo]

Vote:Snerk

[Snerk]

Care to elaborate?

[Csargo]

Care to elaborate?

I just didn't like your vote switch yesterday. You protected Jabbz more than BSmith when you voted for Manasi, since Jabbz was ahead of BSmith at that point. It bothers me.

[Snerk]

I just didn't like your vote switch yesterday. You protected Jabbz more than BSmith when you voted for Manasi, since Jabbz was ahead of BSmith at that point. It bothers me.

Fair. And I figured someone would mention my quite scummy vote yesterday. But I was kinda factionally obliged to try and save Jabbz. For what it's worth I regret the vote.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Pizza still voting for his top town-lean, eh? Can't decide weather to help or bus a scum-buddy?

Did you ever really suspect Renata?

Vote: Snerk

[Dp101]

That is a lot of dead people.

It's also a lot of dead Royalists. Are Org games always this brutal to the scum early on? ~:P

I feel that this is horrible tonewise. Vote: Arakhor

[Snerk]

Did you ever really suspect Renata?

Vote: Snerk

Yes.

[Csargo]

Fair. And I figured someone would mention my quite scummy vote yesterday. But I was kinda factionally obliged to try and save Jabbz. For what it's worth I regret the vote.

Why did you say it was in defense of BSmith then? It all just looks really bad at this point.

[Snerk]

Why did you say it was in defense of BSmith then? It all just looks really bad at this point.

Factionally obliged to save him too. And just a moment earlier BSmith was in the lead.

As scum that manoeuvre would be too ballsy for me. Would have quietly nursed an off wagon vote instead.

[BSmith]

Confirmed. Also the reason I voted manasi over Jabbz.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Yes.

When/why?

[Askthepizzaguy]

This is what I saw when I looked.

Stuff mentioning Renata at that point in the game-

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

That or a preemptive renata lynch for improved thread-ease-of-readage.. :)

Furthermore, not letting Renate get away with posting hidden messages in public this game.
These are the first letters of her posts so far: Vltrnitwibk
What Renate didn't know, is that I am fluent in Polish and thus able to decipher her code. "Vltrnitwibk" means nothing less than "long live the king!" J'accuse, madame!!!!

Needs more wagon. unvote, vote: Renata

Pizza still voting for his top town-lean, eh? Can't decide weather to help or bus a scum-buddy?

First are first page jokey stuff. The wagon on Renata would be after the vote was tied 1-1-1-1-1-1-1-1. But this was page 2 and I didn't see any real reason to suspect Renata before that point. Nothing occurs between then and the Renata scumbuddy comment. Afterward, Snerk doesn't mention any suspicion either.

He unvotes and votes someone else for faction related reasons instead of encouraging people to lynch his suspect.

Strange behavior for someone acting townish.

At a reasonable minimum, Snerk, you're more concerned with faction-related stuff than scum hunting, but you're really going to have to show me what about Renata you found scummy before I unvote you. And even then, I'd need to be voting for someone I think is likely to be scum.

[Snerk]

When/why?

Well my initial vote on her was just an attempt to get a wagon going, and it worked.

Later I grew somewhat suspicious on the interaction between the two to with posts like this:

Pizza! How I have missed lynching your scummy butt.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Good vote. No one will ever suspect you're distancing.

Plus the point I made in the post you just quoted, about your vote on her suddenly turning into a townread after a wagon started to roll on her.

But on tone she seemed similar to her previous town game.

Both of these points I stated in the faction QT at around that time.

[Snerk]

He unvotes and votes someone else for faction related reasons instead of encouraging people to lynch his suspect.

She was hardly "my suspect" though.

At a reasonable minimum, Snerk, you're more concerned with faction-related stuff than scum hunting, but you're really going to have to show me what about Renata you found scummy before I unvote you. And even then, I'd need to be voting for someone I think is likely to be scum.

You find it scummy that I voted to avoid a faction lynch d1?