French Revolution Mafia [Concluded]

[Winston Hughes]

Nope.

[Zack]

that is why auto had to live dorks

[Zack]

vote: csargo

[Winston Hughes]

Everyone in our faction knew the results were coming today, provided Autolycus did not die.

As I understand it, because this was a faction power, he could not prevent it from taking its course.

Autolycus originally suggested Arakhor for the job, and proposed the following targets: Kage, khaan, BSmith, Renata, Monty/Dp101.

Zack then suggested Autolycus for the job, proposed NAC, Monstr, Kage, khaan, Monty, and submitted those as orders.

Barto was absent throughout, and my (Sooh's) only contribution was a minor query about how the power worked (prior to any discussion of how to use it).

[Winston Hughes]

As I understand it, because this was a faction power, he could not prevent it from taking its course.

Actually, I'm not clear whether he/we could have stopped it, but it would have to have been done in the qt.

[Montmorency]

It's gonna be a Populist. Auto didn't screw up the job, but his original picks contained only one scum - he's not clear.

Vote: auto

[Winston Hughes]

Auto's played this really well in the qt if he is a royal.

There was one thing last night, though: he expressed a hope that nobody vig him, saying nothing about the prospect of the royalists killing him.

[Snerk]

Well I'm back on vote:NotACop.

[Winston Hughes]

Well I'm back on vote:NotACop.

[Snerk]

Surely you're not saying this is a bad vote????

[Snerk]

I'm willing to switch to Khan or Monty though.

[Choxorn]

There was one thing last night, though: he expressed a hope that nobody vig him, saying nothing about the prospect of the royalists killing him.

I don't really think that says much either way about him, if he's town, he could be more afraid of being vigged because he'd be thinking "a lot of people suspect me and think I'm scummy, I don't think the Royalists will kill me because I'm lynchbait."

Really, if he's not, but someone else in your faction is and they knew about the scan, why kill Auto? Even if it stops the scan, the Royalists killing Auto just heavily indicates that they knew what he was up to, which would make you and El Barto look even worse than you already do.

[Zack]

Winston is fine.

[Choxorn]

Assuming at least one of the Populists is a Royalist and they knew about Autolycus's scan, I'd expect them to back the seireikhaan wagon over the Dp wagon yesterday, because they'd know that khaan is about to be confirmed town and they'd want to get him lynched before that happens. I'll give El Barto a little bit of town cred for that, but just a little, because I'm not really sure how active he actually is. Same with Autolycus. Winston did vote khaan, which makes him look a little bit worse.

[Montmorency]

At this point a scum - Csargo, presumably - in Renata's group would not kill Renata, as it would only be to their own detriment in the Convention. Csargo's primary defense against the lynch was Renata.

This night, Llewyn jailed me and Khaan jailed Snerk. As Khaan is town, Snerk must indeed have been jailed, which means he at least could not have killed Renata.

The overwhelming probability is that at least one scum is in the Populist faction, which has neither lost nor killed any scum, unlike the other factions. And auto, Barto, and Winston/Sooh were all off-wagon on D1. Al Sipsclar, Choxorn, and Csargo were also off-wagon, but they have individual or factional redeeming factors. Giving auto and Barto a flat benefit-of-the-doubt for QT reasons (which Al Sipsclar would receive by the same token), Winston should be brought down today. Did anyone else catch the buddying toward me yesterday? As soon as he wasn't being suspected as much went right into demure and friendly mode.

Unvote; Vote: Winston