Pokemon Nuzlocke FireRed Mafia [Concluded]

[Manasi]

Just played a quick game of catchup and I can easily say I'm floored at how active Sooh is on this site.

Good stuff.


Reads coming after coffee.

[Manasi]

Logic - villager for earlier posts. I remember the few in the beginning about their playstyle and their history playing on the site. Also compared to French Rev I think they're definitely playing to their villa game.

GeneralHankerchief - Villager for most things, active and helpful ITT when he's around. Think he has a much higher chance of being a villager than a wolf.

Champ - Ok this is hard. I feel like he'd be a lot more active as a villager but I know that during my first .Org game I was really shocked by the tempo of the game and that was a little discouraging. I would say that Champ is probably one of my lighter scum reads this game.

SeveringViper - I read this dude like I would try to read Zack and I'm at like 51% chance he's a villager. I know they've been really active as well I just haven't paid nearly as much attention to them. Wanted to include them because I had thought about them as opposed to the other people I didn't mention.

Novice - This is probably a bad read but from what I've skimmed they've been super active so I'm willing to call them a villager. Also their entrance seemed to be pretty inquisitive in that they wanted to know how people played/what they were like (presumably to develop a better read on them).

Csargo - ily

choxorn - Odd push on me inherently. I'm sure it was a joke but I don't think we're on the same level of each other that would encourage joking around kinda play. That might sound weird but it's kinda like, I'd only joke around like that with people I'm good friends with, but maybe Chox is super cool and wants to be buds. For now he's in light scum w Champo.

Cuthillius - Playing exactly how he does as a villager (granted my only recent experience with him is in turbo games but I think he's doing the same stuff).

Sooh - Don't know about alignment but just wanted to say that I like how much she's posting. I think that with the volume read it's hard to not call her a villager, but I'm scared that my village circle is getting too big.




woop

if you want me to find posts lmk

[Csargo]

I don't have a ton to add, except Csargo ???

I hope you'll have time to make some general reads on a few people to help me read you, Csargo.

Same goes for most tbh. Even if you're uncertain as heck about your reads and you probably will switch them around tomorrow, I'd really appreciate getting them before DL so I can use them to get a read on you. I'll get into and produce some sort of reads list when I'm home from work today.

I was trying to determine what SV was doing, mostly because some of his reactions and arguments seemed scummy to me, because I didn't see what they accomplished. I think I understand what he's doing, I don't know if it has long-term value, but we'll see.

As far as reads go I don't have much. Think Barto seems himself so far, khaan's sort of half in character and half ooc not sure what to make of that. I'm unsure of SV, but want to see what happens going forward. Not sure I've ever played with SV before. I'm not sure what to make of novice yet, I'll probably go through the thread again tonight and see if anything jumps out to me. Actually I'll try to look through it before I have to work, because the day will be over, before I get off work iirc.

[Sooh]

To me some of your (Csargo) posts read almost like a defense of me, and that's strange.

[Csargo]

To me some of your (Csargo) posts read almost like a defense of me, and that's strange.

???

[SeveringViper]

SeveringViper - I read this dude like I would try to read Zack and I'm at like 51% chance he's a villager. I know they've been really active as well I just haven't paid nearly as much attention to them. Wanted to include them because I had thought about them as opposed to the other people I didn't mention.

Is just this a volume read and/or do you actually like whatever you have read from me?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Csargo - ily

Manasi lock town for this read. I'm only 50% joking.

Vote: khaan

Will put down reasons shortly, but this isn't a random vote.

[GeneralHankerchief]

This post:

Got tired of people wanting to lynch me for rp'ing.

khaan's most recent past games on the .Org, in reverse order:

- French Revolution Mafia: town, had a character schtick, not lynched
- Visor's Small Mafia Game: town (subbed in), sort of had a character schtick (speaking nothing in smilies, but only for a few posts), not lynched
- Tokens of My Confection: town, made two posts, not lynched
- Futuramafia: mafia, did not have a character schtick, not lynched (was vigged though IIRC)
- Polandball Mafia: town, made two posts, not lynched
- IKEA Mafia: town, did not have a character schtick, not lynched
- Bird Mafia: town, did not have a character schtick, not lynched

This goes back to March 2016. Does not compute.

[BSmith]

Apologies for being AWOL. Typical weekend for me, unfortunately. I have read absolutely zero of the thread so far, so vote: Monty for purely random reasons. Will do my best to read and get caught up before end of day.

[Cuthillius]

Just played a quick game of catchup and I can easily say I'm floored at how active Sooh is on this site.

Good stuff.


Reads coming after coffee.

i know right

dm too, actually

[Montmorency]

Doesn't inspire much sentiment. And Khaan has another semi-character here:

Csargo used taunt! It's a critical hit!
seireikhaan's anger point activated!


Back in my day we didn't have fancy schmancy things like "role reveals" or "information". We voted for people because they ate spicy meatballs and liked it! Nowadays everyone wants to push and shove and pull and prostrate. All you need to solve mafia is your gut and your heart and the Truth!

Vote: Novice for being on my lawn.

On the other other hand, this post is like his first Futuramafia posts in that he's complaining about certain tactical decisions for the early game:

I don't share no lawn, it's MY LAWN. YOU GIT YOUR OWN LAWN. And then we won't have no troubles, ya see?

On a more serious note, if you want to get into deep conversations and and analysis on day 1, that's... fine, but I'm not too horribly concerned about that yet tbh. Don't get me wrong I'll check back in on day 2+ and compare notes to days after, but I'm not too hot and bothered yet because it's pretty RNG on whether a mafia gets nailed unless they really mess up. Although, on the playstyle bit, I will note that the people from off-site have a bit of a different interpretation of town play on some level to what I grew up with. I'm a bit more used to *everyone* playing relatively close to the vest, yes, even as town. If someone's triggering your scumdar, maybe you poke around, maybe get them lynched off response, but I've never been a fan of these "here's my list, I think people's X, Y, and Z are innocent, people's A, B, and C are iffy, and people's 1, 2, and 3 are scummy".

But Khaan did always say the best way to play scum roles is to do that which the gut wouldn't believe.

[Cuthillius]

This post:



khaan's most recent past games on the .Org, in reverse order:

- French Revolution Mafia: town, had a character schtick, not lynched
- Visor's Small Mafia Game: town (subbed in), sort of had a character schtick (speaking nothing in smilies, but only for a few posts), not lynched
- Tokens of My Confection: town, made two posts, not lynched
- Futuramafia: mafia, did not have a character schtick, not lynched (was vigged though IIRC)
- Polandball Mafia: town, made two posts, not lynched
- IKEA Mafia: town, did not have a character schtick, not lynched
- Bird Mafia: town, did not have a character schtick, not lynched

This goes back to March 2016. Does not compute.

that is super super weak

clearly it's something he hasn't been doing that much recently either

so i don't think you can either make the case that his not having a character schtick is scummy or that saying why he stopped is

like

that also ignores what people said itt

there have been a lot of newcomers to the org, i'd be unsurprised if some of them were all "cut the rp or we lynch you" type deal

i completely disagree with your reasoning and evidence

but eh

[Cuthillius]

Apologies for being AWOL. Typical weekend for me, unfortunately. I have read absolutely zero of the thread so far, so vote: Monty for purely random reasons. Will do my best to read and get caught up before end of day.

Welcome back.

[GeneralHankerchief]

that is super super weak

clearly it's something he hasn't been doing that much recently either

so i don't think you can either make the case that his not having a character schtick is scummy or that saying why he stopped is

like

that also ignores what people said itt

there have been a lot of newcomers to the org, i'd be unsurprised if some of them were all "cut the rp or we lynch you" type deal

i completely disagree with your reasoning and evidence

but eh

If khaan's town, and I point out his lack of character schtick is somewhat worrisome (believe that's the exact phrase I used), and that's his recent history, is that how he hits back at me?

[novice]

Vote: khaan

Will share my actual thoughts later.

[Montmorency]

Tally plz GH is making a play for the badge.

[SeveringViper]

This post:



khaan's most recent past games on the .Org, in reverse order:

- French Revolution Mafia: town, had a character schtick, not lynched
- Visor's Small Mafia Game: town (subbed in), sort of had a character schtick (speaking nothing in smilies, but only for a few posts), not lynched
- Tokens of My Confection: town, made two posts, not lynched
- Futuramafia: mafia, did not have a character schtick, not lynched (was vigged though IIRC)
- Polandball Mafia: town, made two posts, not lynched
- IKEA Mafia: town, did not have a character schtick, not lynched
- Bird Mafia: town, did not have a character schtick, not lynched

This goes back to March 2016. Does not compute.

Does not cover:
A. If he faced pressure/threat of lynch for RP in those games.
B. The possibility of his having played offsite and faced the above.
C. His responding to unfamiliar players by not wanting to potentially draw fire like the above.

Hm?

[SeveringViper]

Tally plz GH is making a play for the badge.

Votes?:

Novice - 1: seireikhaan
Montmorency - 2: autolycus, BSmith
Manasi - 1: Choxorn
GH - 1: Barto
Sooh - 1: Raith
Raith - 1: Logic
Seireikhaan - 3: Csargo, GH, novice
SV - 2: Jabbz, Montmorency

[Cuthillius]

If khaan's town, and I point out his lack of character schtick is somewhat worrisome (believe that's the exact phrase I used), and that's his recent history, is that how he hits back at me?

could very well be, yeah

[SeveringViper]

If khaan's town, and I point out his lack of character schtick is somewhat worrisome (believe that's the exact phrase I used), and that's his recent history, is that how he hits back at me?

Khaan is not cuth?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Does not cover:
A. If he faced pressure/threat of lynch for RP in those games.
B. The possibility of his having played offsite and faced the above.
C. His responding to unfamiliar players by not wanting to potentially draw fire like the above.

Hm?

I was in most of those games and:

a) I don't remember the pressure being that significant.
b) He doesn't play offsite.
c) Can you clarify?

[Cuthillius]

vote:Jabbz

less because i think he's independently wolfy, more that there are a lot of people i think are town

jabbz hasn't provided me with any reason to feel good about his alignment

[Champ]

What time does this day end

[Champ]

Oh 6pm
Ok I'll be home soon and read

[Cuthillius]

Oh 6pm
Ok I'll be home soon and read

please

[SeveringViper]

I was in most of those games and:

a) I don't remember the pressure being that significant.
b) He doesn't play offsite.
c) Can you clarify?

a. Alright.
b. ^
c. Not knowing a good few of the players, it's possible he was worried about getting attacked if he went fully in character.

[Csargo]

What's your opinion on khaan @SeveringViper ?

[SeveringViper]

What's your opinion on khaan @SeveringViper ?

Null, might be promising.
He's made two serious posts so far, mostly talking about play style and declaring he's going to be keeping his thoughts to himself.

[Logic]

vote:Jabbz

less because i think he's independently wolfy, more that there are a lot of people i think are town

jabbz hasn't provided me with any reason to feel good about his alignment

Yo. Narrator says votes must also be in RED to count.

[Askthepizzaguy]

host note: round ends in 5 hours.