Pokemon Nuzlocke FireRed Mafia [Concluded]

[Sooh]

I get the feeling you're in teacher mode and it's unintentionally condescending. It's still condescending. I have experience with this game and I know what I'm doing and why.


Fair enough, you can be assured I have gained, and expect I will get, things out of them.

By all means. It couldn't have just been a compliment of your style and a town lean.

[El Barto]

I sense that novice is posting from his Pokédex.

Poisonous snakes are only a problem to people planning to eat them.

What do you think Pokeymans eat out in the wild?

[Raith Kemmler]

To elaborate, either you're filling the thread with stuff you deem pointless, or you were shading me when you called it pointless.

Alignment question was pointless. Leads nowhere. Everything else I'll humor.

Related question mainly out of curiosity: If you think you have one wolf caught, do you go for the throat right away even if it gets you killed, or wait and try to find/case more suspects/catch other wolves before you charge?

And why does this sound like a long way to say "I believe in basic active town tactics?" Sounds like you're lecturing, why?

(Also, which gens have you played and which is your favorite? favorite 'mon from each gen/overall?)

I was ranting. About the game last year with Golden. Where I tunneled because he scared of dying. Out of my system. For now.

I like going for the wolf when I see it, damn the consequences. But I also tend to self doubt and wait till sure. The wait and team theory build is impressive. But takes a more confident analyst than me. First blood helps that anyway with a solid evidence. Do you actually want me to share the gen thing? I can, but it'd be spammy. But it's been awhile and want to socialize.

So, my first thought was that novice is a bit scummy for pushing the "everyone needs to give me your own descriptions of your playstyles" thing just a bit too hard, especially as he's been on this forum before and I don't recall him doing it when he was truly new (and town) to boot. There's a couple posts in there about ideal town strategy, etc, but that's pretty easy to fake as scum.

Sooh and Viper probably not aligned.

Vote: novice

Novice seems too easy. His stop having fun guy style bristles, but neutral alignment-wise. Don't like seeing him die day 1 as yet.

Threads pretty unbalanced activity wise. Not sure what to make of that. I like Viper better than Sooh currently.

I sense that novice is posting from his Pokédex.

What do you think Pokeymans eat out in the wild?

Other pokemon.

[SeveringViper]

I like going for the wolf when I see it, damn the consequences. But I also tend to self doubt and wait till sure. The wait and team theory build is impressive. But takes a more confident analyst than me. First blood helps that anyway with a solid evidence. Do you actually want me to share the gen thing? I can, but it'd be spammy. But it's been awhile and want to socialize.

I like this, town always could use someone itching to go for the throat but also willing to take some time to think about things.
And nah, that was meant as a little side comment back when the game was just starting, I think it's too far along now to go that far off-topic.

Speaking of game relevance, what do you think of GH and Barto?

[Raith Kemmler]

I've got nothing on Bart. Never do Day 1. Shoot in midgame if no wolves caught. Maybe shoot anyway. Bart's more a, he looks hairy if paired with other people. People I've a better read on. He's easier to theory around.

GH's rational is weak, but! I assumed this was novice's first game here. Apparently not. Would like a summary of previous game meta. Novice is so active this might actually help. I rate GH as a bit shady.

[novice]

Seems pointless but will humor.

Alignment? Pointless question.

Alignment question was pointless. Leads nowhere. Everything else I'll humor.

Well, you said "seems pointless" about the entire request.

GH's rational is weak, but! I assumed this was novice's first game here. Apparently not. Would like a summary of previous game meta. Novice is so active this might actually help. I rate GH as a bit shady.

I can (vaguely) remember three games. First game I was town, followed a few mislynches led by scum pizza, then got mislynched by him. Town lost. Second game I was scum and we won with three scum and three town remaining, and me being widely townread almost until the end. Third game I subbed in as town on day three, tunneled on scum pizza, and got nightkilled quickly. You'd need to read the games for more details.

Sorry if I come across as a killjoy, I'm enjoying the game and find myself smiling while playing it.

[novice]

Well, you said "seems pointless" about the entire request.

I kind of wanted to hear Raith's riposte to this before moving my vote, but I don't think he can convince me to keep voting him anyway. I quite liked the rest of his post 117.

GH is the only active player that's pinged me the wrong way, so he gets my vote for now, even if it is a bit OMGUS.

[SeveringViper]

By all means. It couldn't have just been a compliment of your style and a town lean.

People read things differently from different positions, like you said. All I'm saying is that it can be read like that and I'd assure you others would have that interpretation too.

[Sooh]

People read things differently from different positions, like you said. All I'm saying is that it can be read like that and I'd assure you others would have that interpretation too.

Well it probably won't be a very nice game if you want to interpret everything the worst way possible.

If I sound "teachery" or condescending, that's not the intention. I've never had that problem before with people interpreting me that way, but since you do I assume there could be something lost in translation.

[El Barto]

All right, maybe we should all enjoy the game and quietly backstab everybody else during the night phase?