Pokemon Nuzlocke FireRed Mafia [Concluded]

[Manasi]

Just played a quick game of catchup and I can easily say I'm floored at how active Sooh is on this site.

Good stuff.


Reads coming after coffee.

[Manasi]

Logic - villager for earlier posts. I remember the few in the beginning about their playstyle and their history playing on the site. Also compared to French Rev I think they're definitely playing to their villa game.

GeneralHankerchief - Villager for most things, active and helpful ITT when he's around. Think he has a much higher chance of being a villager than a wolf.

Champ - Ok this is hard. I feel like he'd be a lot more active as a villager but I know that during my first .Org game I was really shocked by the tempo of the game and that was a little discouraging. I would say that Champ is probably one of my lighter scum reads this game.

SeveringViper - I read this dude like I would try to read Zack and I'm at like 51% chance he's a villager. I know they've been really active as well I just haven't paid nearly as much attention to them. Wanted to include them because I had thought about them as opposed to the other people I didn't mention.

Novice - This is probably a bad read but from what I've skimmed they've been super active so I'm willing to call them a villager. Also their entrance seemed to be pretty inquisitive in that they wanted to know how people played/what they were like (presumably to develop a better read on them).

Csargo - ily

choxorn - Odd push on me inherently. I'm sure it was a joke but I don't think we're on the same level of each other that would encourage joking around kinda play. That might sound weird but it's kinda like, I'd only joke around like that with people I'm good friends with, but maybe Chox is super cool and wants to be buds. For now he's in light scum w Champo.

Cuthillius - Playing exactly how he does as a villager (granted my only recent experience with him is in turbo games but I think he's doing the same stuff).

Sooh - Don't know about alignment but just wanted to say that I like how much she's posting. I think that with the volume read it's hard to not call her a villager, but I'm scared that my village circle is getting too big.




woop

if you want me to find posts lmk

[SeveringViper]

SeveringViper - I read this dude like I would try to read Zack and I'm at like 51% chance he's a villager. I know they've been really active as well I just haven't paid nearly as much attention to them. Wanted to include them because I had thought about them as opposed to the other people I didn't mention.

Is just this a volume read and/or do you actually like whatever you have read from me?

[Manasi]

Is just this a volume read and/or do you actually like whatever you have read from me?

More of a tone read. Haven't had much of an opinion either way on you specifically but I'm a fan of you being around.

[Logic]

What was a joke vote for Raith I cannot support with any evidence. He seems rather quiet, but I don't know if that is how he plays on D1, so he gets a pass for now. With what little I have seen from him, I give hime a slight wolf lean.

Both Seireikhaan and Montmorency feel like as good of targets as any, so I'm going to tie it up for the now.
Vote: Montmorency

[Cuthillius]

what do you think is scummy about monty/khaan

in your own words please

[Logic]

what do you think is scummy about monty/khaan

in your own words please

I do hope you don't mind if I use all of Monthy's words as well:

I don't know what's going on. Just tell me who scans type.

Or Vote: novice gets it.

Forced joke. Feels a tad wolfish to me.

Two word Mafia.

Tell me what you see.

Null tell. I feel like I am missing some kind of subtext.

<3, OMG, let's meet up on IRC.

Unvote: novice; Vote: Severing Viper

Responding to Cuth: slight alarms going off here. Feels like a forced joke about breaking the spirit or the letter of the rules. If Monty turns wolf, I would not be surprised if Cuth is one as well.

Isn't "Champ" a Pokemon?

That would have been a proper disposable vote. Too late now though.

Comment's about casting throwaway vote based on username similarity on pokemon. Seems a tad wolfish to me.

What if this is the result we seek?

Slight town lean here. This feels more helpful than not.

Viper is combination of novice, Zack, and Jabbz?

Speculation that seemingly leads nowhere. Not helpful in either case.

I yearn to rely on a stronger will.

I fear what I'm capable of in its absence.

I don't get what Monty is going for here. I don't normally assume being poetic is a wolf trait, but it feels more like an attempt to look more sophisticated, and thus, less wolfy.

Doesn't inspire much sentiment. And Khaan has another semi-character here:



On the other other hand, this post is like his first Futuramafia posts in that he's complaining about certain tactical decisions for the early game:



But Khaan did always say the best way to play scum roles is to do that which the gut wouldn't believe.

Attacking his biggest lynch competitor with what looks like weak reasoning to me. Could be desperate wolf; could be incensed townie. I get the feeling that Monty is a good player, so I think there is more to this than he is saying.

Tally plz GH is making a play for the badge.

The "Play for the badge" comment I am going to have to assume is one of those things under the avatars that GH seems to have already obtained several of. It seems weak reasoning for Monty to mention it, but I am suspicious of that comment in particular without more information.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Csargo - ily

Manasi lock town for this read. I'm only 50% joking.

Vote: khaan

Will put down reasons shortly, but this isn't a random vote.

[novice]

Vote: khaan

Will share my actual thoughts later.

[Montmorency]

Tally plz GH is making a play for the badge.

[SeveringViper]

Tally plz GH is making a play for the badge.

Votes?:

Novice - 1: seireikhaan
Montmorency - 2: autolycus, BSmith
Manasi - 1: Choxorn
GH - 1: Barto
Sooh - 1: Raith
Raith - 1: Logic
Seireikhaan - 3: Csargo, GH, novice
SV - 2: Jabbz, Montmorency

[Cuthillius]

vote:Jabbz

less because i think he's independently wolfy, more that there are a lot of people i think are town

jabbz hasn't provided me with any reason to feel good about his alignment

[novice]

Hey Momty, what's with the bolded statement:

Doesn't inspire much sentiment. And Khaan has another semi-character here:



On the other other hand, this post is like his first Futuramafia posts in that he's complaining about certain tactical decisions for the early game:



But Khaan did always say the best way to play scum roles is to do that which the gut wouldn't believe.

Tally plz GH is making a play for the badge.

This reads like you're holding the door open for a Khaan lynch. Yet in your next post GH is making a play for the badge?

[Montmorency]

But Khaan did always say the best way to play scum roles is to do that which the gut wouldn't believe.

This is a Khaan quote from Futuramafia, where Khaan was scum. I wanted to see how GH would respond in light of his case against Khaan.

He didn't respond, instead saying this to Cuthilius (WHO WAS AGAINST THE CASE AND DIED N1):

If khaan's town, and I point out his lack of character schtick is somewhat worrisome (believe that's the exact phrase I used), and that's his recent history, is that how he hits back at me?

So I tried to warn everyone about GH going for the Pokemon badge, i.e. killing all townies.

Here are my notes on Cuth, btw (I have no other notes):

Cuth: Liked Sooh, novice; liked by novice; weirded by Manasi/Chox; disliked Khaan case by GH; voted Jabbz for non-town but not scummy; Viper sees Cuth-Mont, Logic too?; voted Chox; scumlean by Chox; voted Khaan

[Csargo]

Monty is looking worse today imo.

Zack is here, and looks okay so far. Probably slightly less active than I would expect, but I'll give it time.

Unvote:, Vote: Champ I think he deserves some pressure at this stage. Just dropped a vote on Manasi, and disappeared. Is this how Champ plays?

[Cuthillius]

Just played a quick game of catchup and I can easily say I'm floored at how active Sooh is on this site.

Good stuff.


Reads coming after coffee.

i know right

dm too, actually