Pokemon Nuzlocke FireRed Mafia [Concluded]

[Logic]

Trying to catch up, but here is my thinking through post #500

May I ask what were the reasons for voting in favour of the lynching of Monsieur Montmorency yesterday?

I'd rather not repeat myself, but may I direct you to my case here?

Would agree with all this. Strangely don't like the Mont wagon though despite shady read. Seems like a fool's train. Not really hairy, but like it went in the lead almost incidentally.

To GH about meta question: Off the brief posters, they just stood on in my mind. Csargo mores from past difficulty reading him.

Monty is scummy, but he's not scummy because he is in the lead? What gives?

...No, because I never said anything to Logic about answering for others?

You are going to have to clarify this statement, because it looks like a direct contradiction of this one:

What do you think of cuth answering for you?

I don't like manasi
Vote: Manasi

i feel like she doesnt want to be here and isnt enjoying herself
she loves being town and her lack of engagement is nagl
i dont like khaan i just dont think hes the best lynch

Manasi is less active than in French Rev, but this feels less like a valid read on her, and more like a desperate cover.
Not liking these posts by Champ.

My wolf leans:
Monty
Champ
Severing Viper
Raith Kemmler

My Town leans:
Sooh
Autolycus (mostly because he agreed with my Monty vote, but not in so many words)
Manasi

Everyone not mentioned I haven't spent a lot of time analyzing their posts. Expect another update around 10:30 AM PST.

[Logic]

Also, I suspect that all the plain ol' vanilla's are the Magikarps, and that one of us will evolve into the Gyrados once certain conditions are met. This is just speculation on my part.

[Jabbz]

Also, I suspect that all the plain ol' vanilla's are the Magikarps, and that one of us will evolve into the Gyrados once certain conditions are met. This is just speculation on my part.

This post makes me strongly suspect logic is vanilla town, based on the phrasing of my role pm.

[Zack]

This post makes me strongly suspect logic is vanilla town, based on the phrasing of my role pm.

I'd be pretty surprised if mafia didn't have access to some sort of vanilla town Role PM. Given personal experience with past Pizza games, and this:

9. Mafia's info
The mafia will know who they are and have powers they can safely claim. Try to brute force my game, and prepare for disappointment. They'll always have more info than you.

[Jabbz]

I'd be pretty surprised if mafia didn't have access to some sort of vanilla town Role PM. Given personal experience with past Pizza games, and this:

You're ignoring the clarification later where I talk about mindset and context.

[Jabbz]

Well I'm not sure I'm going to be around at EOD, so I'll throw my vote out now. It doesn't really seem to matter given that there is little chance CSargo isn't swinging. I still think Barto and GHC are the likely scum, and I'll stand by that. Vote: El Barto

In before someone says I'm trying to save CSargo. He's ahead by 5 votes, nothing I do could change that with 2h left.

[Zack]

Well I'm not sure I'm going to be around at EOD, so I'll throw my vote out now. It doesn't really seem to matter given that there is little chance CSargo isn't swinging. I still think Barto and GHC are the likely scum, and I'll stand by that. Vote: El Barto

In before someone says I'm trying to save CSargo. He's ahead by 5 votes, nothing I do could change that with 2h left.

Why GH? I think he is completely out of my POE.

[SeveringViper]

...No, because I never said anything to Logic about answering for others?

You are going to have to clarify this statement, because it looks like a direct contradiction of this one:

What do you think of cuth answering for you?

Really?

And was that anything related to accusing you of getting in the way of questions?

[Montmorency]

Trying to catch up, but here is my thinking through post #500


I'd rather not repeat myself, but may I direct you to my case here?

You may want to update those points.


So, Logic-Sooh or GH-Choxorn for mafs?

[SeveringViper]

So, Logic-Sooh or GH-Choxorn for mafs?

Would you agree that Choxorn being mafia could reflect on you?

I think I don't understand your question as worded. Care to clarify?

Those statements don't contradict themselves as the latter (as quoted) statement was not criticizing you for answering for others, which was the context of the former. Wasn't that clear?

[Montmorency]

You do realize I was responding to this question, right?
Barto asked why I voted for Monty the day prior, and I stated my reasoning.

You can't weasel away that easy, to fiddle at a different angle.

As for GH:
Ok, so GH doesn't think Monty is a good lynch, and then calls everyone on it suspicious. Is he
"clearing" wolf-buddy Monty? That's the vibe I get from this.

Meanwhile, Monty is pushing GH. Distancing from wolf-buddy vibe.

So vote GH, you coward.

This post makes me strongly suspect logic is vanilla town, based on the phrasing of my role pm.

No idea what you mean. But Pizza doesn't want us to discuss Role PMs as such in any further terms.

Would you agree that Choxorn being mafia could reflect on you?

We will deal with it if we come to it. In the Democracy game I alluded to for your edification, I hard-defended Choxorn and then he flipped scum at lynch. Then I hard-defended the next scum to lynch. We got over it and had a good round of drinks. Here? You have seen that I'm minimizing my exposure. But I do still lean town.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

In between those events, I got town GH lynched. But I'm sure I've struck right this time.

[Logic]

You can't weasel away that easy, to fiddle at a different angle.

I answered the question exactly. I'm not weaseling anything.

So vote GH, you coward.

Coward? Now that's rather harsh. Incidentally, I wonder what has given you cause to think I am the least bit afraid.
VOTE: Montmorency

[Montmorency]

"Vote" in caps? Overcompensation. We're onto something here, Pokepeeps.

[novice]

Please heal Manasi.

This post makes me strongly suspect logic is vanilla town, based on the phrasing of my role pm.

surely scum have access to the vanilla role PM?

Which one though? In a field of 3 who claim the same, who would you trust? The first who claimed and so specifically? The counterclaim? The second counterclaim?

Instinct says the first claim is the fishiest, scum eager to get their safe claim in. Second claim is least fishy because it risks a thunderdome.

[Jabbz]

Please heal Manasi.



surely scum have access to the vanilla role PM?



Instinct says the first claim is the fishiest, scum eager to get their safe claim in. Second claim is least fishy because it risks a thunderdome.

It's possible. Once I find out if I get slapped by pizza for discussing role PM's even that much I might cover more.

[Csargo]

It's possible. Once I find out if I get slapped by pizza for discussing role PM's even that much I might cover more.

ATPG is going to slap you no matter what you do, cannot escape.

Logic did Monty strike a nerve?

Gh votes auto, noted. Why auto over BSmith? Their mo's are basically the same.

[GeneralHankerchief]

ATPG is going to slap you no matter what you do, cannot escape.

Logic did Monty strike a nerve?

Gh votes auto, noted. Why auto over BSmith? Their mo's are basically the same.

No real reason, maybe unconsciously pressuring auto to post more since BSmith's already pled RL (and I believe him).

[Logic]

Logic did Monty strike a nerve?

I am not used to name calling in games of Mafia/Werewolf, so the "Coward" comment caught me off guard. However, my caps "VOTE" was not intended to be anything of note. I'm not sure how or why I wrote that out in all caps.

[Jabbz]

ATPG is going to slap you no matter what you do, cannot escape.

I stand by my statement about logic. I find it unlikely that scum would make the connection I did to his post or would have come up with his post in the first place. Combined with a lack of negative feels from him so far this game, I feel safe putting him 98% town.

[Sooh]

Instinct says the first claim is the fishiest, scum eager to get their safe claim in. Second claim is least fishy because it risks a thunderdome.

Ok, I guess I just want a Raith/Chox lynch first and to me I feel like both claims that weren't my own were town claims at the moment.