XCOM Mafia [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

Manasi is a real town lean at about 50 percent confidence.

I can't claim to be an expert Manasi reader at all, but I'm not lynching there anytime soon.

[Logic]

Logic town and not grasping the subtleties of the force.

He unclaimed and explained he's been a miller recently. That has to be annoying.

Of course I don't get "the force." That's in a competing franchise!

[crimson_snow]

I believe you're annoyed by the spam.

I don't believe you have essentially no townies. Weak lean townie on one person is the same as nothing.

republic credits don't work out here, I need something more real.

You did the work loading all these posts and reading up to this point. I think your town game is better than basically nothing so far, so now I have a weak wolfy vibe from you that is very real.

Why? I don't think much if anything this game that has happened is indicative of alignment, so why do you think someone would struggle to find town in a sea of gifs, jokes, and wifom posts?

[Dp101]

Hey DP any reason why you didn't join the wagon if you're annoyed by the lack of content in the game?

Wagons to end spam never work.

[Dp101]

Why? I don't think much if anything this game that has happened is indicative of alignment, so why do you think someone would struggle to find town in a sea of gifs, jokes, and wifom posts?

^^^

[Logic]

I also somehow missed the "unclaim" in my first read-through.

[crimson_snow]

Why? I don't think much if anything this game that has happened is indicative of alignment, so why do you think someone would struggle to find town in a sea of gifs, jokes, and wifom posts?

Wouldn't? I think the intent is clear there anyways.

If anything I lean slightly town on DP for not trying to force reads where he doesn't have them.

[Jowy]

Wagons to end spam never work.

Are you reading him as town? I don't see what's the issue if you aren't.

[Askthepizzaguy]

If anyone tries to lynch you or Champ this game, wipe them out. All of them.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Why? I don't think much if anything this game that has happened is indicative of alignment, so why do you think someone would struggle to find town in a sea of gifs, jokes, and wifom posts?

A generic someone sure. Dp101 is not a generic someone.

[crimson_snow]

If anyone tries to lynch you or Champ this game, wipe them out. All of them.

Tell me about the Champ read? He hasn't even registered as a player in the game to me yet.

I could go back and look at his posts and see if I see what you see, but I'd rather explain it, because I don't like your push on DP here at all.

[crimson_snow]

A generic someone sure. Dp101 is not a generic someone.

You're all generic someones to me!

[Askthepizzaguy]

You're all generic someones to me!

I know. You need time to acclimate and it's possible you don't read very many people right at all.

Different folks I hold to different standards. Specifics, not generics.

[crimson_snow]

I mean, I fully expect people to hold me to some kind of standard. I won't be able to call people town or scum based on how that player is acting relative to previous games of theirs, but there should be some kind of process there and accuracy should be expected to some degree.

Also means I'm not going to take things like 'X is town' with no explanation at face value.

[Fredwood]

Oh, I do love Eddie Izzard.

I hope you have noticed that I am voting for you to be hanged from the neck until you die.

Cake please.

Seems like a you problem not a me problem. I guess I could beg but if I get lynched day 1 in my first game, then I get lynched day 1 in my first game. The Random gods must be sated.

[Champ]

As if Kevin knows anything that isn't candy-related.

because hes fat?
extremely rude

[Jowy]

If anyone tries to lynch you or Champ this game, wipe them out. All of them.

Why Champ?

[Askthepizzaguy]

Tell me about the Champ read? He hasn't even registered as a player in the game to me yet.

I could go back and look at his posts and see if I see what you see, but I'd rather explain it, because I don't like your push on DP here at all.

He barged in here without reading everything, some things but obviously not everything, and began posting.

He should have seen big warning signs in big bold colorful letters that warranted scrutiny if he's scum, so he doesn't modkill himself etc.

Maybe it's NAI for him and he'd not care if he blundered as scum, but in my experience people care about that kind of stuff more when they have a known bunch of teammates working in secret with him.

He's also active and engaged, for him, by comparison to the previous game on here.

It's different and someone could read that as scummy for being different. I do not, because he could have had a very easy and effective scum game by not engaging more.

Now that I think about it maybe he randed scum and is hugely excited about that, and that's why he's sticking around more than a few minutes at a time.

But I'm not on that page yet. I feel good about the townie lean. So we'll see.

[Askthepizzaguy]

I mean, I fully expect people to hold me to some kind of standard. I won't be able to call people town or scum based on how that player is acting relative to previous games of theirs, but there should be some kind of process there and accuracy should be expected to some degree.

Also means I'm not going to take things like 'X is town' with no explanation at face value.

Excellent.

We're in agreement on good town fundamentals and theory at least.

[Dp101]

Are you reading him as town? I don't see what's the issue if you aren't.

Null currently.

[crimson_snow]

He barged in here without reading everything, some things but obviously not everything, and began posting.

He should have seen big warning signs in big bold colorful letters that warranted scrutiny if he's scum, so he doesn't modkill himself etc.

Maybe it's NAI for him and he'd not care if he blundered as scum, but in my experience people care about that kind of stuff more when they have a known bunch of teammates working in secret with him.

He's also active and engaged, for him, by comparison to the previous game on here.

It's different and someone could read that as scummy for being different. I do not, because he could have had a very easy and effective scum game by not engaging more.

Now that I think about it maybe he randed scum and is hugely excited about that, and that's why he's sticking around more than a few minutes at a time.

But I'm not on that page yet. I feel good about the townie lean. So we'll see.

On a superficial level I can see it, but that feels much more player indicative than it does alignment indicative.

Contrary to my previous post, I did read all of Champs posts in isolation and my impression of him is not...someone that would bother closely reading the rules.

I just wanted you to explain it to see if it tracked as something that could be "angly" as I think you referred to the town read being, and I can see how you could have that read as a lean even if not the absolute confidence you expressed in it.

[Champ]

what rules

[El Barto]

Pizza says it doesn't count.

I agree about Pizza.

Let's quasi-bookmark this for information on El Pizzahombre.

Barto! I was just thinking about you, talk to me.

Yes? Hello there, ma'am. What a nice… hat you have.

[crimson_snow]

Null currently.

Part of me wants to be contrarian and stick with my town lean/dislike of the push on DP, but the lack of town reads/leans, calling people null, yet not really trying to change that sends up a couple red flags.

[Logic]

because hes fat?
extremely rude

His intellegence and his weight have nothing to do with each other. However, his expertise in candy might have something to do with his weight.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Here, have some information El bartus.

Vote: El barto

[Askthepizzaguy]

Part of me wants to be contrarian and stick with my town lean/dislike of the push on DP, but the lack of town reads/leans, calling people null, yet not really trying to change that sends up a couple red flags.

He can town-clear himself well by midgame if he is town. That's really the only reason I'm not sinking my teeth into his leg atm.

[crimson_snow]

His intellegence and his weight have nothing to do with each other. However, his expertise in candy might have something to do with his weight.

Reasonably sound logic.

Other than his thoughts on slightly derpy accountants, what are your thoughts on Champ this game?

[Csargo]

Champ y u so engaged this game? You scum? 3rd party? Neutral? Turtle?

[Csargo]

He can town-clear himself well by midgame if he is town. That's really the only reason I'm not sinking my teeth into his leg atm.

You disappoint me ATPG.

Vote:ATPG