XCOM Mafia [Concluded]

[Askthepizzaguy]

I'll even make it a softball question. I think it would be a scummy narrative to call day one bad. Or be at all unenthusiastic about the game state.

No death last night is great, and the actual information that can be gleaned by the tally for much of the round is extremely useful for pairing analysis.

And I have a lot more townies than I did at end of day 1 than start of day 1.

The narrative that day one was bad, is wolfy as hell.

[novice]

The narrative that day one was bad, is wolfy as hell.

A bad day by Champ.

[Sooh]

ISOs bottom up.

Autolucus is a great big ??? with his 1 post.

BSmith not much better with two. Him placing a joke vote on someone to start off the game isn't uncommon. He did the same last game. Him leaving it when he came back and arguably didn't know much about game state is more troubling to me, but I guess there was no real danger that I was being lynched at the point he popped in again.

Logic has many gif posts, jokes and quips. Not much in terms of content otherwise. I don't know why people are townreading him (by people here I guess I mean Pizza, because he's the only one I remember having Logic up high). If anyone is reading him town, can you please let me know why?

Winston started the game with a miller claim, which he later redacted. I think him feeling confident enough to do so is a good sign, plus the fact that he cared enough to follow up when Manasi missed his question. Also he's scum leaning on Logic, which I like :P

Champ not paying attention to the game again. NAI.

Those were the easy ISOs. On to the bigger ones.

[Sooh]

Fredwood: Classical new player until #345. I understand the read on El Barto from someone not used to him. I can also see what he's saying about DP, so good feels in general about that post.
I don't understand who #399 is talking to. Is it to Pizza? I feel like I'm missing context.
From what I see Fredwood is mixing up joke votes with pressure/random votes, which is fine for someone not used to the concept. I still feel pretty good about this ISO, and while I see the defensive that's being brought up I don't think it's unnatural in this case where it's a new player on a new site who's being bugged repeatedly about one misunderstanding. I still have a town lean here.

[Sooh]

Montmorency:
#119 is wut? I don't see how that question led to that answer.
I don't think Monty goes all in on Pizza as scum if Pizza is town. At least that's something I don't remember seeing before. I dislike on both ends the attempts to discredit one another's reads and feels. It will never impress me.
A wish for D2: Can you make more reads all around so that I know your stance on people who aren't Pizza? I don't see Pizza lynched D2 this game, even if he is scum.
I'm having a hard time seeing Monty/Pizza V/V here. One or both may be wolves.

[Sooh]

El Barto:
Obvious joke vote on Fredwood.

Sidenote: After 4 posts in the game, all jokes, Pizza thinks El Barto is cagey.

Another sidenote: Ugh I'm tunneling Pizza.

Why did you vote Jowy here?

Conclusion: lol.

I don't have the same positive vibes from El Barto that I did last game, but at the same time I'm not sure how much negative there is. On second read through he seems ok-ish? I don't feel like he's town for me yet, though I do like his continued questioning for clarification on people's votes and posts.

[Sooh]

Novice: I like #83, #121, #348 (he said earlier he was going to go back to check and then did), the list can go on and on, because I think he's showing incentive to solve, townie process and I like what I'm seeing, even if volume is down from the previous game.

Sidenote: I think #826 is a townie point for Pizza.

[Sooh]

Short break before continuing.

[Sooh]

Read Cuth ISO and feel relatively good about it. I don't have any particular posts to point out, but overall doesn't seem very agenda-y and seems to voice his opinions.

[Sooh]

Manasi:

I don't like this post. Idk if it's a joke, but if true I really don't like it. She also voted me towards EOD and made no comment I think to what I posted, but moved her vote rather late to DP101. I don't like that she had no further opinion of me stated at all. Scum lean.

[Sooh]

Crimson is very much pushing a wifom read of himself. I don't know why he would do that. His first page and a half of ISO seems oddly self centered, advocating a cop check of himself and teasing about hoping he's not the GF etc. There's a lot of "Read me like this" "Don't read me like this" which to me is strange as any alignment, but for him to keep the focus so very much on himself as scum is probably not a thing that happens. Then again it's very scummy to be very self aware, so ugh.

Said he'd be back before EOD, didn't post again until middle of the Night phase.

I'm at null here very much.

[Sooh]

Too lazy to read Pizza, Csargo and DP ISO, at least right now.

TL:DR

Askthepizzaguy - 164
autolycus - 1 - ???
BSmith - 2 - ???
Champ - 18 - ????
crimson_snow - 67 - ???
Csargo - 113
Cuthillius - 54 - mild town
Dp101 - 98
El Barto - 37 - null to town
Fredwood - 28 - towny
Logic - 14 - scummy
Manasi - 57 - scummy
Montmorency - 31 - null to scum
novice - 40 - towny
Sooh - 28 - town
Winston Hughes - 17 - Towny