Calling who the mafia are but not pushing them is not credit.

You give Xia no credit for actually voting wolves when they weren't consensus and it's a dangerous vote, but give yourself credit for calling GH as scummy if Logic flips and then pushing the same narrative as him when Logic did flip.

If you are town and coincidentally happened to do this then yeah, credit. Won't take it away.

But that looks more like PIS than solving.