Hearthstone Mafia [Concluded]

[Montmorency]

Scumish
El Barto - Slightly confused by the 848% earlier, but I'm assuming it was a typo not something sinister. His coded flavor-text may be what is pinging my scum-dar, but I can't identify why he feels less than genuine this early.
Monty - Seeing his last game has made me super wary of him, and he is in my "usual suspects" bucket until proven otherwise.
GeneralHankerchief - Too little content to base anything on. But I could see a "chaos³" GH this early.
Snerk/Dp101 - Snerk/Dp101 have given little to go on, but I can't find a real reason to vote elsewhere yet.

Interesting that GH had too little content to judge, though GH had as many posts as Kage and was probably median in post-count.

GH and Logic team, back for revenge?!

Csargo is also tickling me, but I'll have to figure scenarios for the late vote on Dp.

Kage is mysterious and Sooh and Dp are null.

Manasi is lock town and cannot die.

[Manasi]

Interesting that GH had too little content to judge, though GH had as many posts as Kage and was probably median in post-count.

GH and Logic team, back for revenge?!

Csargo is also tickling me, but I'll have to figure scenarios for the late vote on Dp.

Kage is mysterious and Sooh and Dp are null.

Manasi is lock town and cannot die.

If I say I want to kill GH he's gonna go postal.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

But I wanna kill GH.

[GeneralHankerchief]

If I say I want to kill GH he's gonna go postal.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

But I wanna kill GH.

Nah I just wish you had talked out your Barto thing, like, at all, before the lynch. What about my process didn't you like?

[Manasi]

Nah I just wish you had talked out your Barto thing, like, at all, before the lynch. What about my process didn't you like?

Even suggesting you'd take my read on Barto as anything seriously is kinda funny, you'd typically just brush it off.

I think that your scum read on him was baseless, think he was being more relevant than most people and there were infinitely scummier people.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Even suggesting you'd take my read on Barto as anything seriously is kinda funny, you'd typically just brush it off.

I think that your scum read on him was baseless, think he was being more relevant than most people and there were infinitely scummier people.

If you honestly think that's how I treat your posts then I apologize, I certainly don't intend on doing that.

Anyway, I'd like to go back to this post:

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Gah, I've got work to do and am not sure I'll be around to heavily influence the deadline.

So POEing this:

Csargo
El Barto
GeneralHankerchief
Kagemusha
Logic
Manasi
Montmorency
Snerk/Dp101
Sooh

I'm town. Csar, Sooh, and Manasi have made good posts. Logic is solving in a way that looks decent enough for now and is moving stuff forward at least, plus I feel better about his Manasi clarification that he pointed out to me. There was the one early Monty post I liked that I talked about earlier.

So that leaves:

El Barto
Kagemusha
Snerk/Dp101

Kage is... I think I can figure him out and even though I still somewhat suspect him I think his interactions with me have been fairly natural, so he gets to live for a day.

Snerk's iso was entirely null and Dp's is a bit lacking, even though he's shown signs of pretty clearly general disinterest/not being around much. So even though I think he can do better he might just honestly be Not Around Much.

So that leaves Barto.

My vote's staying where it is barring somebody making a me-in-Chess level post (and I see it) between now and deadline.

This is basically where I laid out my thinking w/r/t the D1 lynch. I didn't necessarily have a scumread on Barto so much as I liked everyone else better. I thought that was made pretty clear in the round where I didn't actually give a reason for any of my votes on Barto beyond humoring Kage (initially) and then this post. See where I'm coming from?

Where do you and I disagree with our placements of people?

[Manasi]

If you honestly think that's how I treat your posts then I apologize, I certainly don't intend on doing that.

Anyway, I'd like to go back to this post:

This is basically where I laid out my thinking w/r/t the D1 lynch. I didn't necessarily have a scumread on Barto so much as I liked everyone else better. I thought that was made pretty clear in the round where I didn't actually give a reason for any of my votes on Barto beyond humoring Kage (initially) and then this post. See where I'm coming from?

Where do you and I disagree with our placements of people?

I think that we're kind of similar in terms of reads. I think that DP and Logic are probably my top towns.

Main difference is that I think all of the scum are in Sooh, yourself, Monty, and Kage.

Csargo is posting well, I agree, so I'd give him a town read for that.

I still haven't shook the tinfoil that wolves can just put it effort and be better than most of the town so I don't know how confident I'm gonna be going through the rest of the game at all, but that's where I am.

Why "clear" Kage for the lynch but push Barto who was obviously having more fun than like ~most of the thread?

I know you said you can probably figure his alignment out etc, but can't you also do that for Barto? I feel like his alignment isn't that hard to place.

[GeneralHankerchief]

I think that we're kind of similar in terms of reads. I think that DP and Logic are probably my top towns.

Main difference is that I think all of the scum are in Sooh, yourself, Monty, and Kage.

Csargo is posting well, I agree, so I'd give him a town read for that.

I still haven't shook the tinfoil that wolves can just put it effort and be better than most of the town so I don't know how confident I'm gonna be going through the rest of the game at all, but that's where I am.

Why "clear" Kage for the lynch but push Barto who was obviously having more fun than like ~most of the thread?

I know you said you can probably figure his alignment out etc, but can't you also do that for Barto? I feel like his alignment isn't that hard to place.

I'm a LOT more confident in reading Kage than Barto. I've never really been able to place Barto well.

As far as your scum pile, I feel reasonably confident about Sooh. Freely admit that Monty could have just skunked me with that one early post of his that I talked about earlier so I might see myself going there depending on how D2 shakes out.

What makes you think the Dp slot is town? It didn't really do much of anything yesterday.

[Sooh]

I don't really think this is scum!Manasi. She's nothing like how I remember her previous scum game. I also don't think Manasi would place her partner here in her reads list
vv

I think that we're kind of similar in terms of reads. I think that DP and Logic are probably my top towns.

Main difference is that I think all of the scum are in Sooh, yourself, Monty, and Kage.

Csargo is posting well, I agree, so I'd give him a town read for that.

I still haven't shook the tinfoil that wolves can just put it effort and be better than most of the town so I don't know how confident I'm gonna be going through the rest of the game at all, but that's where I am.

Why "clear" Kage for the lynch but push Barto who was obviously having more fun than like ~most of the thread?

I know you said you can probably figure his alignment out etc, but can't you also do that for Barto? I feel like his alignment isn't that hard to place.

I know she gave that piece of self-meta herself, but it just reads a bit strange to me. Why would she single him out like that?

I feel like she's been appealing to me quite a lot this game though (mainly because I haven't been posting and generally not helped anyone at all). I am not sure if scum Manasi does that after I nailed her to the wall in her last scum game here. I would think that scum!Manasi would be happy I wasn't in the thread tbh.

Then again I know you're a good player and probably very capable of fooling me, but I'm not willing to lynch you today, and I'm assuming that I'll die N3, so I'll leave that problem to somebody else.

[Csargo]

Interesting that GH had too little content to judge, though GH had as many posts as Kage and was probably median in post-count.

GH and Logic team, back for revenge?!

Csargo is also tickling me, but I'll have to figure scenarios for the late vote on Dp.

Kage is mysterious and Sooh and Dp are null.

Manasi is lock town and cannot die.

I'd like to hear your theories, regale me with your stories.

[Manasi]

Monty calling me lock town is