Star Wars: Rebels [In Play]

[Manasi]

Wait wtf EOD was at 1 PM I'm sorry.

Also rip Zack :(

Sorry babe.

Yeah it's been a hectic day or two but I think everything I'm doing is within my villa range. Compare this game to the HS game and I think you'll see that. Don't really remember how Csargo was reading me that game but I do think I've been playing pretty similarly.

[Manasi]

Wait lmao can we talk about this conversion thing or no because lmfao

[Csargo]

Wait lmao can we talk about this conversion thing or no because lmfao

[Csargo]

Wait wtf EOD was at 1 PM I'm sorry.

Also rip Zack :(

Sorry babe.

Yeah it's been a hectic day or two but I think everything I'm doing is within my villa range. Compare this game to the HS game and I think you'll see that. Don't really remember how Csargo was reading me that game but I do think I've been playing pretty similarly.

You dun goofed.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Look at their interactions. The likelihood of them being scum together is pretty high imo. There's no way you cannot see that. I've been harping on Manasi for the better part of the entire phase, so I'm not sure why you're surprised my vote went there at EoD.

Honestly, no idea why Monty switched in the end, but Manasi was definitely worthy of voting there I think.

Disagree, I don't think Zack would have shaded Manasi like he did if they were partners. Feel like they would have hard townread each other and try to barrel through the game.

Also feel like Zack would have posted more too.

[Csargo]

[GeneralHankerchief]

Why would it be suspicious unless you think he's slipping that he's a wolf with you or something? Bizarre to call it wolfy fypov.

This is Zack shading Manasi, Csar (context is her bit on Snerk). It's not as strong as I initially thought but I'm still not sure mafia!Zack takes this approach with a partner.

[Csargo]

This is Zack shading Manasi, Csar (context is her bit on Snerk). It's not as strong as I initially thought but I'm still not sure mafia!Zack takes this approach with a partner.

I mean it's so mild. To me it seems fairly likely with hindsight especially, but I'm not nearly as knowledgeable on either of their playstyles. Judging purely on how Zack approached this game, I'ma vote Monty tomorrow I think.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Why would it be suspicious unless you think he's slipping that he's a wolf with you or something? Bizarre to call it wolfy fypov.

I mean it's so mild. To me it seems fairly likely with hindsight especially, but I'm not nearly as knowledgeable on either of their playstyles. Judging purely on how Zack approached this game, I'ma vote Monty tomorrow I think.

I think that's definitely a good place to start.

Idk about the Manasi thing, I just... really think Zack would have played differently if that was the case.

Snerk also a good choice to look at - it was Manasi's going after Snerk that prompted Zack's shade.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Right, I need to clear my multiquote. Sorry.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Wow, you guys chat a lot.

Sorry I haven't done anything yet. I'm still trying to get back into the swing of coming to this forum on a regular basis.

So, um, for now I'll Vote: Zack. He was third for the votes on GH, until Snerk abandoned wagon.

Player	Votes	By
Csargo	I	Sooh
El Barto
GeneralHankerchief	II	Montmorency, Zack
Lex-Kat
Manasi	I	Snerk
Montmorency	II	Csargo, GeneralHankerchief
Snerk	I	El Barto
Sooh
Zack	I	Lex-Kat

Did I miss Manasi's vote?

I don't think so? I only posted for one other game here, back in 2015, and I failed to play. I am trying to be better about it this time.

And since that means I am an unknown on this site, I will try to rectify that... somewhat. I am a quiet player. I don't try to make a lot of flashy posts about nothing just to talk. I usually respond to other posts.

I still think Zack is suspicious, but that could be said for a lot of players, since it is only Day 1, and it is hard to get a good read on anyone at the beginning of the game.

Lex-Kat is almost certainly town.

[Csargo]

I think that's definitely a good place to start.

Idk about the Manasi thing, I just... really think Zack would have played differently if that was the case.

Snerk also a good choice to look at - it was Manasi's going after Snerk that prompted Zack's shade.

The problem with playing like that is once one dies their post's are scrutinized pretty heavily, so if you're buddy-buddy it's fairly obvious, of course I guess that's all WIFOM in the end though isn't it.

That's true. Maybe Manasi was right all along...

[Snerk]

Townish: GH, Lex.

If there's bussing it's Lex. A Zack lynch was looking unlikely when she voted for him, with only one vote and very little heat on him in general. If I or GH bussed, it's pretty ruthless. I don't think there was bussing though.

Scummish: Manasi, Barto, Monty

Manasi was shifty overall. Barto too, with minimal content.
If Monty is scum it could provide some answers to why the mafia seemed reluctant to try a more aggressive attempt at a mislynch.

[Montmorency]

Aces. I feel super good. We've got a few lock clears.

I was wrong about 3 scum. Zack had a conversion power. Makes sense now.

Snerk, you started the Zack wagon early in the day when there was no pressure on him. Pretending like LK is a likelier candidate for partner is NAGL.

[Montmorency]

Bye anyone want to claim Alexander Kallus?

[Montmorency]

Snerk, my apologies.

I had it mixed up. I thought you voted Zack after he voted GH for some reason. My bad.

[Snerk]

Snerk, you started the Zack wagon early in the day when there was no pressure on him. Pretending like LK is a likelier candidate for partner is NAGL.

No I dropped the vote a few hours before EOD. And it tied him for a lynch. Hardly no pressure.

[Snerk]

X-post. No worries.

[El Barto]

And I don't know you well enough to know if you are joking. If so... ha ha? If not...

I was riffing on Monty's Palpatine impersonation.

Wait. How have I already posted more than you expected?

You mentioned Zelda recently so you can't be done playing that yet.

Vote:Manasi

Vote: Manasi

On phone, so no more reasoning for this phase.

The one at :53 and the other at :56, what the hell were you two doing?

Bye anyone want to claim Alexander Kallus?

Fishing for partners, man?

[Csargo]

I was riffing on Monty's Palpatine impersonation.

You mentioned Zelda recently so you can't be done playing that yet.


The one at :53 and the other at :56, what the hell were you two doing?

Fishing for partners, man?

[Snerk]

I was wrong about 3 scum.

And I still find it suspicious that you thought there was three scum before Zack's flip. Can't elaborate on this, would bend some rules, the peeps will see it if they see it and make up their own minds.

[Montmorency]

I was riffing on Monty's Palpatine impersonation.

You mentioned Zelda recently so you can't be done playing that yet.


The one at :53 and the other at :56, what the hell were you two doing?

Fishing for partners, man?

Zack had a conversion power eligible just for Alexander Kallus. Whoever claims Alexander Kallus is lock clear. Therefore, it is in Town's best interest to have Alexander Kallus come forward.

And I still find it suspicious that you thought there was three scum before Zack's flip. Can't elaborate on this, would bend some rules, the peeps will see it if they see it and make up their own minds.

We'll talk about this in the morning.


I was on the right track with my analysis at EOD. The Mafia had a volatile situation in which they didn't want to interfere needlessly, with at best a tie looming between two townies (me and GH). I disagree with GH that scum-Zack doesn't interact with scum-Manasi that way, though it's not a strong indicator. And I don't think we can expect both scum to have very similar behavior, or else in theory GH would be the best candidate for D1 play most similar to Zack (excepting EOD). What Zack did, he shaded GH and voted him, and OTOH hand shaded Manasi with slightly more detail while not pushing her at all. At a time when Manasi was almost dominating the thread. Isn't this a common scum-play dichotomy to create deniability or misdirect instincts?

Csargo vs. Manasi: The way Csargo jumped at the CFD opportunity onto Manasi suggests that Csargo was trying to take heat off scum-Zack. If Manasi's flip does not end the game, Csargo is >75% scum.

IMO this is fine, because we never lynch inside:

Monty
GH
Snerk
Sooh
Lex-Kat (except LYLO)

[Montmorency]

Orbital strike incoming

Manasi look out

Hi Csargo

P.S. Sooh is Innocent Child again

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

Grand Admiral Thrawn

Admiral-sama! Notice me!

SOOH IS MECHANICALLY CLEAR DO NOT LYNCH

[Logic]

End of night 1.
Please do not post.
Update may take a while: posting from mobile

[Logic]

GeneralHankerchief was killed

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

"Send a probe to investigate. All leads must be pursued."
―Kallus



General Hankerchief, you are Agent Alexsandr Kallus. You begin the game as team Empire, and win when both of the Rebels are eliminated. Or if successfully recruited by the Rebels, you win when the Rebels have reached parity with the Empire.

You are optionally recruitable to the rebel side.

Manasi was killed

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

“There are some things far more frightening than death.”
―The Inquisitor



Manasi, you are The Grand Inquisitor.
You are team Empire and win when both of the Rebels are eliminated.

You may select one player each night. You see if that player leaves, or if anyone visits your selected player.

Begin day 2
@Csargo
@El Barto
@Lex-Kat
@Montmorency
@Snerk
@Sooh
You may now post

[Montmorency]

Hmm. Well, not everything can go our way.

It has been a pleasure towning with you, GH. You will be avenged.

Csargo, what do you have to say for yourself?

[Csargo]

I mean, I could ask you the same thing...

[Snerk]

Sooh, can you confirm Monty's role claim on you?

[Csargo]

As far as you saying I was trying to start a cfd, I just moved my vote to who I wanted to lynch at the time. There's no way I'd try to save Zack if I was scum there, because that's just a terrible idea, it has no chance of working when >50% of the players just post a couple times a day. That's just exposing yourself for <1% chance of success, it's foolhardy.

[Snerk]

It's Csargo or Monty then. Mechanically I'm leaning Monty, tonewise I'm leaning Csargo.

Ooooooooooooooooooooooooor.....





vote: El Barto


what?