04/12 Generic Fantasy WW Game Thread

i reread through game and updating my groupings that seem so popular with ppl

confirmed/dead good:
empoof

very strong good:
zack
insaner

probably good:
ladd
general
montmorency

likely good:
fable
dyachei
newyn

maybe good:
logic
cuthilius
csargo

maybe bad:
choxorn
egix

dead/confirmed bad:
el barto
pzelda

ppl are already voting egix so

vote: choxorn

maybe i should have logic a grouping lower than i do, bcz with ladd no longer being a strong bad read for me idk why i think logic is good. if there are bads voting for bads it is probably one of cuthilius or csargo

general and ladd are close to being up 1 grouping but the interactions going both directions are stronger for zack and insaner

fable is maybe 1 grouping too low too, i think i think i think he is more good than the other two in his grouping, but all 3 are probz good

ama if u have questions

This is where I'm at -
Never lynch outside of a lylo situation: Zack, Insaner, ladd
Probably town: Cuth, GH, Monty
Voted for confirmed mafia: Fable, Dya, Csargo
Don't like their vote but their posts seem towny: Logic, Merlin
Lynch with fire: Egix, Choxorn

I'd prefer a Choxorn lynch over Egix for selfish reasons (I'm clear if he's mafia )
Merlin would be higher in the probably town section if I base it off only his content but I'm a little worried that his posts feels abit too towny for someone who's supposedly new to forum mafia and I don't really like his reason for voting ladd yesterday.

I'm about to go to bed, and while obviously we still have a long while to go before the day ends, I'd much rather prefer an Egix lynch here over a Choxorn one (or one for anybody else, but this post is talking about Choxorn specifically). This is partly because I think Egix has straight-up been scummier than Chox, partly because of various nightkill-related musings I've had that I'll share if I deem the time to be right. Somebody ping me about this tomorrow or Monday in case I forget to elaborate on it.

Originally Posted by Newyn

This is where I'm at -
Never lynch outside of a lylo situation: Zack, Insaner, ladd
Probably town: Cuth, GH, Monty
Voted for confirmed mafia: Fable, Dya, Csargo
Don't like their vote but their posts seem towny: Logic, Merlin
Lynch with fire: Egix, Choxorn

I'd prefer a Choxorn lynch over Egix for selfish reasons (I'm clear if he's mafia )
Merlin would be higher in the probably town section if I base it off only his content but I'm a little worried that his posts feels abit too towny for someone who's supposedly new to forum mafia and I don't really like his reason for voting ladd yesterday.

Why is ladd in your top category?

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

Why is ladd in your top category?

What he posted yesterday regarding El barto and Pzelda doesn't feel w/w to me and more importantly, El Barto listened to Insaner and switched to ladd when Insaner asked even though he was voting for Insaner before this. I don't see a wolf willingly going along with that if they're partners with ladd.

Maybe I was wrong about merl1n.

Originally Posted by merl1n

i guess pzelda can be lynched, but i think a lot of people pushing/voting them are suspicious

Who were you talking about here?

I feel validated and embarassed at the same time.

Also for ladd to be a wolf, the top wagons at the end of yesterday was w/w/w or w/w/w/w if both ladd/Choxorn are wolves in which case, what are the wolves doing this game?

Originally Posted by Insaner

I feel validated and embarassed at the same time.

I have some thoughts but I think I'd rather hold on to them for now. I wanna see how today develops first.

Originally Posted by nl.

Tally:
1 Montmorency (Pzelda,)
3 El Barto (Zack, Cuth, Csargo)
4 PZelda (Insaner, monty, Dya, GH)
1 Newyn (Choxorn)
4 Ladd (Fable, Logic, Egix, merl1n)
1 Insaner (El Barto)
3 CHoxorn (Empoof, Newyn, ladd)

LMK if i've made a mistake.

insaner and somewhat dya pushing on them so strongly skeeved me out as i didnt think theyd been all that memorable. i thought ladd was bad and insaner was maybe bad, though they werent together. with two confirmed bads to look at posts of, i think i was probably wrong on all accounts there

Originally Posted by Newyn

This is where I'm at -
Never lynch outside of a lylo situation: Zack, Insaner, ladd
Probably town: Cuth, GH, Monty
Voted for confirmed mafia: Fable, Dya, Csargo
Don't like their vote but their posts seem towny: Logic, Merlin
Lynch with fire: Egix, Choxorn

I'd prefer a Choxorn lynch over Egix for selfish reasons (I'm clear if he's mafia )
Merlin would be higher in the probably town section if I base it off only his content but I'm a little worried that his posts feels abit too towny for someone who's supposedly new to forum mafia and I don't really like his reason for voting ladd yesterday.

What makes you view Cuth as probable town at this point?

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

I'm about to go to bed, and while obviously we still have a long while to go before the day ends, I'd much rather prefer an Egix lynch here over a Choxorn one (or one for anybody else, but this post is talking about Choxorn specifically). This is partly because I think Egix has straight-up been scummier than Chox, partly because of various nightkill-related musings I've had that I'll share if I deem the time to be right. Somebody ping me about this tomorrow or Monday in case I forget to elaborate on it.

im agreeable to egix being lynched, i just want them to both have votes. theres only a few ppl who didnt vote a now known bad and i think the others are all good

Originally Posted by merl1n

insaner and somewhat dya pushing on them so strongly skeeved me out as i didnt think theyd been all that memorable. i thought ladd was bad and insaner was maybe bad, though they werent together. with two confirmed bads to look at posts of, i think i was probably wrong on all accounts there

pzelda wasn't that memorable? I can't say I fully understand where you're coming from, but fair enough.

Originally Posted by Csargo

pzelda wasn't that memorable? I can't say I fully understand where you're coming from, but fair enough.

i think you were even less memorable if that helps. i thought you and pzelda were the same person because someone called them capage, and i thought that was you posting on the wrong acct or something xD

Originally Posted by merl1n

i think you were even less memorable if that helps. i thought you and pzelda were the same person because someone called them capage, and i thought that was you posting on the wrong acct or something xD

That's my special ability, I'm the least memorable person you'll ever play with. Remember that.

Originally Posted by Csargo

What makes you view Cuth as probable town at this point?

I've read them as town since early yesterday because I was pretty much on the same page as him regarding Merlin. He also voted for a confirmed wolf relatively early so unless something changes, I see no reason to reevaluate my read on him for now.

I don't think I can really defend how crappy I was yesterday- I'm busy IRL a lot and don't always pay enough attention and that turns into me being way too inactive.

Current thoughts: Zack is lock town, merl1n, Insaner, ladd, GH, and Fable are all likely town, lots of the thread looks somewhere between town and scum to me. Looks like lots of folks wanna lynch either me or Egix today based on how we acted yesterday, and I also thought he was suspicious yesterday- but I also tracked him doing nothing last night, which is far from clearing but is certainly a point in his favor.

Really need to read things a bit more to get a stronger idea of who's scummy, I'll get to that later but for now I need to go eat dinner.

Originally Posted by Newyn

I've read them as town since early yesterday because I was pretty much on the same page as him regarding Merlin. He also voted for a confirmed wolf relatively early so unless something changes, I see no reason to reevaluate my read on him for now.

I completely forgot Cuth was on Barto before me, it didn't register in my head for some reason.

Meh. I think

I think it's probably just Egix tbh.

Was gonna ask what Choxo did in order to remove himself from exactly rand category but they just claimed tracker.

Oh they claim track on Egix. I don't think wolf Egix would've thought himself to be a good kill carrier given his position at the end. I think mechanically we aren't supposed to lynch him now =/ But I think he is a good info lynch and I don't recall him ever commenting on my pzelda push yesterday.

Mainly I want them lynched so GH can clear himself by flipping a wolf. I liked him a lot today actually, buy if Egix flips villa I will be suspicious.

I'm town. I don't have any powers (apart from my voice and vote ofc)

Originally Posted by Insaner

I feel validated and embarassed at the same time.

1 wolf hard pushed. 1 wolf hard defended. Balanced as all things should be.

Originally Posted by GeneralHankerchief

This is a really rough post.

I wouldn't have made such a careless post about someone if I actually knew they were scum.

Should take a look at Empoof's reads at some point.

heyo scoobs, how is kife going?

I realized it was you yday at eod with avatar change et all but I was too tired to process it

Originally Posted by ladd

heyo scoobs, how is kife going?

I realized it was you yday at eod with avatar change et all but I was too tired to process it

life*

also egix, what are your reads rn? Part of me thinks you would not push me d1 as scum but your posts arent good

Originally Posted by Insaner

Should take a look at Empoof's reads at some point.

But my initial guess is lolspk.