04/12 Generic Fantasy WW Game Thread

[Fable]

Everyone sees logic just trying to fill space right?

[Logic]

Everyone sees logic just trying to fill space right?

Compare that with your "memes" and tell me what you think is actually better.

[Fable]

Compare that with your "memes" and tell me what you think is actually better.

My memes obv

[Logic]

@Cuthillius

Hmm. It does seem other than in the early random posting stage you never called zack anything but villagery. I seem to remember it differently, and I don't know why.

My memes obv

Hotlink.doubt.mu.gif

[Fable]

@Cuthillius

Hmm. It does seem other than in the early random posting stage you never called zack anything but villagery. I seem to remember it differently, and I don't know why.


Hotlink.doubt.mu.gif

I mean not doing stuff is better than pretending to do stuff

[Logic]

I mean not doing stuff is better than pretending to do stuff

I disagree on the "Pretending"
Vote: Fable

[Fable]

I disagree on the "Pretending"
Vote: Fable

Cool talk about how I memed all day then bused last minute for no reason.

[GeneralHankerchief]

Town
Zack
Fable
Insaner

Choxorn
Choxorn

Probably town
Logic
Montmorency
ladd

Low town
Cuth
merl1n

idk my bff jill
Csargo
dya
Newyn

Mafia
Egix

---

Some thoughts:

Fable's in the top category along with Zack and Insaner and, yes, ahead of Logic. Let me explain. Aside from replicating what I consider to be one of his town mindsets on D1, Fable swooped in near the end and put a decisive vote on pzelda. A potential bus, yes, but he got some cred with it. Now, indulge me for a minute for a thought exercise. Let's say you're mafia!Fable and you're on a team D1 with pzelda, El Barto, and somebody else. Zelda and Barto both got serious pressure, so bussing might be in order... but what has he done with the cred? Posted a gif and referred to "memes" while referencing the fact that he voted mafia yesterday. Fable's a better mafioso than this. Barto being vigged doesn't change the calculus of mafia!Fable's potential mindset for me, dude was never long for this world and Fable would have known it. This complete lack of putting on airs is not how a deeper scum behaves, ever.

Choxorn is his own category. If he's actually a tracker, the mafia can't afford to leave him alive indefinitely. If he's not, then we'll know.

My dropping Logic down a category is more of a holistic sense of how I feel the game going more than any post or posts he's made. I've noticed in general quite a bit of friction between the three GITPers (Logic, Cuth, and Newyn) in terms of trying to find each other in the game, a friction that I do not believe would be as present if all three were town. My having Logic at least one category above the other two people speaks to how I still feel about him, but it's a feeling I can't quite shake.

As for my two low towns, Cuth's placement there is mostly his response to Zack's one post that I pointed out a couple of hours ago, where he says that he wouldn't bus in this exact game and these exact circumstances precisely because of what Zack highlighted, and it just struck me as very townie in the moment. I like to think that I know Cuth decently well from our previous games together as well as our time designing and running the most recent Anni game, and it just lines up very well with what I know of Cuth. His partner in this section, merl1n, has posted very well and is keeping up a good amount of effort, but he doesn't get to break into the above categories because of how D1 shook out.

The "idk my bff jill" section consists of people I haven't really had the time or effort to better sort. Sorry about that, nothing personal. I'm picking up some very minor scum vibes from dya, mostly because she hasn't hit those little town notes that I ascribe to her town game (Zack that last part was just to see if you're paying attention), but I'm not entirely certain how much of that can be chalked up to general fatigue since her past two games have both ended in intense f3s.

[Cuthillius]

vote: Logic

let me summarize your game as i see it

you don't talk about the wolves at all

you strongly v-read insaner, the consensus read who's all over the place, and you cast doubt on zack, the one who's likely to actually get things done in this crowd

originally this is just because you don't find anything particularly ai about his posts

when justifying this suspicion on d2, you say it's because you'd be suspicious in a late-game scenario, but it's d2 and you've been doing it out of the gate

you push ladd, rescind once no longer viable

you find people suspicious for pushes without weight behind them and then make a few yourself

thoughts?

[Logic]

vote: Logic

let me summarize your game as i see it

you don't talk about the wolves at all

you strongly v-read insaner, the consensus read who's all over the place, and you cast doubt on zack, the one who's likely to actually get things done in this crowd

originally this is just because you don't find anything particularly ai about his posts

when justifying this suspicion on d2, you say it's because you'd be suspicious in a late-game scenario, but it's d2 and you've been doing it out of the gate

you push ladd, rescind once no longer viable

you find people suspicious for pushes without weight behind them and then make a few yourself

thoughts?

I have made a single push for the only person I have suspected. I'm still formulating a few worlds in my mind. Right now I'm suspecting Fable most, but it's the dissonance of their pushes that make me think there's something off there.

You and scoobs are probably the only ones that have any idea what good scum Logic looks like, and that's partially because the Playground werewolf scene doesn't take itself too seriously and that my tells are not seen for tells. I can also definitively say that my scum signs are not present in the game, and that you should know by now.

But, vote me if you think that's where you need to go. You're wrong.

[Egix]

I have made a single push for the only person I have suspected. I'm still formulating a few worlds in my mind. Right now I'm suspecting Fable most, but it's the dissonance of their pushes that make me think there's something off there.

You and scoobs are probably the only ones that have any idea what good scum Logic looks like, and that's partially because the Playground werewolf scene doesn't take itself too seriously and that my tells are not seen for tells. I can also definitively say that my scum signs are not present in the game, and that you should know by now.

But, vote me if you think that's where you need to go. You're wrong.

I don't remember you having this same attitude when you were being wagoned/about to be lynched in the Valentine's Day game.

[merl1n]

every1 seems to point to general as always reading logic right if general is good. what is the sample size on that? has he really never been wrong on logics alignment when good?

[merl1n]

fable is 1 of my stronger good reads i think. i think his vote on pzelda is the opposite of bussing and trying to get credit from it. it seemed more focused on not lynching ladd and him feeling bad if it happened bc he was memeing

[Logic]

I don't remember you having this same attitude when you were being wagoned/about to be lynched in the Valentine's Day game.

Which one was that? The Hydra where I was the poison healer with Capage? Pretty sure I said I do my best work when pressured there, and was fine with the votes on me.

If you want a sample of my scum game, Princess Bride, both A & B are quite emblematic of my scum-style.

[Csargo]

Which one was that? The Hydra where I was the poison healer with Capage? Pretty sure I said I do my best work when pressured there, and was fine with the votes on me.

If you want a sample of my scum game, Princess Bride, both A & B are quite emblematic of my scum-style.

Where can I find that/those game/s?