Mass Effect 17er [Game Thread]

[Maple]

bronana your iso is about as paper thin as it gets

what else are you expecting?

there are far better reasons to call me a wolf

if i were a wolf, i'd list them here, but as a villager i wont hattip

[Arapocalypse]

Anyways, continuing my previous train of thought:

While yes a lot of the time mafia reads are created from the absence of townreads, today's pushes feel a lot more like people who don't have townreads yet but may turn into townreads, given the time to make more posts and hype!!!! Dya/Raskolnikov are very high examples of this read... essentially, it's the underwhelming thing that gives the shrug EoD-feeling!!

Lowkey want to do something spicy!!!

Also, unrelated: I really liked that post that Capage had regarding... I think it was the Montmorency read? Might be useful to go back in my ISO in future days, potentially!!

[Maple]

it relates to what you said would have been the reason I have weak wolf reads

Not just weak: bad

[Dolby]

fwiw I've also played with town csargo in a serious/non-gimmick game once I think?

[Maple]

why was amy a wagon again?

i dont remember any of rekt's posts or whatever their name is

[Maple]

hard pass

respectable

i dont actually know why i asked that

did this post go through?

[GeneralHankerchief]

Anyway I feel bad for Rask coming into this specific slot as a sub, but I don't think he's really done enough + other outstanding concerns from Amy.

Csargo probably my #2 choice, even though I still feel kinda bad about it (this has nothing to do with the case on him, I mean it's what it is, it's just because I like Csargo and don't get to play with him that often).

dya well behind the other two, I think they're close to rand at this point really and the other two have less going for them.

[Raskolnikov]

Vote: Rask

for now

Wagons:

Rask:
+ Decent D1 arguments against Amp, flip has much assoc equity
- Traditionally subs get a reprieve, and content-wise I've never had anything against Amp

Csargo:
+ Not a bad wagon makeup, decent arguments against on paper
- I want to ISO Star Trek D1 for the complete picture on Csargo, present it for D2, also I like to give Csargo a break
0 vig candidate

Dyachei: GH has it right that the dyachei push is the amy push but less of everything




My instinct with this kind of post, where are top wagon mildly defends another top wagon, is that if Csargo is scum dyachei has a high probability of being anti-spewed (i.e. not paired).

Interestingly, Rask/Amp is doing the same near above this post. Grapes are fermenting.



LEANS

NEUTRAL (not null)
Dolb
Sunbae

TOWN
--66%
Ara
Hally

NULL
CL
Visor
Cuth
Eph
GH

Maple
Esoo
Manasi

dya
Amy
Csargo

SCUM
Zelda
--33%

Not very charitable from you Monty. Too bad I don't have time for another ISO rn, but I would CFD you just from this read list!

[Dolby]

why was amy a wagon again?

i dont remember any of rekt's posts or whatever their name is

Visor didn't like her townleaning him basically.

Ara, what post number was the pzelda post you liked?

[Arapocalypse]

I got burned hard by Csargo in Zelda's game with items and more than 17 players that was themed on some board game (tbh I kinda purged it from memory), but the two prior games that he scummed that I witnessed (one game I was town, the other maf) I felt that he was pretty obvious. Didn't really engage with people and just gave takes seemingly for the purpose of giving takes unless he was specifically asked about something. Haven't played with him or really noticed him in a game in a while, and I respect the differences brought up by GH and others but this feels overall more like town him than scum him in my experience

If you could go anywhere else, then where would you want to go?

Besides pzelda!!

[Montmorency]

ngl I was hoping monty would keep his vote and the environment would cause people to re-ev the 2 vote wagons/pzelda

Not a spicy enough D1. 100 posts in 2.5 hours at EOD? Something's coming, I know it, or Dyach prob town.

Unless his team has decided to cut him loose without a fight, which...

fwiw I've also played with town csargo in a serious/non-gimmick game once I think?

What is a serious/non-gimmick game? Mountainous?

[Maple]

Draw your own conclusions from this graphic

spoiler:
it rhymes with Block Blear

[Visor]

wheres your head at raskol

[Cuthillius]

mascarpoooonneee

tiramisu <3

though the stuff you buy at the store has way less flavor than if you make

still tasty in caakkeee

[Raskolnikov]

Anyway I feel bad for Rask coming into this specific slot as a sub, but I don't think he's really done enough + other outstanding concerns from Amy.

Csargo probably my #2 choice, even though I still feel kinda bad about it (this has nothing to do with the case on him, I mean it's what it is, it's just because I like Csargo and don't get to play with him that often).

dya well behind the other two, I think they're close to rand at this point really and the other two have less going for them.

YOu can't really expect more from me when I sub in at 7 PM my time.

Tell me about your concern about Amy then.

[Ephemeral]

there are far better reasons to call me a wolf

if i were a wolf, i'd list them here, but as a villager i wont hattip

[Dolby]

If you could go anywhere else, then where would you want to go?

Besides pzelda!!

pzelda

I'm gonna ignore lacking people bc I'm making a decision on them soon but maybe Maple or Manasi? This isn't because I don't like them but more because I haven't seen anything I've liked from them that I remember

[Dolby]

Not a spicy enough D1. 100 posts in 2.5 hours at EOD? Something's coming, I know it, or Dyach prob town.

Unless his team has decided to cut him loose without a fight, which...



What is a serious/non-gimmick game? Mountainous?

I think Arakhor hosted it? I wanted to discount dethys from contention since I think I played one or two where he was town

[Ephemeral]

Draw your own conclusions from this graphic

spoiler:
it rhymes with Block Blear

tee hee lack claire

[Maple]

rask iso looks pretty rand to me, not soulreading any of their posts

[Arapocalypse]

My current top town are... Dolby/Sunbae/Hally? With Sunbae at the fringe and pzelda/Bop just beyond that!!

If I haven't mentioned yet, Hally's moved up a bit today, by the way!!!

[Zack]

Official Tally as of #1090

5 dyachei (Raskolnikov, Visor, Manasi, Ephemeral, Esooa)

4 Csargo (Sunbae, Arapocalypse, ColonelLubriderm, Hally)
4 Raskolnikov (pzelda, Cuthillius, GeneralHankerchief, Montmorency)

2 Esooa (Csargo, dyachei)

1 GeneralHankerchief (Maple)
1 pzelda (Dolby)

tally still the same

[Maple]

oh i thought we had another hour

lol

where we dropping lads

[GeneralHankerchief]

YOu can't really expect more from me when I sub in at 7 PM my time.

Tell me about your concern about Amy then.

I know, it's not a you thing (probably) so much as a me thing.

There was basically one interaction that Amy made with Visor early on (specifically, she dropped a way-too-early townread on him and Visor didn't really have a natural conclusion to the thought process in his response) that I thought looked suspicious from both sides but Visor later mollified me (and others) on it. Visor later made a full case, it seemed good, Sunbae chimed in with a point... around 12 hours ago? and yeah. That, plus general POE.

What were the results of the isos you did?

[Maple]

haha gh wouldnt it be funny if we cfd you? haha jk

unless?

[Arapocalypse]

Draw your own conclusions from this graphic

spoiler:
it rhymes with Block Blear

I see you stopped at top 3, don't think I missed that!!!!!

[GeneralHankerchief]

Switching to Csar at :57 if the wagons are unchanged.

[Ephemeral]

haha gh wouldnt it be funny if we cfd you? haha jk

unless?

that would be gamer.exe

[Montmorency]

Not very charitable from you Monty. Too bad I don't have time for another ISO rn, but I would CFD you just from this read list!

It's nothing personal, it's wagonomics. I want to see if there's movement. Am I wrong to do it from an objective standpoint?

Switching to Csar at :57 if the wagons are unchanged.

I'll help. Sooner.

Vote: Csargo

[Arapocalypse]

pzelda

I'm gonna ignore lacking people bc I'm making a decision on them soon but maybe Maple or Manasi? This isn't because I don't like them but more because I haven't seen anything I've liked from them that I remember

Maple I somewhat liked some earlier stuff to maybe give another day... but I probably wouldn't go overly out of my way to defend because this is a 48/24, Manti!!!

Manasi sort of shrug? I only remember she came in a bit earlier, didn't give that large of an impression/could go either way!!