Org Mobile Site
Thread: Rampage Out of Space
Originally Posted by hollowkatt:
So it sounds like you town read him?
Like anyone has "potential" to be a wolf but given how Tim treated him, the takes, and not being under threat means that he's kinda just town
Why does Dolby have more woof potential than Argon? Tims was much more heavy-handed with Dolby than he ever was with LA imo. So it sounds like you town read him?
Like anyone has "potential" to be a wolf but given how Tim treated him, the takes, and not being under threat means that he's kinda just town
Not being under threat doesn't make someone town, it's a weird argument.
I was tring him up until yesterday, but I'm obviously wrong somewhere. And the things I've stated aren't enough to remove him from the poe at this point.
Csar my top town right now.
If scum or sk, I done got me a teachin'.
If scum or sk, I done got me a teachin'.
Next I need to read Dolby.
Originally Posted by Dolby:
trust winston regardless
trust winston regardless
if csar, laurentus, hk, or pzelda is a villain, they've left it all out on the field
dream f3 = hk/dolby/argon with both scum and sk still in play
vote: Ibn-Khaldun
If Dolby is mafia I will be very surprised. The way Tim interacted and pushed them day one made me town read Dolby very hard, especially since I had n0 checked Tim as wolf. Dolby being SK and mafia possibly knowing this is not something I will take off the table. Also since I don't want to miss the chance to ask, who dou you are think I should check for being a mafia tonight before flips?
Originally Posted by BorgPicard:
If Dolby is mafia I will be very surprised. The way Tim interacted and pushed them day one made me town read Dolby very hard, especially since I had n0 checked Tim as wolf. Dolby being SK and mafia possibly knowing this is not something I will take off the table. Also since I don't want to miss the chance to ask, who dou you are think I should check for being a mafia tonight before flips?
If Dolby is mafia I will be very surprised. The way Tim interacted and pushed them day one made me town read Dolby very hard, especially since I had n0 checked Tim as wolf. Dolby being SK and mafia possibly knowing this is not something I will take off the table. Also since I don't want to miss the chance to ask, who dou you are think I should check for being a mafia tonight before flips?
Originally Posted by hollowkatt:
the obvs answer is that the active players aren't suspecting the SK of being the SK (or a wolf) whereas the low posters were, but that's also the path of wifom and ruin so eh?
I'm not sure finding the SK is super important as of yet, I'd rather find and chop wolves.
yeah I'd rather find wolves and I don't think that HK is onethe obvs answer is that the active players aren't suspecting the SK of being the SK (or a wolf) whereas the low posters were, but that's also the path of wifom and ruin so eh?
I'm not sure finding the SK is super important as of yet, I'd rather find and chop wolves.
HOST TALLY 4-2
Vroendal (4): Laurentus, Zelda, Csargo, Borg
Dolby (1): Ibn
Csargo (1): Hollow
IK (1): Winston
Not Voting (2): Dolby, Vroendal
Movement
[Zelda] Csargo >> Dolby >> Vroendal
[Hollow] Dolby >> Csargo
Vroendal (4): Laurentus, Zelda, Csargo, Borg
Dolby (1): Ibn
Csargo (1): Hollow
IK (1): Winston
Not Voting (2): Dolby, Vroendal
Movement
[Zelda] Csargo >> Dolby >> Vroendal
[Hollow] Dolby >> Csargo
Originally Posted by Dolby:
yeah I'd rather find wolves and I don't think that HK is one
hk/dolby vs ibnyeah I'd rather find wolves and I don't think that HK is one
Originally Posted by Csargo:
Why does Dolby have more woof potential than Argon? Tims was much more heavy-handed with Dolby than he ever was with LA imo.
Not being under threat doesn't make someone town, it's a weird argument.
I was tring him up until yesterday, but I'm obviously wrong somewhere. And the things I've stated aren't enough to remove him from the poe at this point.
Dolby has more wolf potential than Argon does b/c like Argon is super obvs when he's not town whereas Dolby is much harder to find in both directions. I just don't think wolf LA plays this game this way. SK LA mightWhy does Dolby have more woof potential than Argon? Tims was much more heavy-handed with Dolby than he ever was with LA imo.
Not being under threat doesn't make someone town, it's a weird argument.
I was tring him up until yesterday, but I'm obviously wrong somewhere. And the things I've stated aren't enough to remove him from the poe at this point.
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes:
if csar, laurentus, hk, or pzelda is a villain, they've left it all out on the field
vote: winston hughesif csar, laurentus, hk, or pzelda is a villain, they've left it all out on the field
Originally Posted by BorgPicard:
If Dolby is mafia I will be very surprised. The way Tim interacted and pushed them day one made me town read Dolby very hard, especially since I had n0 checked Tim as wolf. Dolby being SK and mafia possibly knowing this is not something I will take off the table. Also since I don't want to miss the chance to ask, who dou you are think I should check for being a mafia tonight before flips?
me obvsIf Dolby is mafia I will be very surprised. The way Tim interacted and pushed them day one made me town read Dolby very hard, especially since I had n0 checked Tim as wolf. Dolby being SK and mafia possibly knowing this is not something I will take off the table. Also since I don't want to miss the chance to ask, who dou you are think I should check for being a mafia tonight before flips?
Originally Posted by Ibn-Khaldun:
Others voted for Rask because "he played like this in some other game and was mafia" meta but I didn't see anything wrong with his posts. Also, it was D1 after all.
at the time he took some actions that implied his sus on Csargo was very seriousOthers voted for Rask because "he played like this in some other game and was mafia" meta but I didn't see anything wrong with his posts. Also, it was D1 after all.
which wasn't gonna fly for me 80 posts in
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes:
IK's case on Dolby seems:
i) believable, in that there is a coherent villain-hunting thought process going on
ii) plausible, in that it presents evidence that does look bad for Dolby
I can definetely be blamed for El. Honestly a lot of my reason to push him personally was connected to his read on me and his choices in rereading from D1. That said, I'd suspected Garden Gnome since D1IK's case on Dolby seems:
i) believable, in that there is a coherent villain-hunting thought process going on
ii) plausible, in that it presents evidence that does look bad for Dolby
I personally am thinking that Panda and Nanook are HK's SK kills which he's using to scumhunt. Of course, this is built mainly off my own theory of where kill three came from (SK)
Originally Posted by hollowkatt:
Sure, that makes sense. Except that we have one dead scum, no dead SK, and a shitload of dead townies. So trying to determine what wolves think of the SK and vice versa is functionally impossible. As soon as we hit another wolf it becomes a lot clearer I think.
I'm currently voting Dolby b/c of how strongly he thinks I'm SK b/c I struggle mightily to understand how he gets to that read
I think that you've been comparitively underwhelming to your normal play since mid-D2.Sure, that makes sense. Except that we have one dead scum, no dead SK, and a shitload of dead townies. So trying to determine what wolves think of the SK and vice versa is functionally impossible. As soon as we hit another wolf it becomes a lot clearer I think.
I'm currently voting Dolby b/c of how strongly he thinks I'm SK b/c I struggle mightily to understand how he gets to that read
I also think that all probable SK kills are kills that you'd make as SK.
Originally Posted by hollowkatt:
he's more active than the last time I saw him wolfing, he's actually participating in discussions and providing reads in his own LA way
yeah, thishe's more active than the last time I saw him wolfing, he's actually participating in discussions and providing reads in his own LA way
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes:
hk/dolby vs ibn
what, if anything, has ibn done that is townie?hk/dolby vs ibn
Originally Posted by Dolby:
at the time he took some actions that implied his sus on Csargo was very serious
which wasn't gonna fly for me 80 posts in
I can definetely be blamed for El. Honestly a lot of my reason to push him personally was connected to his read on me and his choices in rereading from D1. That said, I'd suspected Garden Gnome since D1
I personally am thinking that Panda and Nanook are HK's SK kills which he's using to scumhunt. Of course, this is built mainly off my own theory of where kill three came from (SK)
I think that you've been comparitively underwhelming to your normal play since mid-D2.
I also think that all probable SK kills are kills that you'd make as SK.
yeah, this
completely agree my play has been underwhelming compared to what you're used to seeingat the time he took some actions that implied his sus on Csargo was very serious
which wasn't gonna fly for me 80 posts in
I can definetely be blamed for El. Honestly a lot of my reason to push him personally was connected to his read on me and his choices in rereading from D1. That said, I'd suspected Garden Gnome since D1
I personally am thinking that Panda and Nanook are HK's SK kills which he's using to scumhunt. Of course, this is built mainly off my own theory of where kill three came from (SK)
I think that you've been comparitively underwhelming to your normal play since mid-D2.
I also think that all probable SK kills are kills that you'd make as SK.
yeah, this
The worst that I feel about Vroe is that I don't think that his reads construction after Winston being copped was good
Originally Posted by hollowkatt:
vote: winston hughes
don't touch what you can't affordvote: winston hughes
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes:
@Ibn-Khaldun
Did you play mafia here back in the noughties golden age?
From time to time. I was more involved with the Throne Room than mafia games.@Ibn-Khaldun
Did you play mafia here back in the noughties golden age?
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes:
vote: Ibn-Khaldun
vote: Ibn-Khaldun
Originally Posted by Ibn-Khaldun:
I feel like you could give more than you have.Originally Posted by Winston Hughes:
don't touch what you can't afford
I thought this was an allusion to prostitution, but apparently it's a whole sociological token.don't touch what you can't afford
Originally Posted by Ibn-Khaldun:
From time to time. I was more involved with the Throne Room than mafia games.
ibn talk to meFrom time to time. I was more involved with the Throne Room than mafia games.
who's town outside winston and pzelda
dolby's case on hk makes some sense
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes:
dolby's case on hk makes some sense
do you think as SK he kills Tims/panda/Nanook?dolby's case on hk makes some sense
Originally Posted by hollowkatt:
vote: winston hughes
hk went too far here?vote: winston hughes
Originally Posted by Winston Hughes:
hk went too far here?
yeah, probablyhk went too far here?
Originally Posted by Dolby:
do you think as SK he kills Tims/panda/Nanook?
i can't immediately think of reasons why he wouldn'tdo you think as SK he kills Tims/panda/Nanook?
Originally Posted by Dolby:
ibn talk to me
who's town outside winston and pzelda
My current list is Winston, pzelda, Czargo, Laurentus and Hollowibn talk to me
who's town outside winston and pzelda
Single Sign On provided by vBSSO