Rampage Out of Space

[Winston Hughes]

not being facetious there

genuinely looking for reasons to the contrary

[Winston Hughes]

Panda I was sus on D1 for a while, then kinda forgot about him. Have continued to forget about him today

Yeah, that's definitely a thing.

[Laurentus]

do you have time to iso gnome and tell me i'm wrong here?

Perhaps. What is the main thrust of your argument against Gnome, though? I recall the bit about how El is at least providing readable info, but it's 01:37AM over here, and my attention span is not at its best, so I don't recall the other arguments.

[Lewwyn]

@Lewwyn

Need you here now.

Who's the chop?

Ahhh I’m awake give me ten minutes to catch up on the thread.

Still high suss on gnome atm

[Csargo]

Vote:GG

[hollowkatt]

Yeah, that's definitely a thing.

Panda for SK maybe

[Winston Hughes]

Perhaps. What is the main thrust of your argument against Gnome, though? I recall the bit about how El is at least providing readable info, but it's 01:37AM over here, and my attention span is not at its best, so I don't recall the other arguments.

The case against Gnome is really just a lack of anything that looks genuinely townie.

39 posts, no discernible splash.

[Laurentus]

I don't think Laurentus is a wolf, and if he is, I think he can be found
Panda I was sus on D1 for a while, then kinda forgot about him. Have continued to forget about him today

I'm starting to sound like a broken record here, but I need your progression.

[Montmorency]

HOST TALLY 2-6

El-Ah (3): Hollow, Dolby, Laurentus
Gnome (3): Lewwyn, Winston, Csargo
Dolby (2): Nanook, Gnome
Vroendal (2): Zelda, Ibn
Nanook (1): Borg
Hollow (1): El-Ah

Not Voting (2): Vro, Panda


Movement

[Dolby] Gnome >> Unvote >> El-Ah
[El-Ah] Dolby >> Laurentus >> Dolby >> Hollow
[Holow] Vroendal >> Laurentus >> El-Ah
[Laurent] Hollow >> El-Ah
[Winston] Visor >> Gnome
[Csargo] Winston >> Gnome

[hollowkatt]

I'm starting to sound like a broken record here, but I need your progression.

That is my progression. D1, which you can find in my ISO, I thought Panda had wolf potential. Then I forgot he was playing b/c his posts aren't memorable at all.
His posts still aren't memorable.
Your posts are fine, I think you're probably town.

[Winston Hughes]

Vote:GG

The problem here is that I'm only right when nobody listens.

If y'all follow my lead, Gnome's gonna flip town.

[Vroendal]

I've lost track of what's going on in the thread to be honest. Lau seems slightly derp-cleared assuming that as a wolf he would read the wolf chat before going into the thread. Dolby's EoD felt super townie to me. I'm scum-reading GG from yesterday, her voting Dolby is noteworthy. Both Dolby and Lau are scum-reading and voting El-A. I was still semi-town-reading him based on his initial entrance and brought him down after reading Dolby's thoughts. Honestly either GG or El-A would be fine with me at this point. Would prefer GG because I'm understanding a bit more as to why she's scummy, but going with my strong player town-leans on a wagon is probably the wisest option for me at this point because I have no idea what happened this phase. I'm choosing not to vote Winston because y'all know what my stance on him is already and it doesn't look like he's any kind of option right now.

Vote - El-A

[Csargo]

in the event that I go under

I still think that LA and HK are the most likely SKs. They still look pretty good to me for not being mafia, though not top tier town.

Vroedal, Winston, Lewwyn, I think are all good

Csargo is a lower level townlean, with Pzelda

Hot takes are that I think that Panda and Ibn-K are likelier town for weak reasons

I don't get the confidence in the Vro read, after looking at those posts. They're better than I remember, but I don't think that's enough for elevating them so high. I don't understand your reasoning here.

[hollowkatt]

@Laurentus
this may help next time :D

[Lewwyn]

I'm not going to tell you I read Gnome as scum.

Right now, I don't have good reasons for reading anyone as scum.

But on balance of how much info they've given and how surprised I'd be to see them flip scum, Gnome is in the scummiest spot.

Yeah, gnome is the scumiest of everyone out here on the float IMO

[Winston Hughes]

I've lost track of what's going on in the thread to be honest. Lau seems slightly derp-cleared assuming that as a wolf he would read the wolf chat before going into the thread. Dolby's EoD felt super townie to me. I'm scum-reading GG from yesterday, her voting Dolby is noteworthy. Both Dolby and Lau are scum-reading and voting El-A. I was still semi-town-reading him based on his initial entrance and brought him down after reading Dolby's thoughts. Honestly either GG or El-A would be fine with me at this point. Would prefer GG because I'm understanding a bit more as to why she's scummy, but going with my strong player town-leans on a wagon is probably the wisest option for me at this point because I have no idea what happened this phase. I'm choosing not to vote Winston because y'all know what my stance on him is already and it doesn't look like he's any kind of option right now.

Vote - El-A

If you are scum, you have utterly defeated me.

[Winston Hughes]

Yeah, gnome is the scumiest of everyone out here on the float IMO

thoughts on the derpgate people?

[Dolby]

I don't get the confidence in the Vro read, after looking at those posts. They're better than I remember, but I don't think that's enough for elevating them so high. I don't understand your reasoning here.

The way that Tims treated him in comparison to the way he treated El is also striking.

[Laurentus]

Do you think that mafia would actually ignore you? Don't you think that you're not being NKed after getting so many green checks makes you look like scum? Your post comes across as scummy.

The very first post is already interesting. Assuming for a moment that GG is scum, then he'd know the green check on Tim was fake, and would in fact not wish to kill him. Could be playing the long game here, though.

[Csargo]

The problem here is that I'm only right when nobody listens.

If y'all follow my lead, Gnome's gonna flip town.

My problem is I couldn't tell you definitively how GG views anyone other than Dolby. It feels like most of their posts have a lack of substance.

[Dolby]

the problem for me reading the LA stuff and trying to apply to GG and IK is that I'm 95% sure that Tims told scum chat about LA's normal cop shenanigans

[Laurentus]

Maybe, but I'd rather wait until D2.

Did GG end up voting Borg? And if not, why not?

[hollowkatt]

every time Winston says "man if this is scum I just lose" I want to turbo chop him with all prejudice.

[Dolby]

borgpicard was just being ridiculous. What is your opinion?

GG said this, and also asked LA why he was voting Nanook later

[Laurentus]

You voted hollowkatt because he called you "town"?

Lack of context for this exchange. The tone sounds rather accusatory, though.

[Montmorency]

HOST TALLY 2-7

El-Ah (4): Hollow, Dolby, Laurentus, Vroendal
Gnome (3): Lewwyn, Winston, Csargo
Dolby (2): Nanook, Gnome
Vroendal (2): Zelda, Ibn
Nanook (1): Borg
Hollow (1): El-Ah

Not Voting (1): Panda


Movement

[Dolby] Gnome >> Unvote >> El-Ah
[El-Ah] Dolby >> Laurentus >> Dolby >> Hollow
[Holow] Vroendal >> Laurentus >> El-Ah
[Laurent] Hollow >> El-Ah
[Winston] Visor >> Gnome
[Csargo] Winston >> Gnome

[Winston Hughes]

every time Winston says "man if this is scum I just lose" I want to turbo chop him with all prejudice.

[hollowkatt]

anyways, legacy:
don't kill dolby, winston, pzelda fo sho

killing in gnome/panda/nook/borg/ibn is probably fine

laurentus I think is townie, same with lew and maybe csargo

[Laurentus]

every time Winston says "man if this is scum I just lose" I want to turbo chop him with all prejudice.

Lol, why, because I did it with you in the last game?

[Lewwyn]

Just to list my thoughts on Gnome:

1) pretty much on the float day 1, had a couple talking about posts, but then never voted
2) comes in Day 2 still without any reads and spends the first half the day saying they have no reads
3) gets a little pressurefrom someone else and then me
4) quickly goes full defensive as hominem attacking me and not giving any reads
5) comes back at the EOD latching onto the idea that she and I must not be w/w to claim that we are both not scum when in fact it could easily mean she is scum and tries to drop it.
6) asks a couple questions in EOD and votes Dolby on a follow up but doesn’t really post a lot about who she suspects. The Dolby vote in particular feels like a tie on

I think she floated until I put pressure, she pushed back to try and get me off her but then belatedly tried to look town with some weak questions eod when that didn’t work. Feels scummy to me.