Sufjan 10er [Game Thread]

[Totally not Taffy]

taffy seems like a villager yolo

You seem to underappreciate the RVS, and since it's late I'll plonk down a vote and go to bed.

Vote: Mischief for pulling an Abe Simpson on us.

[EnderWiggin]

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

I have been asked for cat pics and I shall deliver after all.

[EnderWiggin]

Oh hm that was smaller than I expected.

[Lantana]

Vote: Raskolnikov

[Sunbae]

thats me sneaking away to play werewolf while nobodys looking

[Sunbae]

you all have adorable cats and doggos and i am jealous cause i cant have any at my current place

Looked into getting a rabbit cause that wasnt listed but apparently they require a lot more space than I thought/have

[Lantana]

I love these emojis

[Mischief]

you all have adorable cats and doggos and i am jealous cause i cant have any at my current place

Looked into getting a rabbit cause that wasnt listed but apparently they require a lot more space than I thought/have

Well, to satisfy you until you can get one, I present my sister's bunny:

[Mischief]

Oh hm that was smaller than I expected.

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

[insomnia]

hey all

pleasure to be a guest in the ORG

sap new and old folks

[insomnia]

alr saw some posts saying spamposting here is frowned upon so i tried to read through everything and condense things in 1 post

i really don't understand visor's taffy read. i thought taffy started with a semi-awkward opening that i wouldn't really wolfread without meta, but it kept me on my toes. apparently visor had the opposite take but from his reasoning it didn't make much sense to me. gth his sunbae v read so soon might be a better look? idk them well enough to shake off my early feeling about visor

sunbae's gripes seemed ~ok, not that villagery. i wanna lean into saying experienced players picking on a detail like that is a good look ig

mischief's starting posts seemed underwhelming for them but i have no thoughts on their follow-up

das bout it

[Visor]

alr saw some posts saying spamposting here is frowned upon so i tried to read through everything and condense things in 1 post

i really don't understand visor's taffy read. i thought taffy started with a semi-awkward opening that i wouldn't really wolfread without meta, but it kept me on my toes. apparently visor had the opposite take but from his reasoning it didn't make much sense to me. gth his sunbae v read so soon might be a better look? idk them well enough to shake off my early feeling about visor

sunbae's gripes seemed ~ok, not that villagery. i wanna lean into saying experienced players picking on a detail like that is a good look ig

mischief's starting posts seemed underwhelming for them but i have no thoughts on their follow-up

das bout it

it was just a lazy early read because they were posting a bunch and didnt seem concerned about posting game content

(but i think its probably a silly read, i kinda just made it to try and spark something in the game)

[insomnia]

it was just a lazy early read because they were posting a bunch and didnt seem concerned about posting game content

(but i think its probably a silly read, i kinda just made it to try and spark something in the game)

gotcha, but i don't get the feel they were really posting game content?

[Visor]

gotcha, but i don't get the feel they were really posting game content?

... i didnt say they were posting game content, i said tehy didnt seem concerned (about having to) post game content

they were absolutely not posting game content - which i mention later in the thread anyway?

[Visor]

let me try to reduce this to the simplest arguments

a) i thought the fact they didnt seem to really care about making game related posts (and didnt really make any, just a RVS post) was a minor village note for a newer player

b) i thought by making this village read on them, that if they were a villager, they may take heart and be more willing to engage in the game/solving

[Sunbae]

alr saw some posts saying spamposting here is frowned upon so i tried to read through everything and condense things in 1 post

i really don't understand visor's taffy read. i thought taffy started with a semi-awkward opening that i wouldn't really wolfread without meta, but it kept me on my toes. apparently visor had the opposite take but from his reasoning it didn't make much sense to me. gth his sunbae v read so soon might be a better look? idk them well enough to shake off my early feeling about visor

sunbae's gripes seemed ~ok, not that villagery. i wanna lean into saying experienced players picking on a detail like that is a good look ig

mischief's starting posts seemed underwhelming for them but i have no thoughts on their follow-up

das bout it

Visor's quick v read on me has some fun meta where I expect him to get there on me relatively quickly and he knows I expect him to get there on me relatively quickly. I didn't put much thought to it alignment wise and don't think anyone else should either. What I did think was alignment indicative a bit was the lack of any comments about you after this exchange you two had. Pretty easy spot for wolfVisor to diffuse and then begin pocketing you with a town read or for wolfVisor to start shading you for not getting it, but instead just kinda diffused and shrugged and moved on.

[Visor]

alr saw some posts saying spamposting here is frowned upon so i tried to read through everything and condense things in 1 post

i really don't understand visor's taffy read. i thought taffy started with a semi-awkward opening that i wouldn't really wolfread without meta, but it kept me on my toes. apparently visor had the opposite take but from his reasoning it didn't make much sense to me. gth his sunbae v read so soon might be a better look? idk them well enough to shake off my early feeling about visor

sunbae's gripes seemed ~ok, not that villagery. i wanna lean into saying experienced players picking on a detail like that is a good look ig

mischief's starting posts seemed underwhelming for them but i have no thoughts on their follow-up

das bout it

its interesting in hindsight that this is all negative takes on people

like he has no indications of villageriness, certainly not actively trying to village read anyone

[Mischief]

You seem to underappreciate the RVS, and since it's late I'll plonk down a vote and go to bed.

Vote: Mischief for pulling an Abe Simpson on us.

I was hungry.
I got Raising Cane's, then a friend talked my ear off for hours about Star Wars and 18th century politics.
Though what you said is true, so I'm not going to contest it.

[Totally not Taffy]

Ok having all of my 's changed into ?s and not getting to edit sucks.

I was hungry.
I got Raising Cane's, then a friend talked my ear off for hours about Star Wars and 18th century politics.
Though what you said is true, so I'm not going to contest it.

At first I liked this response and then paranoia kicked in and said "but what if it's a really good wolf who knows how to respond to early sussing in a way that seems sincere?". I come to the conclusion that playing with people I don't know is hard.

I was planning on heading out, but I figured I'd post here first, so people know that I haven't forgotten about this game altogether, being my first game on this site.
A little assurance that I won't be 0-poster.

Yes, this makes perfect sense. What made me vote for you was that coming in just to show presence when you know you're going to leave right after and without actually interacting gives the impression that you feel under pressure to show up. Being new to the site would do that (hello!).

Can I just Unvote: Mischief or do I need to immediately vote someone else?

[Mischief]

Ok having all of my 's changed into ?s and not getting to edit sucks.




At first I liked this response and then paranoia kicked in and said "but what if it's a really good wolf who knows how to respond to early sussing in a way that seems sincere?". I come to the conclusion that playing with people I don't know is hard.



Yes, this makes perfect sense. What made me vote for you was that coming in just to show presence when you know you're going to leave right after and without actually interacting gives the impression that you feel under pressure to show up. Being new to the site would do that (hello!).

Can I just Unvote: Mischief or do I need to immediately vote someone else?

I could understand why someone would be paranoid of that, so I didn't think it was suspicious to vote there.
I never mind all that much votes that seem to come from an understandable perspective since I assume they will get more of a feel for things as time progresses.
Also, hi

[Lantana]

Dya's posts don't do anything for me either way

Who made the 'walks and talks' like a villa read and wants to educate me?

[Lantana]

Vote: Ephemeral

I don't really want to kill visor today; insomnia I was fine with him (by extension raskolnikov saying I was shading insomnia is not nya).
lemme order my reads

[Sunbae]

Vote: Ephemeral

I don't really want to kill visor today; insomnia I was fine with him (by extension raskolnikov saying I was shading insomnia is not nya).
lemme order my reads

Can you talk a bit about Insomnia?

[Lantana]

I think if Rask w then Insomnia v for the phrasing of MY phrasing to insomnia earlier.
For those not aware of what i'm referring to, insomnia asked me a very weighted question from my point of view, I asked why he did so, and Rask thought my weighted question (whilst answering insomnia's weighted question) was noteworthy. I think i'd see that more from a wolf wanting to cause villager villager violence in general than a villager tuning into a random conversation.
As for what that means for Insom's alignment if Rask is indeed a wolf the same would probably apply (Insom v). Although I say that not having thought of what a wolf alternative would look like #yolo

[Raskolnikov]

I think if Rask w then Insomnia v for the phrasing of MY phrasing to insomnia earlier.
For those not aware of what i'm referring to, insomnia asked me a very weighted question from my point of view, I asked why he did so, and Rask thought my weighted question (whilst answering insomnia's weighted question) was noteworthy. I think i'd see that more from a wolf wanting to cause villager villager violence in general than a villager tuning into a random conversation.
As for what that means for Insom's alignment if Rask is indeed a wolf the same would probably apply (Insom v). Although I say that not having thought of what a wolf alternative would look like #yolo

relax, I am a villager. What does it change for you?

also pov: could you rephrase why you thought he was asking you a "very weighted question"?

[EnderWiggin]

Dya's posts don't do anything for me either way

Who made the 'walks and talks' like a villa read and wants to educate me?

That was me.

Dya not only made a legitimate meta read based on a recent game (Raskol read) but also made a read on Visor that I felt legit about, both of those felt like good starts compared to other reads in the game and their gamestate makes sense for how they sort.

I don't think I'd want to visit voting there today. Usually as wolf they eventually feel opportunistic in their play, and more thought goes into their reads as v. Not a hard polarisation but definitely a trend.

[insomnia]

You seem to underappreciate the RVS, and since it's late I'll plonk down a vote and go to bed.

Vote: Mischief for pulling an Abe Simpson on us.

hrm this is a minor good look. fluffing into plopping a vote like this feels like a fine enough progression