Sufjan 10er [Game Thread]

[Raskolnikov]

POE talks D1 are bad because they generally come from wolves struggling to fake cases or escape TMI, so I guess I will reread this slot (is it insomnia or Mischief?)

[Raskolnikov]

(not to say I am convinced by your case or your ISO tbh, but there are too many people gearing up for my ML for me not to take a closer look lol)

[Mischief]

POE talks D1 are bad because they generally come from wolves struggling to fake cases or escape TMI, so I guess I will reread this slot (is it insomnia or Mischief?)

I think it's rather absurd that you claim POE talks D1 are bad.
I know Dya, Sunbae, Visor, Insomnia, and to a lesser extent Ephemera.
Logically, I need to find wolves, and if I can't immediately figure out wolves, I'll figure out villagers, and from that pool of villagers, remove them from the pool of suspects, and find the wolves within that POE.
The fact you take issue with it sounds like you have a problem with D1 solving, which is your problem, not mine.
​Vote: Raskolnikov

[Ephemeral]

I think it's rather absurd that you claim POE talks D1 are bad.
I know Dya, Sunbae, Visor, Insomnia, and to a lesser extent Ephemera.
Logically, I need to find wolves, and if I can't immediately figure out wolves, I'll figure out villagers, and from that pool of villagers, remove them from the pool of suspects, and find the wolves within that POE.
The fact you take issue with it sounds like you have a problem with D1 solving, which is your problem, not mine.
​Vote: Raskolnikov

Ephemera and me are different people btw

[Mischief]

Ephemera and me are different people btw

Oh, shit, I was confusing you two.
RIP

[Ephemeral]

Oh, shit, I was confusing you two.
RIP

that's a classic

[Visor]

Hello

[Raskolnikov]

I think it's rather absurd that you claim POE talks D1 are bad.
I know Dya, Sunbae, Visor, Insomnia, and to a lesser extent Ephemera.
Logically, I need to find wolves, and if I can't immediately figure out wolves, I'll figure out villagers, and from that pool of villagers, remove them from the pool of suspects, and find the wolves within that POE.
The fact you take issue with it sounds like you have a problem with D1 solving, which is your problem, not mine.
​Vote: Raskolnikov

I don't take issue specifically about it. I think your turnaround was weird and POE reads D1 is just a fairly common place to hide for wolves

I don't have a problem with D1 solving.

I have no problem rn.

lol this post. jeebus

[Mischief]

I don't take issue specifically about it. I think your turnaround was weird and POE reads D1 is just a fairly common place to hide for wolves

I don't have a problem with D1 solving.

I have no problem rn.

lol this post. jeebus

If you have no problem with D1 solving, then please, explain what the problem is with having a POE.

[Raskolnikov]

If you have no problem with D1 solving, then please, explain what the problem is with having a POE.

I think I made that clear in the post you quoted, but oh well.

what I find weird about your slot is the conjunction of the turnaround on Visor AND the lack of wolf reads.


POE is fine globally, but D1 is the moment of the game wolves don't have anything to go by and when it's harder for them to fake solve. (later they have flips and other people cases to chat about and build on)
So it's not uncommon to catch a wolf spamming TRs or nulls D1 and working by POE (because that's easier to fake lol).


also Dya meant I am polarised ;)

[dyachei]

I think I made that clear in the post you quoted, but oh well.

what I find weird about your slot is the conjunction of the turnaround on Visor AND the lack of wolf reads.


POE is fine globally, but D1 is the moment of the game wolves don't have anything to go by and when it's harder for them to fake solve. (later they have flips and other people cases to chat about and build on)
So it's not uncommon to catch a wolf spamming TRs or nulls D1 and working by POE (because that's easier to fake lol).


also Dya meant I am polarised ;)

idk about that. I dont remember your village game so much as I remember how out of sync you were (before the thing happened) in our wolf game.

[Raskolnikov]

idk about that. I dont remember your village game so much as I remember how out of sync you were (before the thing happened) in our wolf game.

lol (I am tempted to put this in my sig post game <3)

(fwiw I was totally out of sync regarding the mech stuff, not the thread stuff. I hope. maybe. )

Spoiler Alert, click show to read: 

(fwiw, we swept )

[Mischief]

I think I made that clear in the post you quoted, but oh well.

what I find weird about your slot is the conjunction of the turnaround on Visor AND the lack of wolf reads.


POE is fine globally, but D1 is the moment of the game wolves don't have anything to go by and when it's harder for them to fake solve. (later they have flips and other people cases to chat about and build on)
So it's not uncommon to catch a wolf spamming TRs or nulls D1 and working by POE (because that's easier to fake lol).


also Dya meant I am polarised ;)

Sure, I won't disagree that it's easier to fake, but process of elimination is a basic tool that is central to the game, regardless of what day in the game it is.
Further, if the implication is that on D1 there's not enough information for a POE, that would be strange, because a lack of information is perhaps all the more reason TO have form a POE.
If I have people that I'm able to V read, it makes sense that I exclude them.
If there's nothing enormously damning being posted by those I can't get a proper fix on, it makes sense to have them in my POE.
I don't have any issue with someone saying that POEs can be faked, or that they disagree with my conclusions (provided they add why they disagree), but I do take issue with the claim that POE being used on D1 is inherently wrong, bad, or dumb.
It's just a means to narrow down who my suspects are and figure out wolves, and whatever means I have to sort through however much or little content there is from each player and solve the game, I will use.