Casual 9er Game Thread

[Hally]

I think it's weird to jump in like that, yeah but I don't think it's anything large enough to overwrite any other opinions

i mean, i was thinking wolves would leave rask alive and i would have to spend 48 hours trying to fend off his tunnel to the point where i was trying to mentally prepare myself not to get too annoyed at him so lol

[Sunbae]

i mean, i was thinking wolves would leave rask alive and i would have to spend 48 hours trying to fend off his tunnel to the point where i was trying to mentally prepare myself not to get too annoyed at him so lol

Can you tell me why you were so certain they were a villager? I know I was skeptical at points yesterday, especially once I thought Vulgard was a wolf and you two weren't w/w with the way they came at you while the wagons were you/vulgard.

[Sunbae]

Vote: Mont

I might be a sucker but Hally's insistence that they were going to have to fend off rask for 48 hours and that they have no idea why they aren't an obvious villager is getting me.

If hally's a villager I think mont's approach to yesterdays eod knowing vulgard is going over is just trying to accrue credit and set up the villa thunderdome between me/hally the next day

[Hally]

Vote: Mont

I might be a sucker but Hally's insistence that they were going to have to fend off rask for 48 hours and that they have no idea why they aren't an obvious villager is getting me.

If hally's a villager I think mont's approach to yesterdays eod knowing vulgard is going over is just trying to accrue credit and set up the villa thunderdome between me/hally the next day

to clarify i don’t think i should be an obvious villager per se

i think it’s reasonable to have some doubts on me, i just think the amount of suspicion i’ve received has been wildly out of proportion relative to the quality of my play

[Sunbae]

Vote: Mont

I might be a sucker but Hally's insistence that they were going to have to fend off rask for 48 hours and that they have no idea why they aren't an obvious villager is getting me.

If hally's a villager I think mont's approach to yesterdays eod knowing vulgard is going over is just trying to accrue credit and set up the villa thunderdome between me/hally the next day

[Hally]

Can you tell me why you were so certain they were a villager? I know I was skeptical at points yesterday, especially once I thought Vulgard was a wolf and you two weren't w/w with the way they came at you while the wagons were you/vulgard.

what about that post suggests i was so certain?

i did think rask was probably a villager (and i even thought that before vul’s flip though i had reservations)

it wasn’t a LOCK CLEAR read but yea, i thought he was v

[nebjiamn]

Not caught up nor available now but dislike Hallys incoming NKA including the post about it looking good for barto

doesn?t feel sincere but I?ll preface with the fact I?ve literally read ~10 posts so far

just a gut reaction

[Hally]

if we’re making “i would always kill X if i was a wolf” arguments, i would always kill sunbae

he was my main pusher D1 besides rask and although he did waver on it late D1 w!me wouldn’t risk him coming back to the read

i would much rather try my luck with rask tunneling me because he had less thread pull particularly with zack/benneh and i don’t think he was as town read

[Hally]

Not caught up nor available now but dislike Hallys incoming NKA including the post about it looking good for barto

doesn?t feel sincere but I?ll preface with the fact I?ve literally read ~10 posts so far

just a gut reaction

thread don’t wolf read completely normal hally posts challenge (impossible)

[EnderWiggin]

If we're self nka'ing I never kill Rask because I want to pocket him

[EnderWiggin]

thread don’t wolf read completely normal hally posts challenge (impossible)

God damn this post is wolfy.

[Sunbae]

God damn this post is wolfy.

I think I've decided that I'm just going to ignore the n1 kill and subsequent responses wrt Hally's alignment and make my decision elsewhere. I think Hally's responses at the start of today are weird, but I've been trying to swap pov's and ask "is this how I respond when I kill someone that's been tunneling me and try to get out in front of it" as well as "is this how I respond as town when someone that tunneled me died and I have no idea why and just kind of panic about it being a frame job". I can see both and, frankly, this is just the levely portion that I think just gets me in trouble more often than I'd prefer.

I'm going to take a step back and ask myself "is hally trying to solve peoples alignments or not" That's it. It's simple and it doesn't need to be more complicated. Does Hally give a damn about being correct or is it just words for the sake of words.

I currently think the answer is "I think so"? They've clearly spent a lot of time on me and gone back and forth on the answer there. They've gone back and forth with Vulgard. They've poked at Barto, talked about Rask, and came into today skeptical about Neb (side note: I'd like to hear more about that wolf read). I also think they've been more proactive than reactive wrt poking/prodding in different directions and seem to be coming up with their own thoughts rather than piggybacking others.

I'm not locked in there and I know I'll disappointedCelticsFandotjpg myself if I get away from there again and end up being wrong, but right this second that's where my head is at.

[Hally]

God damn this post is wolfy.

(i’m pretty sure this post is a joke about people wolf reading my posts not a serious wolf read, sunbae)

[Sunbae]

what about that post suggests i was so certain?

i did think rask was probably a villager (and i even thought that before vul?s flip though i had reservations)

it wasn?t a LOCK CLEAR read but yea, i thought he was v

The part where you specifically say you thought overnight that the wolves were going to leave Rask alive to the degree that you were mentally preparing yourself to be tunneled for 48 hours?

[Hally]

The part where you specifically say you thought overnight that the wolves were going to leave Rask alive to the degree that you were mentally preparing yourself to be tunneled for 48 hours?

but wolves can’t NK themselves so he would be alive regardless of whether he’s a villager who wolves leave alive to tunnel me or a wolf who’s decided to hard push me, and it would be annoying either way

me mentally preparing myself to be annoyed at him has nothing to do with his alignment (though again, i thought he was a villager during the night)

the point is i really didn’t expect him to die

[Sunbae]

but wolves can’t NK themselves so he would be alive regardless of whether he’s a villager who wolves leave alive to tunnel me or a wolf who’s decided to hard push me, and it would be annoying either way

me mentally preparing myself to be annoyed at him has nothing to do with his alignment (though again, i thought he was a villager during the night)

the point is i really didn’t expect him to die

Ok, I understand. I was squinting at whether it was a slip but I don't think it is. Your answer makes sense. I know I've pestered you a lot this game, just trying to do my best. I know it can't be pleasant to be on the receiving end of when it's like every post you make gets scrutinized.

[Hally]

Ok, I understand. I was squinting at whether it was a slip but I don't think it is. Your answer makes sense. I know I've pestered you a lot this game, just trying to do my best. I know it can't be pleasant to be on the receiving end of when it's like every post you make gets scrutinized.

it is a bit annoying (not just from you, i’ve been getting it from everyone) but it’s a mafia game, i get it lol

[Sunbae]

Neb, can you explain what made you think we were wrong near eod yesterday? I'm assuming it was some eod vibes but sometimes those are harder to pick up on reading them overnight compared to being there in real time.

[nebjiamn]

Neb, can you explain what made you think we were wrong near eod yesterday? I'm assuming it was some eod vibes but sometimes those are harder to pick up on reading them overnight compared to being there in real time.

game just felt static. dadv basically. i felt good about vulgard for a while but as we approached eod i realized there was no friction in the game which meant if he had a partner they'd given up on him long ago and that just didn't feel right?

ngl, part of it was also just me memeing to myself that i was creature and being doom and gloom, but it was also a genuine thought i had

[Hally]

game just felt static. dadv basically. i felt good about vulgard for a while but as we approached eod i realized there was no friction in the game which meant if he had a partner they'd given up on him long ago and that just didn't feel right?

ngl, part of it was also just me memeing to myself that i was creature and being doom and gloom, but it was also a genuine thought i had

lol?d

[Zack]

vote: monty

[Hally]

what’s monty’s wolf game like?
@Montmorency can you link me one?

[Visor]

Players Votes

Montmorency 2 (Sunbae, Zack)
Zack 1 (EnderWiggin)
Sunbae 1 (Montmorency)

[nebjiamn]

morning

catching up now. fyi today is wife's bday so prob not much from me after this iniital burst til tomorrow morning

[Zack]

i mean, i was thinking wolves would leave rask alive and i would have to spend 48 hours trying to fend off his tunnel to the point where i was trying to mentally prepare myself not to get too annoyed at him so lol

you were that confident he was v?