Casual december game

[Boquise]

my town consist of
ender, vulgard, hk, monty, csargo

i think the way ladd talked to me about kage is not the way you talk about a wolf partner. It was wishy-washy in hindsight and I am reading it as ladd endorsing my wagon on Kage tbh

i am left with renata, dya, amy, taffy
i think renata and taffy have been sounding townie in some posts fwiw
since csargo is in monty's poe, i just wanna say that i think he and renata are not scum together due to how they have posted towards each other today, and how renata rejected my town read of him.

also i am mulling over how i should conclude
1. players coming to renata's rescue when i tried to put light on pizza's sus on her. Does that thread spew her town?
2. renata objecting hard to Amy/Dya being paired. Does that pair or unpair her with them?

so many questions and the clock already passed midnight

[Renata]

I thought you already decided that I'm hard paired with both of them. Doesn't seem like there's much for you to mull over unless you're reconsidering, and this post doesn't suggest anything like that.

[Boquise]

interesting that both renata and taffy vote dya at this point (or well taffy doesnt have much choice tbh)..
mmm

[hollowkatt]

"Get in the death bucket" might be the most towny thing I've seen you say. It's real though. I read your posts and saw you got to Ladd's death only after responding to other things, then say something like "oh wow well lookie at that" and that's always going to read sus to me. Fake surprise. Like, you had seen Vulgard's posts at that point. Most people would scroll ahead to see who got got (if anyone) before continuing with commentary that might be irrelevant.

I get what you're trying to say but here's what I said when I got to that point:

if ender is town, i think ladd could be scum, regardless of my own read of ladd. Because if Ender is town, ladd has strictly pushed only townies. This would mean that Amy is town too

Ladd has been killed! He flips mafia goon.

You may proceed.

@Csargo, @hollowkatt, @Montmorency, @Ampharos, @dyachei, @EnderWiggin, @ladd, @Vulgard, @Boquise, @Renata, @Totally not Taffy, @Kagemusha

swag helluva shot vulgard

I'm not sure what response you're looking for there from me? Also why scroll ahead when the immediate reactions to the action being triggered are possibly important?

[Boquise]

I thought you already decided that I'm hard paired with both of them. Doesn't seem like there's much for you to mull over unless you're reconsidering, and this post doesn't suggest anything like that.

No, I have gone back and forth on it
seems like we are reading two different posts if you genuinely think that post doesn't suggest any sort of reconsideration

[hollowkatt]

This is practically OGI, but looking at dya's contradiction-posts on ladd again



If dya and taffy share a scumchat, would dya be referring to taffy as "he" in-thread D2?

I wouldn't read into that at all

[Montmorency]

You should not read into that. I have other accounts with male names, and Dyachei is an MU mod.

OK.

Boquise please don't EOD snipe, however you vote

I assume dya hasn't shown up today as antispew.

[Boquise]

Vote Dya

[hollowkatt]

That would make it more likely there's a wolf in the bottom group.

the bottom group of your original post? (boq, kage, amy) or the bottom group removing ender (renata/dya/csargo)?

[Boquise]

OK.

Boquise please don't EOD snipe, however you vote

I assume dya hasn't shown up today as antispew.

eod is at 01:00 for me and i go up at 5
so nah tbh

[Renata]

interesting that both renata and taffy vote dya at this point (or well taffy doesnt have much choice tbh)..
mmm

Interesting (TM) that you undermine your own shade immediately upon saying it, but you still think it's necessary to say.

[hollowkatt]

He didn't do that with anyone but known townies, namely Cape and Vulgard, and maybe a little bit of Logic late D1. Otherwise, see the Assoc sheet, it's basically just brief comments.

yeah. reading ladd for spew is hard. I think you did well with what you cobbled together though and as we move forward I think it'll become more relevant, just gotta have more bodies

[Renata]

I get what you're trying to say but here's what I said when I got to that point:



I'm not sure what response you're looking for there from me? Also why scroll ahead when the immediate reactions to the action being triggered are possibly important?

Nothing anymore. You're probably just town and I'm a dumb-ass.

[Boquise]

Interesting (TM) that you undermine your own shade immediately upon saying it, but you still think it's necessary to say.

i do not care about undermining my own thoughts since they are fluid and can change between 2 posts or even within 1 post and i dont care about appearing "townie" in a thread tbh

[Boquise]

i deserve cake if dya and amy are the same alignment tho tbh

[Boquise]

renata, why is it that you are focusing on my low-hanging fruit posts and not the posts where i have answered your questions and critique tbh?

[Totally not Taffy]

my town consist of
ender, vulgard, hk, monty, csargo

i think the way ladd talked to me about kage is not the way you talk about a wolf partner. It was wishy-washy in hindsight and I am reading it as ladd endorsing my wagon on Kage tbh

i am left with renata, dya, amy, taffy
i think renata and taffy have been sounding townie in some posts fwiw
since csargo is in monty's poe, i just wanna say that i think he and renata are not scum together due to how they have posted towards each other today, and how renata rejected my town read of him.

also i am mulling over how i should conclude
1. players coming to renata's rescue when i tried to put light on pizza's sus on her. Does that thread spew her town?
2. renata objecting hard to Amy/Dya being paired. Does that pair or unpair her with them?

so many questions and the clock already passed midnight

1 not if he later changed that read like people suggested
2 neither, there are too many people objecting to your pairing for it to be meaningful

What was your opinion on Csargo's case on Renata?

[Totally not Taffy]

the bottom group of your original post? (boq, kage, amy) or the bottom group removing ender (renata/dya/csargo)?

If the people I'm looking at for scum are Ender/Renata/Dyachei/Csargo and I remove Ender the rest needs to be the exact scumteam or I'm misclearing others. My money's on the latter because otherwise it seems too simple.

[Renata]

Town

Cape
Hollowkatt
Ampharos

Little Bit Towny

Mont
Visor
Blade

Meh

Sorta Wolfy

Taffy

Quite Wolfy

Logic
Pizza
Vulgard

I have read all the posts, these are my reads. Goodbye.

I've never having enough time to do a proper ISO of Taffy today, but reading anyway.

First thing that stands out is this read which is dead opposite of my own at this point and I wish I knew what they were thinking.

[Boquise]

1 not if he later changed that read like people suggested
2 neither, there are too many people objecting to your pairing for it to be meaningful

What was your opinion on Csargo's case on Renata?

he did, but the point was how the thread reacted to someone sussing a player who is at the top of town reads tbh
yeh but they were one of the first and rejected hardest tbh. But oh well, I will leave that point then.


i dont know if i agree with the case, but i think csargo is townie for the case tbh

[Renata]

I find this post important.

I'm not sure what alignment it points taffy towards, but I strongly think this will be clearing or damning in the future

This amuses me. In the linked post was shade on me (drawing attention to the fact I hadn't posted yet) and a bare town read on Boquise.

Do with that what you will.

[Totally not Taffy]

This amuses me. In the linked post was shade on me (drawing attention to the fact I hadn't posted yet) and a bare town read on Boquise.

Do with that what you will.

I think Logic's comment might have had more to do with what I said about him being either town or hard bussed.

[Renata]

Are there other players in this game who you think should know about Visor being good at reading you?

Taffy, what were you thinking when you asked this question?

[Totally not Taffy]

Taffy, what were you thinking when you asked this question?

That Logic's reasoning on why Visor misreading him was a bad look for Visor was only valid if there were no other players in the game who could catch him that way.

[Renata]

Is this based on more than that he's putting you as a top town and you feel you haven't earned that spot yet so he must have tmi?

Vote: Logic

three-way tie

Wait, WHAT?

Taffy's one and only post having to do with Logic's actual alignment is that he looks like a towny. What is this and why. Please answer.

Also never at least to this point answered a very very good question from Logic about who, if he's being bussed (as Taffy suggested was one of the options, with the other being that he is just town), are his partners. Can't exactly go back and demand a response on that one at this point, just noted.

[Renata]

Ender (4): Ladd, Csargo, dyachei, Logic
Ampharos (4): Boquise, Visor, Renata, Montmo
Logic (4): Amy, Ender, Vulgard, Taffy
Luv2spooge (1): HK
Renata (1): Kagemusha
Ladd (1): luv2spooge

EOD in 8 minutes.

This was vote count after Taffy's vote. Why logic over Ender and Amy.

[Totally not Taffy]

Wait, WHAT?

Taffy's one and only post having to do with Logic's actual alignment is that he looks like a towny. What is this and why. Please answer.

Also never at least to this point answered a very very good question from Logic about who, if he's being bussed (as Taffy suggested was one of the options, with the other being that he is just town), are his partners. Can't exactly go back and demand a response on that one at this point, just noted.

That top post is a question from me to HK asking about why HK was scumreading Spooge.

[Raskolnikov]

Dya (5): Vulgard, Renata, Taffy, HK, Boquise
Taffy (3): Monty, Csargo, Ender
Kage (1): Amy
HK (1): Kagemusha

EOD in 15 minutes

[Renata]

That's EoD1, it's as far as I can get.

[Totally not Taffy]

That top post is a question from me to HK asking about why HK was scumreading Spooge.

And I made several actual posts about Logic's alignment.