Quote Originally Posted by Cuthillius View Post
you said above this that you were thinking katze was likely w

you think that sk is >>rand v because you don't think wolves would let w!sk rand over visor there-- why do you think it's unlikely that wolves wouldn't all want to be on visor over sk there, especially given how close the votes were?
that's exactly my point: if i take achro as town (and i'm quite prepared to lose the game rather than think he's played this way as scum), then there cannot be all of the wolves on that wagon

Quote Originally Posted by Cuthillius View Post
also, where's your read at on sk's slot overall? the first time you mentioned him was at eod1 where you explicitly said that you didn't want to vote him, then next on d2 when you said that you had had some light v ping from him but couldn't remember what, and then you read and said that his progression was believable so he's slight v, and that's basically it going into today where you're claiming he's a strong v read based on wagons. what's your take on benneh's argument to the contrary? do you think they could be wolves together?
i think if sk is scum, he's done a very good job of looking townie from my perspective

i am also pretty much entirely just ignoring all of the associative/positional shit that happened before today unless it's incredibly solid (like the actual shake-down of votes at eod yesterday) as i'm sure you can justify literally any set of reads off it at this point

as for benneh's argument, could you please spell it out in your own words as you understand it?